Articles Blog

Peters punts on Pelosi (The Michigan View.com 11.12.10)

Posted by hpayne on November 12, 2010

Rep. Gary Peters, D-Bloomfield Township, ran away from Speaker Nancy Pelosi in his 2010 re-election campaign. Despite voting with the San Francisco Democrat’s radical agenda 95 percent of the time — including support for a massive, budget-busting stimulus bill and the anti-small business Obamacare — Peters championed himself a “blue dog,” budget-cutting, pro-small business independent Democrat who expressed “frustration. . . with Democratic leadership.”

The tactic worked: Peters was a rare Democratic survivor of the Republican tsunami that swept the country on Election Day.

In the wake of that debacle, Pelosi shocked Washington by announcing she would run again for her party’s congressional leadership post. Independent, Blue Dog Democrats have reacted with revulsion, speaking out publicly against the House leader who is synonymous with Washington extremism. “At least 15 Democrats have said publicly that they have lost faith in her ability to lead,” reports Politico on the Blue Dog insurrection. “Even the New York Times’ editorial page has called on Pelosi to step aside.”

Rep. Peters, however, has been nowhere to be found. He has avoided press inquiries and not taken a stand on the controversial Pelosi leadership issue.

Until today. In a contentious interview on the Frank Beckmann Show Friday morning, the independent, leadership-frustrated, anti-spending Peters told Beckmann that on the matter of Speaker Pelosi’s re-election he. . . “will wait to see what happens when I get (back to Washington). That’s just insider politics.”

With the campaign behind him, “Blue Dog” Peters true “Beige Dog” colors are coming out again. While sources say he is privately not as supportive of Pelosi as Michigan congressmen like Sander Levin and John Dingell who represent more liberal districts, Peters’ public silence speaks volumes. Still an insecure, second-term junior member of Congress, Peters cannot afford to cross his potential party leader.

The candidate who ran as the bold defender of small business and the enemy of Big Special Interests, can no longer afford to publicly cross the most anti-small business, pro-Big Special Interest speaker in modern Congressional history. “We’ll see who’s running,” he told Beckmann. “We’ll wait and see who’s there.”

By contrast, across the border in Ohio, Democratic Rep. Tim Ryan, told the Youngstown Business Journal he’s not sure Pelosi’s the right choice. “She’s obviously in charge so she needs to take the brunt of the responsibility for (the election),” he said. “I was brought up to be loyal to people who helped you and I want to be — but at the expense of what?”

Inside politics? Pelosi’s leadership was a core issue of the fall election.

On another sore point, Beckmann pressed Peters on the gutter campaign the Democrat employed against GOP opponent Rocky Raczkowski. Peters ran the nastiest congressional campaign in the state, tarring the Republican with personal attacks so vile that Rocky has filed a lawsuit against Peters. But Peters also pushed the fiction that Raczkowski wanted to raise taxes by 23 percent. The ad campaign — an attack on tax reform eliminating the income tax in favor of a national sales tax supported by Rocky and other Republicans — was so misleading that independent watch dog groups denounced it and many Democrats removed it from the air.

But not the 9th district incumbent. “Any regrets?” asked Beckmann about the ad. “Did it hurt your credibility?”

Peters was unrepentant. But when Beckmann asked again, Peters seemed to suggest that the political ends justified the means. “In 30 seconds,” he said, referring to the ad spot’s running time, “what can you do? That’s nothing new in politics. You focus on those areas that benefit you.”

Peters words would come back to haunt him moments later.

Discussing the Obama deficit commission’s proposal to raise taxes as well as cut spending to address a record, $1.3 trillion deficit (created by Peters’ and Pelosi’s spending binge), Peters allowed how tax increases were necessary. “If you’re going to bring it down, no one area is enough,” he said urging a mix of tax hikes and spending cuts.

Beckmann took the opening and pressed Peters on whether the “pro-small business” pol was advocating tax hikes. “You talked about an ad that only talked about one side of the story? You can’t have one side of the story,” said Peters referring to his own one-sided ad.

Responsible leadership means not giving one side of the story – unless you need to win an election.

Chrysler’s Small-Car Savior Wants to Build . . . Fiat SUVs! (National Review 11.10.10)

Posted by hpayne on November 10, 2010

Fiat CEO Sergio Marchionne has gone native.

Brought to the United States by President Obama a year ago to teach the planet-killers at Chrysler how to make fuel-efficient econoboxes like the ones that proper Europeans drive, the refined Italian executive has fallen in love with big, money-making American SUVs. In an announcement that shook the auto world this week, Sergio announced that he wants Chrysler to help make . . . Alfa Romeo and Maserati SUVs.

Mama Mia! Just wait until Papa Obama gets back from Asia!

On the condition that Fiat would build a 40-mpg car — the Fiat 500 — in the colonies, President Obama agreed to hand over Chrysler for free to the Turin-based automaker in April 2009. “At long last we might finally see some small, fuel-efficient cars from an automaker that milked the SUVcash cow until long after it ran dry,” cheered the snobs at Wired magazine.

But a funny thing happened on the way to converting the savages to the Green faith: Fiat starting making green in the U.S. market. Not tree-hugging green — but the kind of green that comes from selling the old-fashioned, iconic Jeep Grand Cherokee SUV.

Thanks to Americans’ renewed love affair with light trucks — the cuddly giants made up 53 percent of market sales in October compared to just 47 percent for cars — Chrysler’s third-quarter earnings soared. While Washington is forcing Detroit to make small electric cars consumers don’t want, America’s lust for SUVs may rescue the recently bankrupt companies.

Profits on SUVs dwarf those on small cars. Indeed, says Jesse Toprak, auto analyst with TrueCar.com, the Mexican-made Fiat 500 may just break even for Chrysler while the Detroit-manufactured Grand Cherokee is raking in between $3,000 to $5,000 per sale.

“The trend that is really helping Chrysler right now is the return to SUVs among consumers,” says Toprak.

And the Jeep truck brand holds the key to increased Chrysler sales abroad as well. “The potential of the Jeep outside the U.S. is actually better than inside the U.S.,” says Toprak. “If you own a Jeep in the Middle East, for example, you ‘have made it.’”

That is, the vehicles Nancy Pelosi & Co. despise are actually the vehicles that can lead the company that taxpayers were forced to bail out to profitability (Obama himself is the biggest obstacle, as he seeks to punish Detroit automakers with a further doubling of fuel-mileage mandates to 62 mpg by 2025). What’s more, the American invention that our president apologizes to the world for is actually the vehicle that the world craves as a status symbol.

If Fiat’s Marchionne didn’t understand that before he came to America, he understands it now.

The Chrysler flagship Grand Cherokee — fuel mileage just 17 mpg — increased sales a whopping291 percent in October leading a 37 percent increase in overall Chrysler sales. Fiat’s new American brand now projects its 2010 operating profit to hit $700 million, up from an expected, break-even $200 million.

No wonder Marchionne is an SUV convert.

Light trucks are money in the bank — and a big reason every automaker in the world wants to be in the low-gas-price U.S. market. Sergio’s got religion all right. He announced November 8 that he wants Chrysler’s Detroit Assembly Plant — the very facility Obama visited last July to crow about his Detroit bailouts – to build SUV platforms for as many as four brands: Chrysler, Dodge, Alfa Romeo, and Maserati.

Yee-haw! “The improving financial picture is helping make possible development of the fleet of new vehicles that Chrysler executives believe will further bolster the bottom line,” reports the Detroit News, “and take the once dying automaker to Wall Street, as a publicly traded company, in 2011.”

Industry analysts still bemoan the fact that Chrysler’s product mix is still too heavily dependent on SUVs — making it vulnerable to gas-price hikes — but Marchionne is laughing all the way to the bank.

How quickly can Chrysler churn out Fiat SUVs? Reports the News: “The timetable to add a Detroit-built Alfa, and possibly a Maserati, from Grand Cherokee underpinnings is 12 to 18 months, Marchionne said.” Global volume of the Italian SUVs could total 5,000 outside the U.S.

The accelerated schedule would mean jobs, jobs, jobs. Not the green, taxpayer-subsidized jobs that Obama promises. But the private, sustainable jobs that Wall Street investors crave.

“I’ve never seen a vehicle have this kind of support,” Marchionne admitted of the Grand Cherokee, adding that he underestimated its quality and appeal. Welcome to America, Sergio. You knuckle-dragging savage, you.

Dillon-less Democrats: Now what? (The Michigan View.com 11.8.10)

Posted by hpayne on November 8, 2010

As Frank Beckmann first reported on the View Sunday, Rick Snyder named Democratic House Speaker Andy Dillon his state treasurer Monday morning. The move fulfills Snyder’s campaign promise to reach across the aisle for budget solutions. But what does it mean for a reeling state Democratic Party? Is losing its biggest name and most prominent legislator another punch in the gut?

No, agree two prominent Michigan political analysts – but for very different reasons.

Bill Ballenger, editor of Inside Michigan Politics, says that the Dillon’s defection is symptomatic of a self-destructive party that lurched to the Left this election and paid the price. Joe DiSano, a Democratic political consultant with Lansing’s Main Street Strategies, says good riddance. He says Dillon’s inept party politics laid the foundation for the Democratic defeat and his departure will allow the party to focus on its core issues.

“This will have no impact. What Democrats did to Dillon sent a signal. We don’t want you. You have no future here,” Ballenger told The View in reference to moderate Dillon’s resounding defeat in the Democratic Party primary to left-wing union-toadie Virg Bernero.

A proponent of union health benefit reform to tackle that state’s gaping budget deficit, Speaker Dillon’ s ideas found more advocates in Republican than Democrat circles. Bernero exploited that rift — along with Dillon’s pro-life abortion views – buy lining up Big Labor support and running Dillon out of the Democratic primary in a huge upset last summer. Soured by the experience, Dillon refused to endorse Bernero for governor and speculation of a Snyder alliance began – even briefly fueling rumors that he might be the GOP nominee’s running mate.

Ballenger says that the odds were always long for Democrats in 2010, but rather than run to the middle, Big Labor decide “to fly the flag. Bernero ran a class warfare campaign and they got creamed.”

Dillon’s move will give him a fresh platform to espouse his ideas on union benefits reform. But it also removes the Democratic Party’s most obvious choice to lead the party back to the mainstream after a disastrous campaign in which it not only lost the governor’s mansion — but the both houses of the Legislature as well.

DiSano, however, says that Dillon shoulders a great deal of responsibility for the Democratic debacle.

“Losing Dillon is a net plus,” he says. “His claim to fame is two government shutdowns. He is a complete failure.”

The veteran strategist, who co-hosts the blog “TwoGuysNamedJoe.com,” with fellow consultant Joe Munem, says that — far from being a progressive party leader — Dillon’s lack of pragmatism in pushing benefits reforms spit the party and “took a lot of oxygen out of key issues like lobby reform and campaign finance disclosure.” As a result, the House speaker “never gave a sharp contrast to the Republicans” and was a much responsible for the Nov. 2 wipeout as was the head of the ticket.

But DiSano and Ballaneger agree that Dillon’s departure leaves a huge void in the Michigan Democratic Party. Who will fill it?

“They have to look themselves in the mirror and ask: Do we keep doing this?” says Ballenger. “Or do we have to go in a new direction? The choice was never going to be Dillon.”

But if not Dillon, who?

Bernero is damaged goods. Young party phenom, 33-year-old Granholm wannabe Jocelyn Benson, went down in flames to Ruth Johnson in the Secretary of State’s race. DiSano doesn’t see Benson as an immediate prospect. Instead, he points to this week’s election to replace Dillon as House minority leader as the start of the process of finding their Moses to lead them out of the wilderness. Woodrow Stanley and Richard Hammel — both long-serving, Flint-area, Big Labor pols — will likely emerge as the winner of that contest, says DiSano who also likes Senate Democrat Gretchen Whitmer as “a fresh voice.”

Ballenger isn’t impressed. “The Democrats had a bright person in Andy Dillon,” he says. “But they screwed up. Now the Republicans are taking advantage.”

Payne: Election ’10 by the numbers (The Michigan View. com 11.5.10)

Posted by hpayne on November 5, 2010

As the dust settles on November 2, the numbers reveal a Michigan route of historic proportions and a referendum on the Granholm years. Or, as Detroit News columnist Dan Howes calls it: “The Lost Decade.”

“How bad did the gubernatorial race turn out for Virg Bernero?” writes our political editor Dan Calabrese. “Not only did he win only five of Michigan’s 83 counties, but four of them just barely gave him the nod.

“The Lansing State Journal reports that Bernero carried Ingham (where The Angry Mayor lives) by only four-tenths of a percent. Bernero also carried Wayne (61-39), Genesee (52-48), Washtenaw (50.4-49.6) and Gogebic (51-49) counties. By the way, remember when blue-collar Macomb County was considered a bellwether county for not only state but national elections? It went 62-38 for Snyder.”

The Detroit News’ history buff and View columnist, Jeff Hadden, judges the Democratic Party’s “Ground Zero”partisan base vote at 38 percent. A little guesswork, yes, but also calculated on the disastrous campaign of Jeffrey Fieger that lost to popular Gov. John Engler in 1998 – Engler’s third term when no one wanted to run against him because everyone knew it was a lock – by 62-38.

Thirty-eight percent. Ground Zero. Bernero won 40 percent, meaning that he won just 2 percent of voters other than those who still think Jimmy Carter was the greatest president of all time. Speaking of Carter, his veep and 1984 Reagan opponent, Walter Mondale, only won three states in his sacrificial lamb campaign. Practically Bernero-esque.

Want good Democratic news? Don’t look at the state Senate. Republicans gained six seats and now hold a staggering 26-12 majority. Calabrese again:

“The Republican majority (is) so enormous, the Democrats will be able to caucus in a booth at Burger King.” Oh, yes, and the Dems also lost their majority in the House.

But it was just the economy right? There’s nothing fundamental here. Michigan saw right through those racist, Tea Party right-wing nuts, right? Wrong. Steve Mitchell’s exit polling found voter favorability ratings for the conservative Tea Party movement running 53-37.

“Mad as hell and won’t take it anymore?” Won it, 61-26.

After eight years of Jennifer Granholm, that’s your political landscape. The worst governor in Michigan history? You be the judge. One last number: Unemployment is 13 percent.

How did Peters survive the tsunami? (TheMichiganView.con 11.4.10)

Posted by hpayne on November 4, 2010

On Tuesday night Michigan Republicans were celebrating in the streets, smashing the Obama agenda, overturning Priuses, and cheering a state government sweep and big U.S. House wins. But one Pelosi poodle managed to escape the carnage.

How did Gary Peters – a first-term, 2008 Obama coattail Democrat in Republican Oakland County – survive?

Peters’ triumph was a lone bright spot for Democrats thanks to Big Money and the changing demographics of the 9th congressional district. But, warns Michigan political guru Bill Ballenger, Editor of Inside Michigan Politics, the party should drink its bubbly fast because redistricting under a Republican state capitol may spell doom for Peters’ district soon.

“If it was Bouchard or Bishop, the Republicans would have won,” says Ballenger matter-of-factly – getting the “what-if?” question off the table first. The question as to why the GOPers didn’t field their first string of Sheriff Mike Bouchard (who stubbornly ran for governor in a crowded field) or Senate Majority Leader Mike Bishop (who lost the AG primary to Bill Schuette) dogged Republicans all campaign.

Instead, Army Reservist Rocky Raczkowski (why isn’t a guy who drops his day job to put on a uniform and serve his country in hellhole Somalia considered “A Team?”), a hard-working, former state House minority leader got the nomination, riding a wave of Tea Party anger to upset Establishment Republican Paul Welday in the primary. A military man in a conservative district – a shoo-in, yes?

No, insists Ballenger, pointing out that the 9th is hardly a Republican cinch given its strong Democratic Jewish vote on its west side, youth vote in Royal Oak, and black urban vote in Pontiac. Meanwhile, the district’s core, Bloomfield Hills, has been hemorrhaging population with the decline of the auto industry.

Never a dynamic campaigner, Peters also benefited from incumbency in a rich district where buying congressmen is a necessary part of the business model. Strategically positioned on the House Finance Committee and the elite “New Democrat” fundraising club, Peters raked in money as gatekeeper for House financial reform legislation — most importantly, carving out regulatory exceptions for auto dealers. Incumbency has its privileges.

“Peters has always presented himself as a reasonable business candidate,” says Ballenger, “even as he votes Left. It’s a total sham.”

A 3:1 fundraising advantage allowed the Wall Street lackey to hammer the Rock with personal attack ads on the national Pelosi party model. With Rocky incapable of answering every volley, Peters maintained the offensive until election day — even running a false tax ad that most Democratic Party candidates pulled after watchdog groups called it a fib.

As the returns came in late Wednesday Morning, one Rocky insider called Campaign HQ “the saddest group of Republicans in Michigan.” But, says Ballenger, the Rocky setback is a speed bump.

The important event on Tuesday night was the Elephant Party’s sweep of Lansing, meaning that they will be in the driver’s seat come redistricting. That means when Peters pulls out the big bucks to defend his seat in 2012, or 2014, or. . . he may not have a district left to defend.

Washington Disconnect: SUV Sales Well Over 50 Percent of Market (National Review 11.3.10)

Posted by hpayne on November 3, 2010

As if to put a punctuation mark on how out-of-touch Washington is with the electorate, October vehicle sales released today reveal that SUV sales have now almost fully rebounded from their pre-recession numbers and now make up 53 percent of the market, with cars at just 47 percent. The numbers have flipped since last October as the economy recovers and customers return to bigger, more fuel-thirsty vehicles.

The figures came in the same month that the Obama administration ordered the EPA to study raising average mpg mandates to an absurd 62 mpg by 2025 (why not 100 mpg? Do I hear 150?) on top of an already fanciful 35 mpg figure by 2015. Currently, only cars like the tiny Smart two-seater make 35 mpg while the market trend is away from compacts.

To justify their mpg mandates, Washington Democrats claim that Americans are warming to hybrids. But October sales contradict these claims, as hybrid sales continued their drop to just 2.6 percent of the market – down from 2.9 percent last year (and 3.1 for 2009 as a whole)

The MSM, having spent all of last month extolling the virtues of new electric cars, largely ignored the inconvenient SUV data. “Most automakers reported strong truck and crossover sales while Toyota noted that its hybrid sales were off,” reported the Detroit News.

At GM, the marked SUV sales rise spelled good news as the profitable vehicles will help the Detroit giant pay off its massive government loans. GM’s “hot vehicles include the Chevrolet Equinox, GMC Terrain and Cadillac SRX followed by the larger Buick Enclave, GMC Acadia and Chevrolet Traverse,” reported the News. “On the pickup side, the Chevrolet Silverado, Avalanche and GMC Sierra saw sales rise 9 percent for the month.” All are low-mileage SUVs.

Michigan Democrats: ‘Blown away’ (The Michigan View 11.3.10)

Posted by hpayne on November 3, 2010

“And in five years, you’ll be blown away.” Make that FOUR years. Michigan has seen Obamanomics’ future. It’s called Granholmnomics. And the state has had enough.

If the Republican takeover of the U.S. House was a national rejection of Barack Obama’s radical economic agenda, then Michigan’s across-the-board triumph of Republicans from governor to taking the state House and Senate to picking up key congressional seats was a cry for help after four failed years of Jennifer Granholm’s version of Barack Obama’s European-style, Democratic Socialism.

“And in five years, you’ll be blown away,” said the Sweden-smitten governor as she launched her pro-Europe, pro-stimulus, pro-tax, pro-green transformation agenda in 2006. Her fellow Democrats were blown away Tuesday night after four years of escalating unemployment. It is a profound message to Obama to cease and desist too, lest he risk losing the White House as well as his governing majority.

Rick Snyder’s victory was not so much a vote for Rick Snyder as it was a giant “STOP” sign placed in front of Democratic polices that have bankrupted the state, divided it politically, and offered fairy tales about powering giant auto plants on windmills. Rather than address budget problems, Granholm shamelessly patched them with federal stimulus band-ads while filling her Big Union supporters with pay hike bubbly.

Virg Bernero promised more of the same, Rick Snyder did not. Mr. Snyder, you had us at “hello.”

Michiganians understand that their state has neglected fundamentals. That it needs to pare back its labor costs and get competitive again. That it needs to get its budget house in order. But Granholm’s solution ignored fundamentals. Like Obamanomics, she sought to exploit Michigan’s woes and turn it into a green laboratory.

Beginning in 2006, Granholm spent billions on infrastructure, claiming it would be a jobs engine. Lacking executive experience like her Chicago-activist-turned-president twin in Washington, she drove Michigan’s budget into a tree in 2007, shutting down government and raising taxes as the state groaned under the weight of a decade-long recession. Meanwhile, she dabbled in economic witchcraft, dishing out a cauldron of tax breaks to rich, politically-connected corporations from Big Green to bling-breasted Hollywood moguls in a fanciful attempt to “diversify” Michigan’s economy.

But the state continued to tank as businesses recoiled at the state’s anti-business unions, its perverse business tax and its rudderless budget process.

Then along came a Nerd.

A successful businessman. A man with executive experience. A political outsider with no connections to the Wayne County McNamara mafia. A budget balancer. A job creator. A bore on the stump.

The anti-Granholm. Michigan’s electorate has rewarded him with a landslide and an army of new legislators to staff the sinking ship. On a night when America buried Obamanomics, Michigan made sure Granholmnomics was in the coffin too.

The Dems’ Green-China Myth (National Review 10.29.10)

Posted by hpayne on October 29, 2010

The twin China lies of the 2010 Democratic campaign (and they are wall-to-wall here in Michigan) are that 1) Red China is stealing our jobs, and 2) Green China is an energy conservation model. China’s economy is a jobs engine at the same time it’s solving greenhouse emissions?

The Institute for Energy Research demolishes the Obama-Friedman-Clinton mantra that China is a granola-crunching paradise for tree-huggers:

The Obama Administration is either making up energy statistics or they are woefully ignorant, as the record of China is clear. In order to lift its people from poverty to plenty, China has embarked on the greatest expansion of energy use of all kinds in world history. They use 3.5 times more coal than the US, and long ago surpassed our economy in carbon dioxide emissions.

This year they passed the United States as the #1 consumer of energy in the world, a title we had held for over a century. Unlike the Obama Administration, the Chinese are developing their oil shale resources. They are welcoming investment in their offshore oil industry and are planning to build 2 dozen nuclear power plants while the US dithers over the permit for 1. While US politicians and the Obama Administration call for the removal of dams and their renewable energy, China in the last decade has added more hydroelectric capacity than the US has built since 1776.

China (has just) unveiled a new supercomputer that is 1.4 to 2.6 times as fast as the fastest computer in the US. What is the computer going to be used for? Solar panels? Windmills? Butterfly Power? Hardly. As the China Daily reports, their new computer “has begun trial use among target clients including….the National Offshore Oil Corporationdata center.”

They’re going to use it to look for offshore oil. Something the Obama Administration won’t let us do.

Re-elect Not-Rob-Steele (The Michigan View 10.29.10)

Posted by hpayne on October 29, 2010

You are the universally-recognized hero of universal health care. You inherited the mantle from your father who first introduced socialized care legislation in 1943. You spent 55 years in Congress as Captain Ahab chasing his Moby Dick. You introduced every session of Congress since 1957 by submitting a nationalized health care bill. You are so revered that even your Medicare gavel, first pounded in 1965, is an icon. You were cheered on the House floor when Obamacare – finally, the universal health care solution – passed October, 2009. You were given the podium by Speaker Pelois herself to pound your iconic gavel in a “vindication” celebration, as The New York Times itself called it. You sat next to the President Change himself in a packed, East Room signing ceremony to acknowledge your achievement. You thrust your crutch in the air when the air when the crowd gave you a standing ovation. You were booked by The Daily Show so that you and Jon Stewart himself could celebrate the arrival of universal health care by breaking open walnuts with your iconic gavel. You would be running this fall to celebrate your victory – and you had the photo album to prove it.

You are John Dingell. Your campaign victory lap has arrived. And now you want everyone to know. . . that your Republican opponent is a China-outsourcing, Social Security-stealing mega-rich fraud?

In an election when Democrats are running from Obamacare, perhaps the most extraordinary tale is that the one man who never gave up hope on socialized medicine refuses to claim his Great Victory. So reviled is the Democrats’ health care power grab, that not even John Dingell will acknowledge its existence.

“Imagine Steve Forbes getting himself elected, ramming through a flat tax, and then clamming up about what he’d done,” says a media colleague.

As Dan Calabrese of The View’s Campaign Buzz blog catalogues, Dingell hasn’t used one frame of the carefully choreographed footage from Obamacare victory party last spring.

Instead, his ugly campaign has tried to drown cardiologist-turned-Republican candidate Rob Steele in the gutter. Just this month alone, Dingell’s – er, Not-Rob-Steele’s – campaign has consisted of, in order:

– A TV ad that claims Rob Steele “opposes workers” and supports “tax breaks for companies that ship jobs to China and India.”

– A press release claiming Rob Steele “supports tax cuts for companies that ship jobs to China and India.”

– A radio ad that claims Rob Steele supports “tax cuts for the mega-rich,” billions in borrowing from China, privatizing Social Security, “gambling your retirement money on Wall Street,” and being “just another vote for special interests.”

– A TV ad that claims that Rob Steele supports China outsourcing, “tax breaks for himself and the mega-rich,” and gambling your Social Security on Wall Street

– A TV ad claiming that Rob Steele just stole grandma and is selling her to Chinese slaveholders.

(Okay, just kidding about that last one.)

No ads touting Obamacare. No ads with Big John and his iconic gavel. No pictures signing health reform – crutch thrust in the air to thunderous applause! – at the White House. No justification for Dingell’s 55 years in the House except that he can bring home pork.

Somewhere under that gruff, tough, 80-year-old exterior, John Dingell must be weeping. This is it? This is why he got into public service? This is why he carried his father’s torch? This is what he wants people to know about him? To respect about him?

John Dingell, the shrunken, embarrassing, symbol of the 2010 Democratic majority.

Check for the union label (The Michigan View 10.28.10)

Posted by hpayne on October 28, 2010

In the election stretch run, a beleaguered Democratic Party has struck its familiar pose as the party for Main Street, not Wall Street — a political levee against a flood of corporate and special interest money. But as the enormous special interest sums flowing into the paradoxically anti-special interest campaign of Secretary of State candidate Jocelyn Benson show, the image couldn’t be more misleading.

Thanks to massive stimulus expenditures in Washington on politically-favored public employees, Democrats are awash in special interest money this election cycle. While taxpayers have suffered through the worst downturn since the Great Depression, the federal government has used their tax money to cushion fat public employee unions. Thankful unions have cycled millions of that revenue back to Democratic campaigns.

The result? The Number One campaign spender this year is not Big Business, it is Big Labor.

“The American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees is now the biggest outside spender of the 2010 elections,” reports The Wall Street Journal. “The 1.6 million-member AFSCME is spending a total of $87.5 million on the elections.”

“We’re the big dog,” brags Larry Scanlon, the head of AFSCME’s political operations, and Big Labor wants to stay there.

State government unions have been the recipient of $160 billion in Democratic largesse to prevent public-sector layoffs. In Michigan, it has allowed public unions like AFSCME, the MEA, and the UAW to avoid layoffs and pay cuts. The Mackinac Center reports that state employee payrolls grew by four percent even as private payrolls were slashed 11 percent. Democrats have been at the receiving end of huge campaign gifts as Big Labor fears a GOP win this November will reduce the gravy train to a trickle.

Every major Democrat in Michigan is raking in the campaign donations. Democratic Secretary of State candidate Jocelyn Benson told The Detroit News this month that she’s running in part because of her concern over Big Money influencing politics. “It will be my mission as your next Secretary of State to ensure that no large corporations or powerful special interests down (sic) out your voice,” she says on her website.

That is an odd claim from a candidate who has raised a staggering $800,000 – in part from radical George Soros-supported activist groups – but primarily from Big Labor. For example, the SoS candidate has receives a whopping $34,000 (the maximum contribution allowed) by the United Auto Workers. Yes, the UAW. Even as its auto membership has declined, the union has become a major public employee representative boasting UAW Local 6000 – the state’s largest public employee union.

In a View analysis of Benson’s campaign contributions, Big Labor is everywhere. In addition to the UAW’s gift, the anti-special interest candidate’s contributor list is a Who’s Who of Big Labor special interests:

Michigan Education Association Political Action Committee: $33,950 American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees: $10,000 American Federation of Teachers, Michigan PAC: $5,000 International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, PAC Local 58: $5,000 Michigan Nurses Association PAC: $5,000 Plumbers and Steamfitters 85 PAC: $2,500 United Food and Commercial Workers: $2,000 – Iron Workers Local: $450

And so on. Benson also insists that she is a non-partisan candidate, but her Big Union backers – unlike corporations which play both sides – are extremely partisan with some 90 percent of their contributions going to Democrats. If elected to office, the “non-partisan, non-special interest” candidate looks increasingly like a Trojan Horse for George Soros and a mule for Big Labor.

About that Volt Planetary Gear Flap: A Correction (National Review 10.27.10)

Posted by hpayne on October 27, 2010

Detroit – Last week, I reported that the media dust-up over whether the Chevy Volt is an EREV (extended range electric vehicle) or a series hybrid mattered because it was the difference between  a $7,500 tax credit — or just $2,500 per Volt sold. I stand corrected.

The tax credit is determined — not by drive-train — but by battery size. To quote the federal legislation itself:

Section 30D provides for a credit for certain new qualified plug-in electric drive motor vehicles. The credit is equal to the sum of: (1) $2,500, plus (2) for a vehicle which draws propulsion energy from a battery with at least 5 kilowatt hours of capacity, plus an additional $417, and $417 for each kilowatt hour of battery capacity in excess of 5 kilowatt hours. Under § 30D(b)(3), that portion of the credit determined by battery capacity cannot exceed $5,000. Therefore, the total amount of the credit allowed for a vehicle is limited to $7,500.

Your federal government at work. At 16 kilowatt hours, the Volt’s battery qualifies.

Which is why those wealthy California greens will get $7,500 off their new green status symbol. And therein is the real reason GM badly wanted to designate the Volt an EREV (even though it really operates more like a series hybrid).

“They did not want to be painted with the same brush,” says Ward’s auto analyst Bill Visnic. Because if Leo diCaprio wants a new green status symbol, he wants something that is “different” than his hybrid Prius. Though U.S. taxpayers will not be amused to learn that subsidizing Leo’s new toy will cost them $5 grand more than the Toyota.

The Empty Mayor (The Michigan View 10.25.10)

Posted by hpayne on October 25, 2010

The Angry Mayor became The Empty Mayor Sunday.

Bill Clinton’s visit to Detroit was supposed to be a high point of Bernero’s “Comeback Kid” campaign. Instead, the embarrassment of a half-empty Renaissance High auditorium led The Drudge Report and symbolizes a campaign of incompetence and elitism.

Clinton’s red meat speech was meant to light a fire under Democratic turnout – but he couldn’t even motivate Democrats to attend his motivational speech. “He began his speech just before 3 p.m. in a high school gym that was less than half full,” reported The Detroit News’ Paul Egan. “Shortly before Clinton took the stage, the Rev. Wendell Anthony, president of the Detroit branch of the NAACP, urged attendees to leave bleacher seats along one side of the gym and try to fill the area in front of the podium before Clinton began his address.”

This is a campaign not ready for prime time. Short of The One, Clinton is the party’s biggest fundraiser. And Bernero’s ground campaign couldn’t bus in enough folks to fill the seats? Heading into the election’s stretch run?

Bernero’s dais was a Who’s Who of Michigan politics including the mayor’s running mate Brenda Lawrence, John Conyers, Debbie Stabenow, SOS candidate Jocelyn Benson, AG candidate David Leyton.

“Clinton is still a rock star in Detroit,” said Wayne County Commissioner Kevin McNamara. Trouble is, the dais nearly outnumbered the rock star’s audience.

“This is two problems,” says Michigan pollster Steve Mitchell of Mitchell Research. “It’s a problem of campaign organization. You don’t book a facility for Bill Clinton unless you can fill it. But it also has to be disconcerting to Democrats as a precursor of low base voter turnout.”

Worse, the appearance at public Renaissance High only highlighted last week’s news that Bernero – the pro- teacher union, Big Government cheerleader – hypocritically attended private schools himself and sent one of his kids to private Catholic School, even as he questions the value of school choice for suffering Detroit families stuck in Michigan’s worst public school system.

His podium partner is no less elitist when is comes to public schools. Clinton sent his own daughter to Sidwell Friends, one of Washington’s most elite private schools when he was president and an opponent of school choice in the District of Columbia.

The private school pals were no doubt uncomfortable in their unfamiliar public school surrounds – a discomfort made more so by the empty seats.

Soros slithers into Michigan politics (The Michigan View 10.23.10)

Posted by hpayne on October 23, 2010

The heavy hand of George Soros has been back in the headlines this week with his nearly $2 million contribution to NPR and alleged meddling in the Juan Williams firing. His influence is being felt in Michigan in a key state election as well.

Jocelyn Benson, the ambitious, young lefty running for Secretary of State is one of a handful of races targeted by Soros’ SOS Project this year according to the American Spectator.

Secretary of State races would seem an odd target for the billionaire political mogul, but control the SOS office and you can control close electoral outcomes. Soros learned that in 2000 when a Republican SOS in Florida resisted Democratic efforts to change election rules in midstream, denying “hanging chad” votes and ultimately the chance for Al Gore to steal a presidential election.

Soros is determined that that not happen again.

“At the top of the SoS Project’s slate of candidates is Minnesota’s radically left-wing Mark Ritchie,” reports The Spectator, “a former community organizer whose cavalier attitude toward electoral fraud and whose shamelessly partisan conduct during the recount process cleared the way for Al Franken to steal last year’s U.S. Senate election.”

“The strategic targeting of the SoS Project yielded astounding results in 2008 and 2006,” continues The Spectator’s Matthew Vadum. “In 2008, SoS Project-backed Democrats Linda McCulloch (Montana), Natalie Tennant (West Virginia), Robin Carnahan (Missouri), and Kate Brown (Oregon) won their races.”

SOS has already given $3000 to Benson. She is defensive about Soros, first telling Frank Beckmann she knew little about him (an unlikely claim given her party ambitions and the fact that she was a field director for the 2004 Kerry prez campaign), and then admitting that she had taken the SOS Project money.

But there’s more. “Benson is a candidate ACORN would love,” writes Vadum. “Last year in Michigan, she helped to lead the fight to stop the Republican secretary of state ‘from disenfranchising voters who were victims of home foreclosures.'”

Indeed, Benson has made the foreclosure conspiracy a centerpiece o her campaign even as the current SIS, Terry Lynn Land denies any such plot. The Detroit News editorial board asked Benson where she got her evidence.

Benson cited widespread “media reports.” When pressed on which media she was referring to, she admitted the conspiracy was “reported” by only one publication: The Michigan Messenger. What is the Michigan Messenger? A left-wing propaganda publication funded by George Soros.

“The Alternatives” timely media panel (The Michigan View 10.22.10)

Posted by hpayne on October 22, 2010

“It’s fortuitous that this media panel is happening tonight,” said John Fund Thursday. “How many of you heard what has happened to Juan Williams?”

National Politically-correct Radio’s firing of liberal black journalist Williams for his thoughts on Muslim airport stereotyping ” and Fox News renewal of his contract ” were a perfect backdrop for a panel on “The Alternatives: How New Media is Changing the Political Landscape,” sponsored by The Michigan View.com and The Mackinac Center.

The panel, featuring Fund of Fox/The Wall Street Journal, Frank Beckmann of WJR-Radio, Ken Braun of Michigan Capitol Confidential, Kathy Hoekstra of the Mackinac Center, and yours truly (editor of the View) convened in Pontiac to discuss the conservative media revolution that now challenges the liberal Mainstream Media across the country today.

The program was broadcast live on WJR-Radio as well as simulcast at Mackinac.org. An enthusiastic audience of 100 filled the Oakland County Commissioners Auditorium to hear of a diverse menu of products from national cable news to talk radio to local Internet publicans that have transformed the media landscape and that are having a profound effect on this year’s elections.

A decade ago, NPR’s censorship of Williams might have ended his career. Today, he is welcomed with open arms by a more tolerant alternative media and his story told instantly through dozen of media outlets across the country.

Thanks to all who joined us last night. You can watch the fill telecast at Mackinac here.

Why Care about the Chevy Volt’s Planetary Gear? Follow the Money ( National Review 10.21.10)

Posted by hpayne on October 21, 2010

Why has the complex drive-train engineering of the Chevy Volt become a headline in the popular press? Why does anyone care whether the Volt is an EREV (extended range electric vehicle) or a series hybrid? Simply put, it’s the difference between whether Government Motors gets a $7,500 tax credit — or just $3500 per Volt sold. It’s the difference between whether the sticker says $41,000 or “just” $33,500. It’s the difference between how many credits GM gets towards Obama’s artificial average-vehicle-mileage mandate of 35 mpg.

When the feds start running consumer markets, engineering quibbles matter.

As Holman Jenkins wrote in the WSJ on Wednesday, “the gasoline engine that generates electricity when the (Volt) batteries are depleted will, under certain circumstances, directly turn the planetary ring gear and help drive the car.”

Engaging the planetary ring gear is the type of genius engineering solution auto nerds come up with to make cars better. The Volt, properly understood, is a “plug-in hybrid” since it is capable of running on the battery ALONE all the way to 100 mph (a “dual mode” Prius hybrid, by contrast, runs on a gas engine with a battery for low-end assist).

But by crossing the breach between the gas engine driving a generator or directly driving the wheels (that outer, “planetary” gear in the transmission), it created havoc for GM’s public-relations department which had advertised the Volt as the real deal electric (“230 mpg!” Also a fabrication, but that’s another story) and therefore worthy of the $7,500 “electric” handout as opposed to the $3,500 “hybrid” handout. Regardless, GM — or rather, the rich Greenies who need the latest $40-grand status symbol — will get your $7,500 in tax money because the tax credit was designed for the Volt in the first place.

The whole flap shows the cynical loopholes that pervade this industry now that the government is making the rules.

Mitch Albom, special interest lobbyist ( The Michigan View 10.19.10)

Posted by hpayne on October 19, 2010

In his weekly client newsletter — er, Sunday column — entertainment lobbyist Mitch Albom – er, Detroit Free Press writer Mitch Albom — demonstrates why government programs and tax subsidies are so hard to end.

Albom takes umbrage at GOP gubernatorial candidate Rick Snyder’s unusually specific pledge to end a 42 percent tax subsidy for the movie and television business — a business that Albom, himself a writer of film scripts — admits to lobbying for. “(Snyder) claims they don’t pay off and calls for phasing them out — this during a campaign when candidates are usually evasive,” writes Albom, who — if Snyder were less specific — would undoubtedly write the stock liberal hack’s column taking umbrage at a Republican candidate not being more specific about where he wants to cut government (which is precisely why candidates don’t go into specifics. But I digress. . .).

Lobbyist Albom says that eliminating the tax subsidy “would be bad for Michigan. I was involved in bringing these tax incentives to our state. I helped with their creation, testified before the Legislature, met numerous times with the governor and her staff.” But why stop there? Why not a subsidy for his struggling newspaper? Or fellow struggling book authors? Or. . . .

Albom and his rich Hollywood friends are a classic special interest (Big Hollywood meet Big Oil and Big Ethanol) with a built-in celebrity factor (special interests loooove celebrity salespeople). Lobbyist Albom naturally claims the program has worked. “Within three years, we jumped from less than $2 million in film and TV activity to more than $600 million to date. Name me another business that grows that fast.”

No doubt, the program has worked for scriptwriter Albom who stands to benefit from cheaper film costs thanks to his Michigan neighbors. Indeed, as a Michigan radio personality, his radio program also benefits from the steady flow of celebrities — Richard Gere, the cast of Detroit 1-8-7 — that parachute into the state.

But the hard evidence is that what’s good for Mitch is not necessarily good for Mich.

In a devastating study, the Mackinac Center found that after two years the film subsidies “impact on the overall state economy is too small to measure, (but) its effects on taxes and the budget are significant. The state has authorized $117 million in film credits, and the Department of Treasury estimates that the subsidies will cost $155 million in the upcoming fiscal year.” Ouch.

“Critics of the program — usually people who will never benefit from it — say we’re not making back enough money,” snorts Albom in response. This is an argument? By this logic, if you don’t like the wasteful B1 weapons program, you obviously aren’t a defense contractor who benefitted from it. Don’t like Big Ethanol subsidies? Why, you don’t grow corn?

It’s all about jobs, jobs, jobs, says Albom. “It is terribly hard to measure the ripple effect of a movie or TV show — the hotels, rental cars, restaurants or tangential businesses.” So it makes us feeeeeel good. And by that standard, no subsidy will end. Ever.

“We give tax incentives to all kinds of businesses (more than $3.5 billion to more than 500 companies under Gov. Jennifer Granholm, according AnnArbor.com). Isn’t that partly what our tax money is for? To create jobs, ignite citizens and boost the image of our state?” writes Albom.

No. Private investment — not tax goodies — is what creates jobs. That’s what made Michigan an industrial power. That’s why — despite Granholm’s billions in special interest subsidies these last four years, the state’s unemployment rate — jobs, jobs, jobs — has climbed from 7 percent to 15 percent. Government-subsidized jobs aren’t permanent jobs. They will disappear as soon as another state ups the tax credit ante.

All that’s left for Albom is to huff and puff: “As I often want to say to these angry critics, so what’s your great idea?” It’s the same great idea that this country has had since its founding, Mitch. It’s right there on the Mackinac Center’s website and dozens of others: Create a low-tax, low-regulatory, pro-Right to Work, pro-growth environment and watch the jobs flood in.

It works every time.

Would Jesus drive a Chevy Volt? ( The Michigan View 10.15.10)

Posted by hpayne on October 15, 2010

Back in ’03, as a shiny new arsenal of light trucks dominated the Detroit Auto Show, an anti-SUV movement took to the streets to protest that the gas-guzzlers inside. The trucks, they are argued, were underwriting the terrorists we were fighting in the Middle East.

Their slogan: “What would Jesus drive?”

Led by influential left-wing millionairess Arianna Huffington, a powerful coalition of Democratic lawmakers, green groups, journalists, national church groups and Hollywood celebrities launched the “Detroit Project,” an ad campaign that contended that cars were a moral decision and that American sinners must move to hybrid electrics and declare energy independence from abroad or else continue to fuel nefarious petro-dictatorships (in the words of the New York Times Thomas Friedman) and their destabilizing policies.

Now, fueled by billions in green stimulus subsidies, a $4-a-gallon gas scare, and a 35 mpg decree from the greenest president in history, that movement has culminated in this month’s GM roll out of the first iconic plug-in hybrid, the Chevy Volt. The Volt embodies the Green movement’s ideal auto. It can drive 40 miles without using a drop of gasoline. It is one of a fleet of vehicles – including cars from Nissan, Tesla, and Fisker – that rely on batteries for power.

But would Jesus drive them? No, concludes influential Car & Driver columnist Aaron Robinson.

In a pair of devastating columns, Robinson shows that the lithium battery-powered revolution looks a lot like the oil status quo that Greens have spent the last decade denouncing. The essential elements of lithium-ion batteries must be imported from thuggish, foreign regimes. The batteries in the electric Nissan Leaf contains about nine pounds of lithium. Nissan claims capacity for a half-million electric cars per year by 2015, meaning it will need about 2,250 tons of lithium annually.

Goodbye oil dependence, hello lithium and cobalt dependence.

“Wherever energy has been discovered in the past century, fortunes have bloomed,” writes Robinson in his September column, “As We Go Green with Clean Electric Cars, Somebody’s Going to Get Dirty.” Bolivia’s lithium-rich, 4000-square-mile Salar de Uyuni salt flats “has earned it the title of the ‘Saudi Arabia of lithium. And the Bolivians are not the only ones in South America getting measured for sheik’s robes. Argentina’s Salar del Hombre Muerto (“Salt Lake of the Dead Man”) and the salt playas in Chile’s high Atacama Desert represent about 80 percent of the world’s easily exploitable lithium reserves.”

The majority of that reserve is in Bolivia, home of half the world’s known lithium deposits – and ruled by Evo Morales, a populist socialist closely aligned with anti-American Venezuelan President Hugo Chávez, who likes to say things like: “Either capitalism dies or else Planet Earth dies.” You know Chavez? He’s one if the petro-dictators that lithium batteries are supposed to liberate us from. Venezuela is a major U.S. oil exporter.

The authoritarian Chavez is a model for Bolivia’s Morales, who want s to nationalize the lithium industry as Chavez nationalized the Venezuelan oil company, CITCO. Morales, reports The New Yorker magazine, is “friendly with Fidel Castro, of Cuba, and Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, the Iranian President. Ahmadinejad visited La Paz in November to announce a joint project to study lithium technology. ‘I’m a big admirer of you and your people,’ Morales told him. ‘Our people have the mandate to liberate ourselves from the empires.'”

And cobalt – also an essential ingredient in the green-preferred lithium power plants? Cobalt extraction typically goes hand in hand with copper and nickel mining,” writes Robinson in the magazine’s October issue. “About 80 percent of the world’s cobalt supply is believed to be in central Africa’s “copper belt,” a band of ancient, mineral-endowed soil straddling Zambia and the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC). . . . The mining of these minerals takes place amid ‘one of the worst conflict situations in the world,’ says Congo policy analyst Aaron Hall of the Enough Project, a left-wing group funded by Democratic billionaire George Soros.”

“In the DRC’s eastern provinces of North and South Kivu, various rebel factions and the national army conduct mining at gunpoint or extract levies at checkpoints along the roads that fund their fighting. . . . (while the) the open pit mining that produces cobalt is causing serious environmental degradation,” he goes on.

“EVs are touted as clean transportation for socially-responsible types,” write Robinson. “You know these people they’re the ones the ones in the Whole Foods carefully reading the package labels.” Yes, we know the ones. They were the same people that said electrics were the guilt-free solution to the gas engine – the moral choice for a new generation of Americans.

“Does anyone living in our modern consumer paradise care if their vehicle purchase helps pay for murder and environmental ruin in Africa?” concludes the Car & Driver columnist.

We await the “What would Jesus Drive?” protest signs at the green 2011 Detroit auto show.

Backfire: Bernero-backed firm offshores jobs to Asia (The Michigan View 10.13.10)

Posted by hpayne on October 13, 2010

A medical devices firm that Virg Bernero has touted as an example of his success bringing jobs to Lansing has outsourced manufacturing to Southeast Asia and is further expanding its Malaysian operations with 200 employees.

Details of Symmetry Medical’s vast international operations come at the same time The Angry Mayor has made corporate offshoring a cornerstone of his gubernatorial campaign. Bernero has accused his GOP opponent and ex-Gateway CEO Rick Snyder of funding a firm, Discera, that recently opened a five-man office in China, arguing that it robs Michigan of jobs.

But the Bernero-favored Symmetry dwarfs Discera in locating jobs in low-cost Asian nations.

Thanks to special MEDC tax favors, Symmetry is expanding its Lansing operations, but the Penang operation is Symmetry’s fastest-growing facility worldwide. “Development plans for Symmetry Penang’s operations are significant and include . . . instrument and implant manufacturing exclusively for Asian markets,” its CEO Brian Moore told TheEdgeMaylasia.com.

Asked at a Detroit News editorial board interview if Symmetry is engaged in the very same practices — growing sales opportunities in Asia — that he hammered Discera for, the usually glib Bernero was incoherent.

“Does Snyder have the right to expand? Absolutely,” said Bernero before launching into an attack on why Dicsera did not have a right to expand in Asia. He said that Symmetry was growing jobs in Michigan — but so is tiny Discera which has 41 employees, 27 of them stateside.

Indeed, if Discera is a public nuisance, then Symmetry is a serial offender. Discera’s office in China is 300-square-foot with three salespeople, one field applications engineer, and an administrative assistant (the lone engineer Benero found particularly troubling as our The Buzz’s Dan Calabrese reports here).

Meanwhile, Bernero’s pals at New York Stock Exchange-listed Symmetry (Wall Street not Main Street!) have a 50,000 sq. ft. facility where the company outsources manufacture of its implants, instruments and sterilization cases. Its new $15 million facility there will be hiring DOZENS of engineers and other personnel to serve as an international sales centre.

The Symmetry double-standard comes as Bernero — down big points in the polls — flails wildly at his opponent trying to make some impression on his “jobs, jobs, jobs” resume. “We think it’s unconscionable that someone who wants to be Michigan’s governor is helping Chinese companies gain a competitive edge,” says a Bernero campaign spokesman.

Really? By that strained standard, the mayor himself has been integral in helping Chinese companies. He lobbied for the GM bailout – the same GM that has 21,000 employees in China in a minority partnership with Shanghai Motors, a Chinese government company that produces cars for the Chinese market.

Southeast Asia is the world’s biggest, fastest-growing market. Bernero’s threats to discourage Michigan firms there is suicidal.

The Volt Rolls Out to a Media Goregasm (National Review 10.12.10)

Posted by hpayne on October 12, 2010

Imagine the U.S. government offering $7,500 to well-off buyers of a BMW 3-series convertible, and an additional $2,000 to buy fuel. Imagine the outrage. There you have the problem with the Chevy Volt.

In the midst of a slow economy and voter anxiety, the U.S. government is preparing to roll out its green electric-car program starring Chevy’s plug-in hybrid. While GM has offered the car for media drives, the collective Goregasm from the press hides the fact that the high tech, silent, undoubtedly cool electronic gizmo is a $41,000 plaything for the blue coast jet set.

“I drove a pre-production Volt,” writes one reviewer with the Boston Herald, “(and it) proved to be a far better vehicle than I was expecting, an undeniable engineering coup for GM. The biggest surprise may be how well the Volt handles. The T-shaped battery pack is placed very low in the chassis, and the lower the extra weight is, the better.”

The trouble with pressie car reviewers is the cars are free. Sure, the Volt handles better than the $17,000 Chevy Cruze with which it shares a platform — but if it’s handling you want, you’ll drop your $40 grand on a BMW. Or an Audi A5. Or any number of vastly superior vehicles in that price range.

And that gets to the nub of the issue. The Volt — and its expensive electric stable mates — are rich niche cars for DiCaprio & Co. Which is why the Toyota Prius–dominated hybrid market has never eclipsed 3 percent of cars sold. Which is why the U.S. government is desperately offering a $7,500 tax credit to buy it and another $2 grand for a fast-charging station.

“The Volt strikes us as the closest in concept to the winning formula of the Prius,” writes Car & Driver, which — unlike their media brethren — has managed to maintain some perspective. “This is without a doubt the most important new car since the advent of hybrids in the late ’90s, and GM has nailed it. Is this the handing off of the Prius’s very illustrious torch?”

The Volt is evolution, not revolution. That is, it’s the new green fashion statement. It’s the new Prius.

Debate: Nerd survives Angry Mayor (The Michigan View 10.11.10)

Posted by hpayne on October 11, 2010

Wixom – The Angry Mayor threw the kitchen sink (actually the outhouse toilet) at The Tough Nerd.

In the only debate of the 2010 governor’s race, Virg Bernero’s challenge was to try and drag Rick Snyder off his white horse – the legendary, iconic white horse of a successful entrepreneur rising to the people’s rescue in difficult times – and into the muck. Once there, Bernero might have a fighting chance. “The Chief Executive Outsourcer,” said Bernero, dropping his bombshell, had not only outsourced Gateway’s jobs to China but was vested in a company called Discera “that had shipped jobs to China.”

“Mr. Snyder,” said the Angry Mayor in his angriest smolder, “how could you?”

Snyder might have answered that Symmetry – a company that Bernero credits himself with bringing to Lansing – has outsourced hundreds of jobs to the Far East to make its medical devices. He might have pointed out that Discera is a small startup of 41 employees that has opened a tiny, 5-man office in Shenzhen to serve customers there. Or he might have laughed at Bernero’s flat-earth protectionism, pointing out that, were it not for General Motor’s massively profitable investment with Chinese government-owned Shanghai Motors, the Detroit Company would not be able to finance UAW pensions.

But Snyder stayed firm in his saddle. He said Discera was an Ann Arbor-based company that “does not have an operation in China” and that the Center for Michigan’s “Truth Squad” had found Snyder’s ad claims of Gateway outsourcing “simply untrue.” Then he returned to his tested, positive platitudes that “I am the only job creator in this race.”

The refusal to jump into the mud and beat some sense into Bernero’s empty head will disappoint those (like me) who crave these teachable moments. But by staying the high road, Snyder won this debate and locked up the election.

In the end, this was a debate played on Snyder’s terms. Recognizing that this is an election about job creation in Michigan’s worst economy in a generation, Bernero has made this a contest of who can create more jobs. Yet despite reading from the GOP playbook on job creation, low taxes, and balanced budgets, The Angry Mayor cannot win this game. Snyder’s American success story of growing tiny Gateway Computer to a 10,000-employee behemoth in the 1990s is his trump card.

Bernero has tried to puncture that resume by caricaturing his opponent with a pampered-rich-guy-who doesn’t-care-about-you-but-loves-foreigners campaign.

But the rich guy charge is ridiculous on its face: Why would a multimillionaire take a $172,000 public employee job if he didn’t care about Michigan? And Snyder is no trust-baby, but a self-made man who “grew up in a 900-foot square home in Battle Creek” as Snyder reminded the TV audience.

And the foreigner bashing? Tasteless. Consider: Bernero himself is the son of Italian immigrants. If his father were Chinese he would have to disown him.

What a difference four years makes. In 2006, Jennifer Granholm – another silver-tongued Democrat – wiped the debate floor with Dick Devos, a job-creating businessman trailing in the polls and challenging her Big Government ways. Granholm bashed him on sending jobs to China, and selling out Michigan women on abortion and other social issues.

But this is “a different economy, a different environment,” says Saul Anuzis, who was Michigan GOP Chief in 2006. “This year, 56 percent of voters rate jobs the #1 issue. The next closest issue ge ts only nine percent.”

In tonight’s debate, social issues merited just one question 50 minutes into the hour-long debate. Tonight, Michigan’s unemployment rate has swelled from 7 percent in 2006 to 15 percent. Tonight, the businessman who created jobs is up 20 point in the polls.

He’s on his white horse and Michigan prays he has a plan.