Articles
But Palin has libeled Imam Rauf (The Michigan View 1.14.11)
Posted by hpayne on January 14, 2011
When it comes to national controversies, Sarah Palin has been wronged – but she has also been wrong.
She was libeled this week as an instigator of the Tucson massacre, but she has spread libel herself about the Ground Zero Mosque imam, Faisal Rauf. “Rauf refuses to recognize that Hamas is a terrorist organization dedicated to the destruction of our ally, Israel,” she wrote on her Facebook page last July.
Rauf is in Metro Detroit this weekend and repeated – again – that he opposes Hamas and terrorism in an interview this morning with Frank Beckmann on WJR. “Hamas is a terrorist organization. They have committed terrorist acts,” he told Beckmann.
This is consistent with what his website, CordobaInitiative.org, which states: “Hamas is both a political movement and a terrorist organization. When Hamas commits atrocious acts of terror, those actions should be condemned. Imam Feisal has forcefully and consistently condemned all forms of terrorism, including those committed by Hamas, as un-Islamic.”
Or when he told Soledad O’Brien on CNN’s Larry King Show last September 8 that “I condemn everyone and anyone who commits acts of terrorism. And Hamas has committed acts of terrorism.” He also said he would “absolutely” refuse any monies from Hamas. And Israel? “Targeting of civilians is wrong. It’s a sin in our religion, whoever does it. I am a supporter of the State of Israel,” he said in a radio interview last June.
“(I) feel it would be an intolerable and tragic mistake to allow such a project sponsored by such an individual to go forward on such hallowed ground,” Palin concluded.
But “such an individual” told Beckmann that he has had a mosque on this “hallowed ground” in lower Manhattan “for twenty years. I’m very sensitive to 9-11. Members of our mosque were among the victims – and were among the first responders.”
Many more Muslims have died at the hand of Muslim extremism than any other faith. Like most American Muslims, Rauf says he wants to build a “YMCA” to celebrate America’s tolerance for all religions.
The “tragic mistake” here is Palin’s.
Dingell: Giffords shot because Palin and GOP ‘were putting crosshairs on her’ (the Michigan View 1.14.11)
Posted by hpayne on January 14, 2011
John Dingell has not been shy this week about using the Tucson massacre for political advantage.
The View.com reported Thursday morning that the senior member of Michigan’s Congressional delegation – and the longest-serving U.S. House member – took to the House floor Wednesday afternoon to add more fuel to the narrative that Sarah Palin and Republicans were responsible for the shooting – even as President Obama was in the air to Tucson for a memorial service in which he would ask that politicians not “use this tragedy as one more occasion to turn on one another.”
But it was not the first time Dingell had spun his conspiracy theory.
On Monday at the Detroit Auto Show, Dingell was even more explicit – without any facts whatsoever – that Palin had provided a road map for Jared Loughner to kill Democratic Rep. Gabrielle Giffords.
“Gabrielle Giffords had one of the great pundits of the far right come out and talk about how they were putting crosshairs on her,” Dingell told Nathan Bomey of AnnArbor.com while visiting Cobo. “It took only a little while for some fellow to believe, well, you know, that’s the case.”
Dingell’s Monday accusation came as evidence mounted that politics had nothing to do with shooter Jared Loughner’s rampage. By Wednesday, when Dingell repeated the libel back in Washington on the House floor, there was no doubt that Loughner was a deranged individual that not only was divorced from politics – he was divorced from the real world.
He was suspended from school “after police officers who removed him from a biology class told the school they believed he had mental health problems,” reports the Wall Street Journal. And Zack Osler, a friend of Loughner’s, told ABC News that “he did not watch TV. He disliked the news. He didn’t listen to political radio. He didn’t take sides. He wasn’t on the left. He wasn’t on the right.”
No matter. Dingell followed his Michigan colleague, Sen. Debbie Stabenow, in fingering conservative “hate speech” for Loughner’s actions.
“I saw the district of Gabrielle Giffords has a crosshairs put on it,” said Dingell departing from his prepared text. “As a lifetime rifleman and shooter, I know what crosshairs signify when you put them on somebody and I know what happened. And one other thing: ‘if ballots don’t work, bullets will.'”
Using hyperbole typical of his party’s strategy to use the Gifford’s shooting to change the GOP’s legislative momentum, Dingell compared Republican rhetoric to the racism of the civil rights movement, declaring the current political atmosphere the worst he has ever seen.
“Mr. Speaker, I have seen firsthand the anger brought on by landmark, life-changing legislation. The rage during the civil rights debates was unlike anything I had seen, until now,” said the longest-serving member of Congress.
“Within the last year I have witnessed anger at my community events that rival the behavior I witnessed during the civil rights debates,” he continued in reference to a heated town hall debate in the midst of Democrats’ attempt in 2010 to force through Obamacare against broad popular disapproval.
“What is different today is not the anger and apprehension felt by some in this country, but the inciting speech, dare I say encouragement, given by well-established folks in the seemingly mainstream political parties,” he said before ticking off the usual litany of quotes – taken out of context – by Nevada Republican candidate Sharron Angle, Texas GOP candidate Stephen Broden, Michele Bachmann (R-Minnesota), conservative commentator Glenn Beck, and finally Palin’s signature: “Don’t retreat, reload.”
Dingell’s lesson was entirely partisan, as he included no controversial examples from the Left such as Bill Maher’s riffs on wanting Dick Cheney and Rush Limbaugh dead or even now-President Obama’s famous quote from a 2008 Philadelphia campaign speech: “If they bring a knife to the fight, we bring a gun.”
Politics, as Charles Kruathammer pointed out, is a natural theater for battleground rhetoric. Indeed, Michigan is regularly referenced as “a battleground state.” Why? “Because fighting and warfare are the most routine of political metaphors,” writes Krauthammer. “Indeed, the very word for an electoral contest — ‘campaign’ — is an appropriation from warfare.”
Perhaps Obama understood this as he tried to damp his colleagues’ raging rhetoric at the Tucson memorial service Wednesday night. His speech “was a non-accusatory, genuinely civil, case for civility, in stark contrast to what we’ve read and heard over the last few days,” reviewed Rich Lowry of the National Review. “He subtly rebuked the Left’s finger-pointing, and rose above the rancor of both sides, exactly as a president should.”
Sadly, Dingell has shown no such leadership.
“Members of this body have a duty to speak up – as do members of the media – who have been saying these kinds of things,” Dingell concluded on the House floor. “(They) will lead us into a time when we will create a threat not just to the lives and well-being of our members but also to the lives and well-being of this country and its debates.”
Auto show: Welcome to Bizarro World ( The Michigan View 1.10.11)
Posted by hpayne on January 10, 2011
In 2010 the American truck was resurgent.
Sales of American trucks leapt 18 percent as the segment regained over 50 percent of market share. As financial fears and $4 gas prices receded in the rear-view mirror, American buying habits returned to normal: Americans prefer SUVs that ride high over smaller sedans. Cars shed 6 percent of market share and hybrid-electrics’ share plummeted 17 percent.
So when the North American Auto Show opens in Detroit Monday, automakers will emphasize . . . small cars and green hybrid-electrics?
Welcome to Bizarro World, the annual Detroit auto show press week where what’s inside the walls of Cobo has little to do with the real world outside. With some 5,000 practicing members of the Green Church – liberal journalists and their Washington Democratic allies – roaming the show floor, the automakers will entertain them with politically-correct talk about building small cars to meet federal 35 mpg standards to combat global warming.
Outside, temperatures are expected to drop to below-normal temperatures of 11 degrees with snow in the forecast in the midst of a brutal Detroit winter that has city shelters taking in 25 percent more homeless than usual. And one year ago, the Climategate scandal pulled the mask off the global warming science fraud.
The show’s Alice in Wonderland quality is an annual ritual. At this decade’s start for example, for example – while SUV sales roared – General Motors rolled out a 108 mpg concept called the Precept and Ford promised an 80 mpg family car by 2003 (financed by the taxpayer-funded $1 billion USCAR program). Neither car ever came to market, but boy did they wow the press pews.
The green propaganda is loudest this year from America’s two partially-nationalized automakers, GM and Chrysler, which were rescued by Washington in part because Obamacrats wanted Detroit to make the expensive electric cars they fancy.
GM will roll out its new sub-compact twins – the Chevy Sonic and Buick Verano – built in the taxpayer-rescued, UAW-staffed Orion Township plant. The cars will make nary a profit. Indeed, the tiny cars come to market after a year of big losses for subcompacts with even Honda’s vaunted Fit sales off 20 percent.
Fortunately for taxpayers, GM trucks from its Chevy and GMC lines flew off lots in 2010 (GMC sales rate was double that of GM’s sedans). And with a profit of $5,000 a copy and up, they helped the company repay millions in taxpayer loans.
Chrysler offers another stark contrast in reality vs. perception. Just down snow-covered Jefferson Avenue from its global-warming fighting show command post in Cobo Center, Chrysler’s Jefferson North plant is operating at full capacity churning out giant Jeep Cherokee SUVs (mpg: 18) which saw sales skyrocket in 2010.
So successful is the Cherokee that Chrysler CEO – and Fiat chief – Sergio Marchionne has ordered that the SUV be the platform for a new wave of trucks from Alfa Romeo and Maserati. Yet Chrysler will shy from telling this success story before the Green press, and will instead roll out a new version of its Chrysler 300 sedan Monday.
To be fair, automakers must offer a full range of vehicles in order to meet consumer tastes should gas prices return to $4 a gallon- as most automakers eventually expect. But the effort to hide SUVs – the market success story of 2010 – is still striking.
From Ford (an electric Focus) to Toyota (more members of its Prius hybrid family) to Hyundai (the little Veloster), major manufacturers will preen low-profit green. Manufacturers know that value of press reports that paint it with a green halo rather than an “immoral” triton and devil horns. And by producing cars that help meet Washington’s fanciful 35 mpg average fuel efficiency riles, they also avoid ugly headlines about government fines and public hearings.
Auto show marketing is cynical, but manufacturer are not stupid. When the show opens to the public on January 15, carmakers will roll out their full menu of SUVs and large sedans for the public. Indeed, visiting press week and public week are a study in contrasts as the public swarms the SUVs that the holy Greens reviled the week before.
Welcome to the Detroit Auto Show press week. It’s a parallel universe.
Why we love sports (and hate politics) ( The Michigan View 1.6.11)
Posted by hpayne on January 7, 2011
Rich Rodriguez was hired to produce a winning football program at one of America’s football powers, the University of Michigan. He failed. In three years, he compiled a mediocre 15W – 22L program. He went winless against U-M’s arch rivals, Ohio State and Michigan State. On Saturday, his team was humiliated on national television in the Gator Bowl, 52-14.
On Wednesday he was fired.
Results matter in football. It’s why we love sports. And it’s why we hate politics.
Contrast the fate of Rodriquez with that of another prominent state leader, Gov. Jennifer Granholm. With storm clouds gathering but unemployment at 6.7 percent after her re-election in 2006, Michigan’s first female governor (Rodriquez was Michigan’s first coach of Hispanic descent – but so what?) promised to address looming structural problems:. “In five years, you’ll be blown away,” she said. Four years later unemployment is12.8 percent, she has presided over two budget shutdowns, and she leaves the state with $1.5 billion budget hole.
Yet she is rewarded with coverage touting her record as a visionary pol whose only sin was having the bad luck to be in office at a time of difficult circumstances.
It’s enough to make you change the channel and look for a football game.
Sports reporters buried Rodriquez in a rising flood of vitriol, all but carrying him out the door. “Rich Rodriguez never truly fit with Michigan. His personality didn’t fit. His style of play didn’t fit,” harrumphed Adam Rittenburg at ESPN.com. “Rodriguez miscalculated badly, and so did Michigan. It’s a colossal failure and a brutally painful lesson for a once-hot coach and a once-unshakeable program: Be careful what you wish for,” groused The Detroit News’ Bob Wojnowski. “In ugly, out ugly.”
“Why wouldn’t Rich Rodriguez be fired? In three years, he didn’t win a single important game,” penned Mitch Albom of the Detroit Free Press.
Just the facts, ma’am. The guy didn’t get the job done.
Contrast this common sense sports coverage with a whole backfield full of writers, cheerleaders and excuse-makers willing to come to QB Granholm’s defense. “History has yet to write whether her unflagging efforts to diversify the economy in areas like advanced manufacturing, technology and alternative energy pay long-term dividends to the state,” writes Crain’s Amy Lane. “She was left a bad hand by John Engler, and, unfairly, was forced to be the face of job losses in the state when. . . many of the auto industry’s problems were the result of decades of gross corporate incompetence,” whined MLive’s Darrel Dawsey. “She must have been thinking, how things would be different if she was starting where Rick Snyder beings with the ‘wind at his back,'” apologized Tim Skubick in the Oakland Press.
Please. Granholm’s stimulus and green subsidy economic program was doomed from the start, a retro-Keynesian solution that has failed everywhere it’s been tried from Spain to the Obama White House.
A pet of the Big Labor establishment, she didn’t lift a finger to fix the state’s long-term structural problems — a direct contrast to reformist Governor Mitch Daniels in neighboring Indiana who also endured bearish, double-digit unemployment economy but balanced the state budget.
When Politico and The Huffington Post offered Granholm a national stage to trumpet her “achievements,” Michigan Capitol Confidential’s Tom Gantert called Politico to ask the Website to explain what qualified her for such a forum.
Now, that sounds like what a sports reporter would have done.
2010: Trucks climb, hybrids fall (Michigan View 1.5.11)
Posted by hpayne on January 5, 2011
A year after two Detroit automakers emerged from bankruptcy, 2010 offered signs of hope for the U.S. auto industry with the Big Three automakers all showing solid sales gains.
They have SUVs to thank.
Washington pols and their press parrots relentlessly touted a new wave of electric vehicles like the Chevy Volt and Nissan Leaf. But green hybrid sales dropped 14 percent to just 2.4 percent of the market last year while light trucks roared back to a majority of vehicle sales fueled by low gas prices and fatter consumer wallets.
As a result, GM, Ford, and Chrysler all saw healthy gains in their bottom line as SUVs carry a substantial profit margin over small car sales.
Chrysler Group reported U.S. sales of 1.1 million vehicles in 2010, up 17 percent compared to 2009 on the strength of its popular Jeep Grand Cherokee and Dodge Durango SUV products. And while President Obama heralded the company’s coming compact ” the tiny Fiat 500 ” Chrysler and Fiat chairman Sergio Marchionne prepared to expand the SUV lineup into Europe with Alfa Romeo and Maserati-badged trucks.
Ford sales were up 19 percent from 2009 on the strength of double-digit truck and car sales. And GM’s resurgence came on the back of 17 percent growth in its Chevy car and truck lines and a big 32 percent boost in GMC truck sales.
All told, trucks – which typically rake in twice the per vehicle profit of cars or more – gained three percent of total market share over a year ago to become the majority of vehicles sold in the U.S. at 50.2 percent. That’s good news for GM and Chrysler as they pay back big taxpayer loans.
The contrast in consumer tastes to Washington’s stated preference is startling.
President Obama and the Pelosicrats not only mandated vehicles get an average 35.5 mpg by 2015 but encouraged the sales of hybrids with $2500 subsidies. Yet sales of such vehicles actually declined.
On the whole, light trucks sales gained 18 percent while hybrid sales fell off by 5 percent. As manufacturers enter 2011 with oil on the rise at $100 a barrel, automakers will need to have a diverse lineup of vehicles to satisfy every consumer taste.
But 2010 made it clear that green is not an auto revolution ” it is just another niche of vehicle.
‘Cheap shot’: Guv, Brooks take the gloves off (The Michigan View 12.27.10)
Posted by hpayne on December 27, 2010
After eight years of division, bridge-burning, and kicking the can down the road, it was only appropriate that – in her last days as perhaps the state’s most ineffectual modern governor – Jennifer Granholm would take a shot at the state’s most effective pol, Oakland County Chief Executive Brooks Paterson.
“He through out his career has fanned the flames a lot,” she said of Patterson’s recent criticism of Detroit’s corrupt water department. “I urge him to come to the table with an open hand rather than a fist.”
Incendiary words from a Lansing politician whose ineffectiveness as governor has been in stark contrast to Patterson’s success as CEO of the state’s richest county. Indeed, as Granholm floundered in Lansing through two budget shutdowns, Patterson’s innovation in the face of reduced county revenue made him a rare bright spot in a leaderless landscape. “Inside Politics” political guru Bill Ballenger called Granholm Michigan’s worst governor while nationally-renowned, Lansing-based economist Pat Anderson called Patterson the “most successful elected official in Michigan.”
But the governor decided to stick her foot in it one more time. Patterson’s retort was typically frank.
“These were cheap shots, chicken shots,” he told Fox 2 News, noting that she made no similar remarks about the non-partisan Mayor Jim Fouts of Warren who has also been critical of Detroit corruption. “She’s a former prosecutor. . . either prove the charge or shut up.” Citing his extensive negotiations and contacts with Detroit officials, he said Granholm’s salvo showed “ignorance on her part. She doesn’t know what we’ve been doing. I’m disgusted. I think we’ve made a significant contribution to this state.”
Patterson also ridiculed Granholm’s attempt to take credit for diversifying the state’s economy, a strategy he says she stole from his own Automation Alley efforts in Oakland County. “The governor says her legacy is (economic) diversity,” said the Oakland County exec. “It’s absolute plagiarism.”
Granholm made her comments to Fox 2 political reporter Tim Skubick who was quick to came to the governor’s defense in his Oakland Press blog, blaming Patterson for forgetting “what time of the year this is…you know all that stuff about peace and good will.”
But Patterson’s reaction comes on the heels of similar remarks from outgoing Senate Majority Leader Mike Bishop (R-Rochester Hills), painting a picture of a governor who was more interested in scoring political points than getting things done.
“Gov. Granholm is a very smart lady,” Bishop told The Detroit News editorial board Dec. 10. “But she does not have one important thing: leadership instincts. She had a media machine that constantly attacked. I couldn’t leave town without fear of being attacked behind my back.”
The backstabs continue even as she exits the capitol.
Bishop says he warned Michigan voters in 2008 that “if you want your country to look like Michigan, then elect Barack Obama.” That is true not only of Granholm’s market socialist economic policies, but also of the deep partisan divide she has left in her wake.
Payne: Cash for Clunkers big tax hike ( The Michigan View 12.23.10)
Posted by hpayne on December 23, 2010
St. Louis – “SUVs’ comeback means bigger tax bills for some,” screamed the headline on the front page of the St. Louis Post-Dispatch December 23, and taxpayers in the Show Me State are livid.
Here (and in other states like Virginia and South Carolina), taxes are levied on personal property, and – thanks to Nancy Pelosi’s destruction of thousands of used SUVs under the 2009 Cash for Clunkers bill – the prices of used cars are actually rising as light truck sales make a comeback.
“The personal property tax on Lisa Kamper’s Saturn Outlook was $443 this year, about $65 more than she paid last year. The 2008 sport utility vehicle had increased in value — by nearly 13 percent,” writes Post-Dispatch reporter David Nunn. “Tony Lucia’s 2007 Dodge Ram is costing him more this year, too. Its value surged by 8 percent, his taxes by $41.”
Both cars are a year older, and, by conventional wisdom, should have lost value, costing their owners less. But when U.S. House Speaker Pelosi ordered the destruction of all vehicles she and her Democratic colleagues deemed “gas guzzlers” a year ago, it distorted the used car market for SUVs.
Now, with SUVs a hot ticket again – sales are 53 percent of the market despite Pelosi’s efforts to “green” the industry – demand is outstripping supply.
“The market values of many used trucks and sport utility vehicles have risen, for the first time in memory,” says the Post-Dispatch, resulting in “hundreds of complaints from truck and SUV owners with ballooning tax bills” in cities like St. Louis.
Car sales plummeted to 10 million vehicles in 2009 at the same Pelosi declared SUVs enemies of the planet and targeted them for destruction when traded in for a Washington-approved fuel sippers. For the first time ever, more vehicles were scrapped than built.
Now, SUVs are back and buyers are willing to pay for the limited supply.
“On some vehicles, we’re talking like 20 percent increases,” Jonathan Banks of the dealers association’s Used Car Guide told the Post-Dispatch. Car prices, he says, have increased by 3 percent nationally – but big SUV prices have soared by nearly 10 percent.
Large trucks like Chevy Tahoes or Ford Expeditions that are 1-5 years old went from $17,300 in late 2007 to about $23,500 this year. Some indexes, says Banks have put used-car prices at their highest levels ever.
“St. Louis city officials said it was the first time they had seen used cars increase in value,” reports the Post-Dispatch. The result is bigger taxpayers and angry phone calls from confused residents.
But it’s not Missouri officials they should be blaming. It’s soon to be ex-Speaker Nancy Pelosi.
Feds: Detroit organized crime family (The Michigan View.com 12.16.10)
Posted by hpayne on December 16, 2010
Using legal instruments designed to bring down mafia mob bosses, the feds’ massive, 38-count federal indictment Thursday of the “Kilpatrick Enterprise” – if true – exposes a political empire built on shakedowns of city and federal taxpayers for tens of millions of dollars through extortion and bribery.
While then 31-year-old prodigy Kwame Kilpatrick was elected mayor in 2002 promising a new generation of city leadership, he was apparently just the new generation family don – a junior Detroit Corleone who saw his position as an opportunity to milk constituents to grease the palms of family and friends.
He came by his behavior naturally. While her son and husband were being indicted Thursday, Mob Mom Carolyn Cheeks-Kilpatrick, Detroit’s soon-to-be-ex-representative in Congress, was shaking down – albeit legally – America’s taxpayers for $1.5 million in pork as Democrats forced through a last-minute omnibus spending bill in Washington.
The View’s Mike Brownfield has a full report here.
Cheek-Kilpatrick’s’ money grab came on top of news last week that she – and fellow Democratic Rep. John Conyers – were the only two members for the Michigan Congressional delegation to use taxpayer dollars for personal cars. How tacky – two state reps using the state’s poorest district to live a rich lifestyle.
Fox2 News reports about that here.
Indeed, Conyers is further proof that corruption is hereditary. His $80,000, $1250-amonth Cadillac Escalade Premium edition was leased – and illegally provided – for his 20-year-old son.
But as the Kilpatricks prove, Detroit corruption is a family affair. The federal indictment alleges that Kilpatrick and his father extorted “hundreds of thousands of dollars in cash, free flights and other benefits from a variety of contractors. Some of the allegations date back to Kilpatrick’s days as a state representative before he was elected mayor in 2001.”
The Detroit News has the full report here.
The 13 instances of extortion read like something out of The Godfather. Kwame’s pal Bobby Ferguson, a construction contractor, allegedly “kicked back at least $424,000 in cash and other benefits to the former mayor and Bernard Kilpatrick deposited more than $600,000 in cash into his personal bank accounts while his son was mayor,” reports The News. For example:
— The mayor canceled a $10 million sewer repair contract because the winning bidder refused Ferguson’s demand for a 25 percent share. He awarded the work to another contractor who agreed to Ferguson’s demand.
— Twice Ferguson extorted contractors for $10.4 million in work on sewer repair contracts for Detroit. And he extorted a company for $5 million in work on a combined sewer and recreational facility.
Kwame is already in federal prison for violating probation. “If you steal from taxpayers, you are going to be held accountable,” said U.S. Attorney Barbara McQuade after indicting the Kilpatricks under the RICO (Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act) act traditionally used to combat organized crime.
Organized crime? That’s the Kilpatricks all right.
Protesting in Cancun, freezing in Michigan (The Michigan View.com 12.15.10)
Posted by hpayne on December 15, 2010
Should Michigan voters support a plan to send billions in tax dollars to mitigate global warming’s effects in the Third World at a time when their state is setting records for cold weather, their per capita income is down 5 percent in a decade, unemployment is hovering near 13 percent, and Detroit warming shelters are expecting a 25 percent increase in homeless?
“That’s a strong way to put the question,” says Andy Hoffman, professor of sustainable enterprise at the University of Michigan’s School of Natural Resources and the Environment, who just retuned from sunny Cancun with a U-M delegation of 30 students and alumni to monitor the 2010 United Nation’s Climate Summit.
It’s a question global warming activists should get used to.There’s a new sheriff in town in Michigan’s Fred Upton, R-St. Joseph, the new chair of the House Energy and Commerce Committee, who with other Republican legislators will be keen on asking why the United States tripled its funding of global warming aid to developing nations — to $1.7 billion — this year when deficits are out of control and global warming legislation is a dead letter among the American people.
A green advocate, EPA veteran, and prolific author, Hoffman is unfazed by the brutal weather than greeted his companions upon their return from Cancun. “One cold snap is not a sign that global warming is losing steam,” he says, though the Green movement itself has made a history of exploiting warm weather events to advance its agenda. “There are long-term concerns about shifting weather patterns. Think of the droughts in Africa.”
Last year’s Climategate scandal, however, revealed that top global warming scientists were manipulating data to fit their pre-conceived unions. That scandal — and a decade of flat temperatures — have combined to gut public support of the climate movement. An unpopular House cap-and-trade bill — passed with the support of the entire Michigan Democratic delegation — fueled this fall’s tea party rage against a Democratic Congress that seemed intent on burdening a crippled U.S. economy rather than helping it to its feet.
Hoffman seems undeterred.
He says spending billions “to develop technology and components transfer to developing nations” is crucial in heading off a climate catastrophe. He says that Upton & Co. should find somewhere else to cut — perhaps defense spending at a time when the U.S. is fighting two wars on the Mideast terror front. He deflects a question as to whether fighting global warming is as important as fighting the War on Terror, but says it’s essential that the U.S. not only send billions aboard but invest billions at home to develop green technologies.
“We should be doing what China is doing in renewables, or else we’re going to be buying these technologies from abroad,” he says, sounding a common theme of green envy for the Communist nation that — ironically — is building a new coal plant at the rate of one-per-month while the GranObama administrations have strangled coal power here. “Any new technology requires government support”This is poppycock, of course.
From automobiles to cell phones, new products have succeeded in America because its markets are relatively free of government interference. Capital is finite, and the more capital is free to find its most efficient use, that is where prosperity will grow.
Michigan and the nation are desperate for that kind of prosperity. Its electorate has just voted to steer away from Green Democrats who have diverted one-sixth of the trillion-dollar stimulus package to green technologies.
Rather than traveling to Cancun to lobby for a post-warming, green utopian future funded by U.S dollars, Hoffman’s U-M students might have spent the week in a Detroit soup kitchen, seeing how the poor freeze when the state’s economic engine, the auto industry, doesn’t produce enough carbon-burning vehicles.
Cox: Obamacare ruling ‘a welcome sign’ (Michigan View.com 12.15.10)
Posted by hpayne on December 15, 2010
Judge Henry Hudson’s ruling Monday declaring Obamacare’s individual mandate unconstitutional gave a boost to Michigan Attorney General Mike Cox whose office has joined 19 other AGs in Florida in the Mother of All Lawsuits against the Democrats’ health scheme.
“Never before in our history have you had to buy something as the price of citizenship,” Cox said in a Monday press release. “Today’s ruling is a welcome sign that Michigan’s legal challenge to this unprecedented overreach by Congress and the President will succeed.”
The Virginia ruling comes just two months after another district court judge in Detroit dismissed a challenge to the Obamacare mandate
“If Congress can require this, then there’s no check on federal power,” added Cox on The Frank Beckmann Show Tuesday AM. While Cox will be relinquishing his office this January, incoming AG Bill Schuette has said he will continue the suit. “I’ll pass it on to him,” Cox told Beckmann. “I will be watching with great interest. This case is important to what we are as a people.”
Like Michigan’s challenge, the Virginia district court case questioned Washington’s authority to force Americans to purchase a product as the price of citizenship. “If Congress can require this, then there is no check on federal power,” he warned in an appearance on The Frank Beckmann Show Tuesday AM.
While narrow in its scope and only addressing Virginia’s statute banning the mandate, Hudson’s ruling was a blow to the cornerstone of Obama’s takeover of health care and echoed the larger AG’s suit that Obamacare is a violation of the Commerce Clause.
“A thorough survey of pertinent constitutional case law has yielded no reported decisions from any federal appellate courts extending the Commerce Clause or General Welfare Clause to encompass regulation of a person’s decision not to
purchase a product,” wrote Hudson. “The unchecked expansion of congressional power to the limits suggested by the Minimum Essential Coverage Provision would invite
unbridled exercise of federal police powers. At its core, the dispute is. . . about an individual’s right to choose to participate.”
Back in October, District Court Judge George Steeh in Detroit bought Obama’s argument that the mandate was not a violation of the Commerce Clause. “By choosing to forgo insurance plaintiffs are making an economic decision to try to pay for health care services later, out of pocket, rather than now through the purchase of insurance, collectively shifting billions of dollars, $43 billion in 2008, onto other market participants.”
The next arena for this battle comes Thursday when Florida Judge Roger Vinson will hold a hearing on motions for summary judgment in the case.
The conflicting opinions lead many observers to project the case will ultimately be settled by a deeply divided U.S. Supreme Court – an appropriate end to the highly partisan legislation that seeks to regulate nearly 20 percent of the U.S. economy. In a symbol of his divisive presidency, Obama is the first president to pass modern domestic legislation without a single vote from the opposing party.
True to form, Metro Detroit Congressional reps split on the Virginia decision along partisan lines.
“I have stood firm in my position that Congress had no authority to impose a mandate that an individual purchase health insurance,” said Republican Rep. Candice Miller in supporting Hudson’s decision.
By contrast, Democrat Rep. Sander Levin didn’t try to make a legal argument for the mandate – the administration has argued everything from tax law to the Commerce Clause to justify it – but simply said “a quality health care system for all Americans is built on the premise that responsibility is shared between employers, the government, and the individual.”
He also took a partisan shot at Hudson as a biased “Bush appointee.”
Granholmnomics is already the national model (12.11.10)
Posted by hpayne on December 12, 2010
After leading Michigan through a lost decade and her party to a resounding defeat on November 2, Governor Jennifer Granholm wants America to know that history will smile on her legacy. In a post-election public relations offensive, Granholm last week proclaimed herself a visionary who has built the foundation of a “Green Belt” economy in Michigan that should be implemented nationally.
It already has.
“If you want your country to look like Michigan, then elect Barack Obama,” Michigan Senate Majority Leader Mike Bishop warned Presidential-candidate John McCain in 2008 – explaining how Obama intended to follow the Granholm economic model of public stimulus and green tech subsidy.
Indeed, since taking office in 2009, Obamanomics has mirrored Granholmnomics with the same disastrous results: a stalled economy and a historic election defeat that gave a mandate to Republicans to reject European market socialism. In a defiant Detroit News interview and an op-ed article for both The Huffington Post and Politico, Granholm urges Michigan and America to stay the course.
Obama and Granholm are natural allies. Both are attractive, charismatic Harvard-trained lawyers with no experience in business, a missionary’s belief in spreading global warming gospel, and a zeal for green tech.
Convinced that Michigan must play a central role in their utopian vision of a post-carbon America, Obama recruited Granholm to lead a discussion of the “new economy” at the 2008 Democratic Convention and then tapped her expertise again for his economic policy team upon entering the White House in 2009.
The subsequent similarities between Obamanomics and Granholmnomics are striking. Compare, for example, Granholm’s January, 2008 State of the State address with an Obama campaign speech later that same year.
Granholm:
“I’m proposing a Michigan economic stimulus package — nearly a billion dollars for needed infrastructure and building improvements. But let me talk for a moment about one sector that has blockbuster potential for Michigan: alternative energy . . . . Because of the need to reduce global warming and end our dependence on expensive foreign oil, the renewable energy and energy efficiency industries will create millions of good paying jobs. I say we will win these jobs for Michigan and replace the lost manufacturing jobs with a whole new, growing sector.”
Obama:
“(My stimulus plan) will be a two-year, nationwide effort to jumpstart job creation in America and lay the foundation for a strong and growing economy. We’ll put people back to work rebuilding our crumbling roads and bridges, modernizing schools that are failing our children, and building wind farms and solar panels, fuel-efficient cars and the alternative energy technologies that can free us from our dependence on foreign oil and keep our economy competitive in the years ahead.”
Central to Granhobama economics is the belief that government should pick economic winners and losers – devoting public resources to investing in politically-favored, green companies.
In her HuffPo article, Granholm pretends that Michigan has been a “laboratory” and that “Washington can take a lesson from what is happening in Michigan,.” In fact, Granholm’s state vision has been entirely dependent on federal largesse – a fact that she later admits, writing that “we pancaked our state incentives on top of the competitive federal Department of Energy grants to advanced battery companies and suppliers.”
True to Obama’s 2008 speech, he has devoted stimulus money to feed his – and Granholm’s – new economy vision. “The American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 —Obama’s $787 billion stimulus — has been marketed as a jobs bill (that) has obscured its more enduring mission: a long-term push to change the country,” reveals Time Magazine’s Michael Grunwald.
“One-sixth of the total (stimulus) cost,” writes Time, “(this) is an all-out effort to exploit the crisis to make green energy, green building and green transportation real; launch green manufacturing industries.” In a “trickle-up” transfer of wealth from taxpayers to rich corporations, billons in federal dollars have gone to GM, Ford, South Korea’s LGChem, A123 Systems and other Big Green firms in Michigan – and other states.
“We need a moon shot – a Jobs Race to the Top,” writes Granholm. “Race to the Top” meet “21st Century Jobs Fund” – an identical, $2 billon state plan she put in place in 2006 in Michigan to award green companies with public funds (of 505 applicants, 67 won Michigan’s “race to the top” in the program’s first year).
“In five years, you’re going to be blown away,” she said in 2006. But five years later, Michigan’s unemployment rate has doubled. This time, she’s moderated her rhetoric to a national goal to “create three million new jobs in three years.”
Obama has followed her model to the letter – right down to the moon shot analogy. “We’re taking chances, because that’s how you put a man on the moon,” says the Energy Department’s Arun Majumdar about federal funding of grid-scale storage, solar energy and other green technologies are too costly to compete without subsidies.
The result? Like Michigan, the economic recovery since the recession ended in mid-2009 has been slow compared to past recoveries.
Though economically obtuse, Granholm’s article gives a glimpse into her – and her White House ally’s – sheer audacity.
“Here’s how it works,” she says. “Take funds the U.S. now spends on economic development programs (about $170 billion). Focus the competition on clean energy job creation. Devote the competition to rewarding the most effective public-private partnerships. (For example) state governments might give incentives for solar energy production.”
More humble policymakers would just return that $170 billion to the private sector. But Granholm and Obama want to be like private investment bankers making investment picks (turning government “into the world’s largest venture-capital fund,” says Time). The difference being that investment in their tax-funded venture is mandatory and does not have to produce financial results!
What happens when the subsidies run out? Just as Granobama have looked to Europe for inspiration, look to Europe for the fallout. In total financial collapse due to pursuing its reckless Greenomics, Spain is gutting the subsidies that have propped up its green experiment.
Granholm claims she (and Obama) have created the foundation for a new economy. But it is a model built on the quicksand of government subsidy.
Bishop: Mulhern ‘extremely counterproductive’ (THe Michigan View 12.9.10)
Posted by hpayne on December 9, 2010
In a candid, wide-ranging interview Wednesday with The Detroit News editorial board, departing Michigan Senate Majority Leader Mike Bishop, R-Rochester, painted first man Dan Mulhern as a crazy in-law in a dysfunctional Lansing political family that bickered through the last four years even as the state’s fiscal situation imploded. At a time when Michigan desperately needed leadership to address its fundamentals, Lansing instead was led by a feckless Gov. Jennifer Granholm and a split legislature where Democrats and Republicans deeply mistrusted one another’s motives.
“Dan Mulhern was never present during any negotiation I had. He has been extremely counterproductive,” said Bishop in response to Mulhern’s broadside this weekend blaming the senator for his wife’s troubled tenure. “It was like he was scared of her,” Mulhern told the Detroit Free Press. “So how do you negotiate with someone who is scared of you?”
“Gov. Granholm is a very smart lady,” said Bishop, who led the Republican Senate for the Democratic governor’s last term. “But she does not have one important thing: leadership instincts.”
Worse, Bishop described a governor more interested in political intrigue than in building bipartisan bridges. “She had a media machine that constantly attacked,” he said describing the pair’s chilly relationship. “She came at me all the time. It’s hard to build trust with someone who doesn’t’ want to bring down the wall. I couldn’t leave town without fear of being attacked behind my back.”
The result was a state government that shut down twice — in 2007 and 2009 — without a budget agreement. Granholm, Bishop said, would introduce reforms such as a service tax, but always as stalking horses to increase taxes – a non-starter for Republicans who feared tax hikes would send the wrong message at a time in which the state was struggling to retain businesses.
Indeed, the governor’s 12 percent hike in personal income taxes in 2007 did nothing to stem budget red ink, says Bishop. “It did damage to the business environment here and revenues fell off anyway because we were losing manufacturing.”
Meanwhile, Republican proposals also went nowhere unless Democrats extracted revenue hikes in return. Lacking the strategic skills of former Senate leader John Engler, Bishop nevertheless focused his caucus on union pay reform, proposing a five percent pay cut and 20 percent co-pays on health insurance to bring public workers’ costs more in line with the private sector. Bishop says he valued a solid relationship with Democratic House Speaker Andy Dillon – “Andy and I generally saw eye to eye” — though Dillon’s embrace of union reform increasingly cast him as a heretic in his own caucus.
This leaderless, rudderless menagerie of political doctors came at a time when the Michigan patient was suffering severe trauma to its vital signs. Hemorrhaging revenue as Detroit’s auto industry went south, the state budget was being consumed by entitlement costs (“Medicaid has ballooned 60 percent since 2000,” says Bishop) and union benefits. In addition, Granholm was strangling business with increased regulations.
In 2008, when the McCain for President campaign pulled up its Michigan stakes to concentrate elsewhere, Bishop pleaded (to no avail) with McCain to stay. He told McCain that Michigan should be his base camp. He told him that Granholmnomics was Obamanomics in practice.
He told McCain he should warn voters that “if you want your country to look like Michigan, then elect Barack Obama.”
Instead of addressing the state’s fiscal fundamentals, Granholm applied Band-Aids. Treated with budget tricks, tobacco settlement money, and federal stimulus dollars, the patient’s problems were masked. “The governor was never good at dragging the big issues across the finish line,” reflects Bishop.
Now the Snyder administration will inherit the mess. Bishop is optimistic that Michigan is fixable, ticking off a handful of reforms – “low-hanging fruit” he calls them – from holding department heads accountable for budgets to punishing pols who miss votes. “Snyder has a mandate to make big changes,” he says.
The biggest change needed? Leadership.
Chairman UpendObamacare ( The Michigan View 12.8.10)
Posted by hpayne on December 8, 2010
Maul the Midwest. Coddle California. Dictate to doctors. Hobble health care. Ban the bulb. Cancel coal. Destroy Detroit. Grovel to the Greens.
Goodbye to all that.
Chairman Henry Waxman (D-Left Coast) is out. Hail the new Chairman Fred Upton (R-Middle America).
In a demonstration of the sea change that November 2 has brought to Washington, Upton – an auto-friendly, Obamacare-reviling, global warming critic – has been given the reins over the House committee with perhaps more power to reverse President Obama’s radical agenda than any other: Energy and Commerce.
With jurisdiction over the EPA and the Department of Health and Human Series, Upton has a chance to deal crippling blows to Obama’s anti-carbon and pro-national health care vision. In an extraordinary turnabout, Michigan will go from being in the cross-hairs of Chairman Waxman, a Green religious zealot with a Left Coast disdain for “flyover country,” to being in the driver’s seat under the 13- term Chairman Upton from St. Joseph. Upton will also be a very different chair from the last Michigander to hold the post, John Dingell, who – though pro-auto – used the bully pulpit to preach socialized medicine.
Upton seems energized by the challenge.
“I look forward to standing shoulder to shoulder with Speaker Boehner, Leader Cantor, Whip McCarthy and the entire Republican Conference as we repeal Obamacare, fight rampant job-killing regulations, cut spending, and help put folks back to work,” he roared upon learning of his coveted new post Tuesday afternoon.
“We face many challenges, but priority number one is to repeal the job-killing Obamacare law,” continued Upton, signaling to the Tea Party-led electorate that Republicans heard them loud and clear.
Under Waxman, leftist HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius was given a free hand to impose Obamacare and demonize business. Just days after the election, Waxman applauded Sebelius’ new rules mandating how insurers had to spend their premium dollars..
“In today’s market, too many insurers – particularly in the individual health care market – charge high premiums and yet spend 30 percent or more on administrative costs, high salaries, and profits,” declared the Dictator from Beverly Hills.
Shot back Upton today: “If we have learned anything these last two years of soaring unemployment and out-of-control spending, it is that government is not the answer to all our ills.” Ultimately, Upton recognizes that his committee’s charge is not just to oversee – but to reverse Obama’s agenda entirely.
The congressman, who served in the Reagan Administration from 1981-5, told the Washington Examiner’s Byron York that his task is like the “game Jenga, in which small wooden blocks are stacked in a tower. Players remove blocks from the lower part of the tower and place them on the top, seeing how high they can raise the structure before it collapses from lack of support below.”
“Ultimately the tower falls,” Upton told York. “I’m convinced that if you take the health care law and begin to look at all of the different parts, you can make it fall.”
He will also fight a rogue EPA which Waxman gave free run to regulate carbon emissions in defiance of public will and the failure of Washington to pass cap and trade.” The Obama administration is on notice – they will not be allowed to regulate what they have been unable to legislate,” says Upton in direct shot across EPA’s bow.
Upton’s reward comes after a challenge from Joe Barton of Texas. Barton’s opposition was fueled by concern about Upton’s commitment to principle as he was a co-sponsor of the outrageous 2007 law that banned Americans from buying incandescent light bulbs by 2012. The law has not only denied consumers’ choice but destroyed hundreds of American manufacturing jobs. Upton, a team player by reputation, pushed the law on behalf of his president at the time, George Bush – who himself was trying to buy his way into Green heaven after a lifetime as an oil man.
Upton has indicated has learned his lesson. While repeal of Obamacare will take some time, Upton can reassure the troops immediately with one bold stroke:
Restore the bulb.
Tax cuts for the rich: Should Ilitch keep it or Pelosi spend it? (The Michigan View 12.3.10)
Posted by hpayne on December 3, 2010
As a punch-drunk America staggers towards a massive Washington tax left hook on January 1, Washington Democrats and their media chorus are framing it in the ol’ class warfare language of keeping tax cuts for the wealthy. But the premise is misleading. After all, “the wealthy” are people — entrepreneurs, innovators, job creators.
Here’s a better question: Is it better, for example, that entrepreneur Mike Ilitch keep his millions in Detroit — or ship them to Washington?
Remove the media class caricature and put a human face on America’s wealthy, and the choice is a no-brainer. The $10 million-a-year that Ilitch could keep from the Bush tax cuts, according to a back-of-the-envelope assessment of Ilitch’s tax bill by experts, would be a huge boon to Detroit from one of its savviest investors. Sending his hard-earned dollars to D.C., on the other hand, would guarantee its disappearance down a rat-hole of bureaucracy, administrative paperwork, politically-correct-experimental-green-projects, pork and so on.
“Who could do more with $10 million-a-year for the city of Detroit — Ilitch or the feds?” asks one financial expert drafted by The Michigan View.com to assess Ilitch’s tax exposure.
Ilitch, and “the wealthy” like him in Michigan — DeVos, Meijer, Penske, Gilbert, Taubman, Brown, and so on — are human job engines. They are economic multipliers — investors capable of mobilizing not just their own millions but inspiring investment from others in more businesses, communities and cities. Ilitch, for example, is currently pursuing a multi-million dollar strategy for downtown Detroit that would further define its core city as a destination for sports and entertainment and multiply opportunities for restaurants and small retail. Every dollar that he spends in Detroit means jobs and development.
As a privately-held company, we do not know Ilitch Holdings’ tax liability, or how much they have saved from the Bush tax cuts. But we do know that in 2010 Mike Ilitch is #238 on America’s wealthiest list with a net worth of some $1.7 billion. The Michigan View.com asked local financial experts — top area accountants and a money manager – to conservatively estimate what Ilitch would have to cough up to the feds if tax cuts were to expire on Americans making more than $250,000 a year.
Iltich’s holdings are vast — from sports teams to real estate to restaurants — but we asked our gurus to make very general, rule-of-thumb estimates of his potential income. They settled on three pillars: income earnings, capital gains, and real estate capital gains. To make our estimate as simple as possible, we reduced it to two: income and capital gains, both of which will be subject to Obama’s New Year tax hike.
Estimating a ten percent profit, Ilitch’s taxable income would be $170 million in his 35 percent top bracket – or $59 million. If the Bush tax cuts expire, Ilitch’s tax rate would increase by 4.6 percent to 39.6 percent or an increased tax bill of $8.3 million.
Capital gains? Conservatively estimating 30 percent of his wealth is in paper ($510 million), our experts estimated a 5 percent capital gains profit or a $3.8 million tax bill. An expiration of Bush capital gains cuts would raise the rate from 15 to 20 percent for a net gain for the feds of another $1.3 million All told an increased IRS tab for one of Detroit’s most productive citizens of about $10 million-a-year. Or a staggering $50 million over five years. Send it to Washington and it would go through the sausage mill: appropriations, benefits, federal union rules, redistribution to states, administrative costs. . . .
Or Mr. Ilitch would keep his tax cut, and the $10 million to $50 million might never leave Detroit, one of America’s poorest cities, a city in need of millions in investment from entrepreneurs like Ilitch who are eager to do just that, creating jobs, local tax revenue, and quality of life.
“I’d much rather Ilitch spend his money supporting the Tigers’ pitching staff than masking unsustainable federal spending,” muses James Hohman, an economist with The Mackinac Center.
Tax cuts for the wealthy sounds better all the time.
Volt: Back to the Future (The Michigan View 12.1.10)
Posted by hpayne on December 1, 2010
The Mighty GM Publicity Machine and its Media Chorus put on a show in Hamtramck, Michigan Tuesday, introducing the General’s new Chevy Volt electric car with anticipation not seen since . . . well, since GM last rolled out its ill-fated EV-1 electric car just over a decade ago.
Even by Detroit’s carnival barker standards, the first plug-in Chevy Volt to come off the assembly line generated an impressive display of hyperbole and myth-making. But then, not every vehicle launch is accompanied by politicians and the full-backing of the federal government. Washington’s ruling class has proclaimed the Volt a revolution in automobility (and GM is more than happy to milk the free publicity) which gave the event the air, if not the reality, of a game-changing moon-shot.
“Every aspect of the Volt — from its aerodynamic shape to its battery chemistry — is a testament to the importance of math and sciences,” crowed Chief Carnival Barker Mark Reuss, President of GM North America, about the egg-shaped vehicle before him. “By encouraging Detroit-area students to pursue these topics, we hope to cultivate the next generation of engineers who will build upon the Volt’s innovative technologies.”
Actually, the Volt’s battery-driven technology is hardly new.
The battery lost out to the internal combustion engine (its current direct-injection evolution is itself a marvel of the math and sciences) in the early 20th century and has been playing catch-up ever since. What has changed is consumer taste. In 21st century, three-car garage America, automakers have discovered a new niche – not unlike sports-car-buying motor heads who covet Chevy Corvettes – of influential green buyers.
The current darling of this niche class might as well be steam power, the other technology that displayed early auto promise before succumbing to the ICE’s superior mix of cost and convenience.
Why, if this GM electric thing fails for a second time (after a now-familiar greengasm of ecstasy over the EV-1’s revolution, a fickle press quickly soured in 1996 when the little electric didn’t get the advertised 100 miles-per-charge and sales sagged). . . imagine – imagine! – a car that only runs on water, that is lighter than a combustion engine (well, if you leave out the boiler), that has instant torque and is as easy to refill as your local creek, and. . . and we’ll call it the GM Stanley Steamer!
And Senator Carl Levin can take credit for it.
Yes, Senator Levin. Since the automobile is the most regulated consumer product on the planet, political interference is inevitable. And so in addition to today’s roll-out of the global warming-fighting, foreign oil-independent Volt (which draws its electricity from coal and gets its lithium batteries from mines in Australia and South America) we also got Carl wheeling out his giant straw man.
“We’ve always known there would be doubters,” said the Michigan Senator in a letter to GM’s CEO – leaked for the occasion, natch. “Congratulations on answering them so well. (TheVolt) is testament to the notion that industry and government can work in partnership to advance the complimentary goals of strengthening our industrial economy and protecting our environment.”
Actually, no one ever doubted GM – America’s biggest car company – could build an electric car. But plenty have reason to doubt whether it will ever sell above cost (the $41k wonder costs $40 k to produce), whether it’s good policy for American taxpayers to be subsidizing rich celebrity buyers like Leo DiCaprio at $75000 per Volt sold, and whether anyone other than green elites will pay $41 k for a glorified Chevy Cruze with gas at $2.90 a gallon.
Hamtramck was a glorious place to be Tuesday morning as American ingenuity polished another beautifully-engineered product. But while pols were high-fiving each other over their joint government-industry, planet-saving small car . . . just a few miles south on I-75 in Detroit, Jeep Assembly was cranking at full-speed, three-shifts-a-day, 24-hours-a-day to meet America’s unslakable thirst for $30,000, V-6 –powered Jeep Grand Cherokee SUVs.
And they make a nice profit of $5 grand apiece.
Governor Gra – mole?
Posted by hpayne on November 30, 2010
The big day has arrived. You’re front and center at the unveiling of the Chevy Volt, the car, the icon, the manifestation of your dream as governor of a Michigan reborn as a Green Belt manufacturing state.
And all the GM CEO can think about is your moles.
Gramole_GM“And, uh. . .Governor Gramole. . . there you are. Thank you very much for being here,” misspoke GM’s new CEO Dan Akerson this morning as he struggled with the governor’s name. The bright side? At least he didn’t mention her ears.
New boss, same as old boss: Calley’s insurance mandates (The Michigan View 11.29.10)
Posted by hpayne on November 29, 2010
Governor Rick Snyder says he wants to make Michigan more business friendly. He may want to tell his lieutenant governor.
Brian Calley raised some eyebrows this summer upon his appointment to be Snyder’s right-hand man when Lansing watchers recalled it was Calley who had co-authored the very Michigan Business Tax Frankenstein that Snyder had targeted as a centerpiece of his campaign. The Snyder team quickly assured his supporters that Calley’s MBT tryst was not love, but a necessary evil to end the disastrous budget shutdown.
But only days after the Snyder-Calley team has been swept into office, Calley is once again stepping on his governor’s pro-business message by making Granholm-esque insurance company-bashing a priority. Is this really how the The Nerd wants his administration to come out of the blocks?
Conservatives quickly jumped on Calley’s latest anti-business brickbat ” mandated autism coverage – with The Detroit News editorializing that “one of the few competitive advantages Michigan has on health care costs is that it doesn’t have a lot of health insurance mandates – rules requiring that health insurance provide coverage or specific treatments for particular diseases or disorders that drive up coverage costs.”
In the midst of a decade-long recession, Michigan would seem ill-served by giving up any competitive advantage. But Calley has aggressively pressed his point with news interviews, a letter to The News, and now an appearance Monday morning on the Frank Beckmann Show with autism activist Steve Bockmann.
“So-called insurance ‘mandates’often elicit knee-jerk opposition, but I urge Michigan legislators to think beyond short-sighted responses. The opportunity to turn around the lives of children with autism is available, but it is out of reach for most Michigan families because the cost of treatment can reach $50,000 annually,” Calley ” who has a four-year-old with autism ” wrote in The News. “Twenty-three states have already reformed their laws to cover autism. Now Michigan must step into the 21st century. Michigan must resist the status-quo mentality that leads some to reject autism insurance reform, especially when the fiscal and human benefits to the state would be so overwhelming.”
Government knows best? Everybody else does it? It’s the future? Where have we heard that before?
Yes, those are the guiding principles of the Jennifer Granholm – used to mandate, for example, renewables by Michigan utilities and drive up the cost of Michigan energy ” a program staunchly opposed by Snyder/Calley in the campaign.
Like Granholm and Big Utiltiy, Calley apparently believes Big Insurance doesn’t know its own business. “Autism is a complex condition and medicine’s understanding of it is rapidly changing,” says The News editorial. “A state coverage mandate introduces unknowns into the state insurance market, which is itself in flux because of changing federal law.”
There are a myriad of conditions that companies must study every day (here’s another one – dyslexia which afflicts my family) which is precisely why we have markets ” so that they can design policies that best suit their clients.
The Michigan and American electorates revolted against Know-it-all Democratic politicians who think they know better. Incredibly, one of the recipients of that revolt ” Republican Brian Calley ” seems not to have gotten the message.
Obamacare carnage: Kids lose union health coverage ( the Michigan View 11.29.10)
Posted by hpayne on November 29, 2010
Think opposition to insurance mandates only comes from heartless small businesses? That Obamacare saves money? That there aren’t consequences to Big Government mandates?
Then get a load of this headline at The Wall Street Journal today: “Union Drops Health Coverage for Workers’ Children.”
Why? Because Obamacare’s mandates have made it too expensive for the SEIU ” yes, the same SEIU that is one of the biggest liberal union, Democratic lobbies in the country ” to continue insurance coverage of its employees.
“One of the largest union-administered health-insurance funds in New York is dropping coverage for the children of more than 30,000 low-wage home attendants,” reports The Journal. “The union blamed financial problems it said were caused by the state’s health department and new national health-insurance requirements.”
How has Obamacare destroyed insurance coverage for kids?
“New federal health-care reform legislation requires plans with dependent coverage to expand that coverage up to age 26,” (the union) wrote in a letter to members Oct. 22. “Our limited resources are already stretched as far as possible, and meeting this new requirement would be financially impossible.”
“The fund informed its members late last month that their dependents will no longer be covered as of Jan. 1, 2011,” continues The Journal. “Currently about 6,000 children are covered by the benefit fund, some until age 23.”
Ah, those compassionate liberals.
The Volt’s Reason to Be (National Review 11.26.10)
Posted by hpayne on November 29, 2010
Critics of the Chevy Volt rightfully point out that GM’s new plug-in hybrid is an overpriced Chevy Cruze, that it is not a revolution-in-the-making but a niche vehicle, and that it should stand on its merits without expensive taxpayer subsidies. But those critics also assume a rational world.
The world American automakers live in today, though, is highly irrational — governed by irrational Washington agencies that have bipartisan political support to draft irrational mpg mandates that force carmakers to irrationally build cars consumers don’t want to buy.
The Chevy Volt is GM’s rational answer to irrationality.
This week, the EPA announced that the Volt will get an EPA MPG rating of 60 mpg, which will go a long way towards helping the company meet the government’s absurd 35 mpg average for all the vehicles the company makes. That is, since consumers prefer cars that get 21 mpg on average (53 percent of vehicles bought today are SUVs, after all), GM can throw in the Volt’s 60 mpg to goose up its fleet average and avoid millions in federal fines and public execution by the national media.
The EPA arrives at its 60 mpg figure with a suitably obtuse averaging of the Volt’s 93 mpg on battery power alone (which it can manage for up to 35 miles) and the 37 mpg it will get on the car’s tiny 1.4-liter gas engine once the battery runs out of juice. All of these ratings will appear on the $41,000 window sticker of the Volt in a blizzard of mumbo-jumbo that will make its rich green buyers feel good about saving the planet.
It will also make GM feel good about meeting the fed’s ridiculous rules.
And it will make everyone else feel $7,500 lighter in the wallet from the subsidy of each Volt sold.
The ‘Recovery Fall Tour’: More Subsidies for the Rich ( National Review 11.24.10)
Posted by hpayne on November 24, 2010
Goodbye “Recovery Summer Tour.” Hello “Recovery Fall Tour.” Different name, same waste of taxpayer dollars.
At a Chrysler facility in Kokomo, Indiana today, President Obama stubbornly continued his pre-election theme that the UAW bailout and green jobs are rescuing the American economy. The president, Veep Biden, and Fiat/Chrysler Chief Sergio Marchionne touted Chrysler’s $300 million investment of taxpayer money into the Indiana plant to build a new generation of transmissions.
But the president’s visit only managed to highlight again the stimulus’s “Robbing Hood” economics: stealing from taxpayers to pay big corporations. Obama’s posse was accompanied by Delphi executive Gary Cameron, whose company was the recipient of $89 million in federal stimulus money to help “transform America” into a green economy.
Delphi will use its tax dollars to build green-vehicle components to be used in hybrid cars targeted at buyers making over $100,000 a year. The grant “definitely improved our competitive position,” said Cameron. “Kokomo is obviously a manufacturing site today because of the stimulus-partnership money.”
In addition to Delphi, federal stimulus has also gone to Korean multinational LGChem and A123 Systems to make green batteries for upper-class chariots


