Articles Blog

Payne: Friedman vs. freedom

Posted by hpayne on May 31, 2012

Mackinac Island – Mackinac Policy Conference keynote speaker and liberal icon, New York Times columnist Thomas Friedman, told an overflow crowd at the Grand Hotel Thursday that the world is turning away from the United Sates and looking to China as the model for the 21st century.

America’s most notable new émigré, Chinese dissident Chen Guangcheng, might beg to differ.

Writing in Friedman’s paper on Wednesday, Chen condemned China as a lawless nation. His home country “inflicted (punishment) on me and my family over the past seven years,” writes Chen. “The fundamental question the Chinese government must face is lawlessness.”

Indeed, China is less a model for the 21st century than a relic of the 20th, a century that saw the American model of democratic capitalism triumph over both German fascism and Russian communism. Today, China is a hybrid totalitarian-fascist state – a government with one boot on the industrial accelerator and the other planted firmly on its people’s necks. And as last century, 21st century Chinese like Chen wish it were more like America.

Friedman, however, envies the Chinese model – infamously titling a chapter of “Hot, Flat, and Crowded,” his 2008 book, “China for a Day” in which he dreams of an American dictatorship that can impose Friedman’s vision of a green, post-carbon economy to prevent global warming.

“Watching (the) climate/energy debates in Congress, it is hard not to draw the following conclusion: There is only one thing worse than one-party autocracy, and that is one-party democracy, which is what we have in America today,” he wrote in a 2009 Times column. “One-party autocracy certainly has its drawbacks, but when it is led by a reasonably enlightened group of people, as China is today, it can also have great advantages.”

Disturbing stuff from a man whose own opinions are protected by the Bill of Rights – an alien concept in his Utopian China. But what Friedman fails to grasp is that the same totalitarian government with the power to ban things he doesn’t like (“Bam! Just like that – 1.3 billion people, theoretically, will stop using thin plastic bags,” he thrills in “Crowded” about China damning plastic bags), can also ban things he likes. Like Chen’s speech.

Friedman never mentioned Chen in his Mackinac talk.

Chen would have inconveniently forced Friedman to admit that liberty is what makes America the envy of the world. Instead, Freidman ludicrously claims that what made America a superpower is a five-part “formula” (a formula the Obama Administration has enthusiastically embraced with ruinous effect on the nation’s economic recovery):

1) Education

2)The best infrastructure

3)The most open immigration policies

4)The best rules and institutions

5)Most government-funded research

Well, he got #4 right. But to suggest that millions of immigrants like Chen flock to the U.S. because of our “infrastructure” is laughable. They come for freedom. The freedom to realize the fruits of their hard work. To own their own property. To start their own business. To speech.

In short, the freedom from Big Government, the historical enemy of liberty.

But here is where it gets really weird. Deep down, Friedman knows this. Responding to a question from moderator Devin Skillian, Friedman said we are beating China. Say what? “I would start to fear China when they are stealing our sauce,” said the columnist who has spent the last 30 minutes explaining how China had stolen our sauce. ” Without a Bill of Rights, he said, China can never be a rich nation. “When you steal those, I’ll worry.”

Huh? You can envy Chinese totalitarianism. Or you can envy the American Bill of Rights. But you can’t do both.

It is this utter confusion that betrays Friedman as today’s most overrated thinker. A brilliant reporter when on the ground (his must-read Middle East reports, for example) columnist Friedman is incoherent when organizing his facts into a cohesive philosophy.

The Times man’s appearance at Mackinac was breathlessly anticipated by Detroit’s establishment. But his failure to grasp what makes America the greatest nation in the history of humankind simply takes your breath away.

Payne: Stabenow defends her title

Posted by hpayne on May 30, 2012

Mackinac Island – Incumbent Michigan Democratic Senator Debbie Stabenow will get a pass on her waste of federal money on green energy boondoggles and Pete Hoekstra will get grilled on whether he’s a birther.

Welcome to the Michigan Senate race 2012.

Stabenow and her potential challengers, Hoekstra and Clark Durant, appeared on the same stage for the first time on Mackinac Island Wednesday in a preview of one of the country’s heavyweight Senate matchups this fall. But in a clunky format, the three candidates appeared individually, never faced one another, and were at the mercy of inept moderator Rick Plute of Michigan Public Radio.

The U.S. may be mired in its worst recovery since the Great Depression, record deficits, and 8 percent unemployment, but moderator Plute was intent on painting Hoekstra as a birther and Durant as a tea party fossil advocating a part-time federal legislature.

Stabenow, meanwhile, showed why she will be a formidable opponent.

With MSM-MPR running protection on her record, she smiled sweet platitudes while taking credit for saving the Detroit auto industry. If Al Gore created the Internet, then Debbie Stabenow created the GM resurgence.

“I authored” seemed to begin every Stabenow sentence as she took credit for the Big Two bailouts, (sorry, “bridge loans” is the market-tested term), manufacturing retooling loans, advanced battery subsidies, Cash for Clunkers, and the sun coming up in the east.

But how to get America’s economy jump-started? Ummmm . . . . “The greatest opportunity for us is clean energy technology. It’s all about innovation,” she claimed, despite the fact that Obama/Stabenow investments in Solyndra, Evergreen, A123 Systems, and other “innovative” companies have been financial black holes.

Faced with this waste of taxpayer dollars, MPR’s Pluta asked Stabenow . . . whether she was in favor of Senate filibuster reform. Really.

The grilling would come from Durant and Hoekstra who both opened fire on Stabenow over the national debt.

“We are crushing our kids,” protested Durant, a successful Detroit charter school entrepreneur who champions a record as Mr. Fixit. “There’s not a business here that would keep this team in place with that kind of performance. Thank you, Debbie and Pete, for your service, but we need different answers.”

But the only answer Pluta was interested in was whether Durant wanted a volunteer Congress ” badgering the candidate about why he allegedly had a problem with paying public officials.

Payne: The McCotter Politics Conference

Posted by hpayne on May 30, 2012

The Mackinac Policy Conference? Call it the McCotter Politics Conference.

GOP Rep. Thad McCotter’s ballot blunder dominates discussion among this year’s Republican-friendly conference of business and political movers and shakers. There is general confusion on how McCotter’s campaign could have screwed up the most basic task in politics – getting 2,000 signatures to qualify for the primary ballot – but consensus that McCotter is a moron.

“(McCotter’s district) was one of the top 10 safest in the country,” said Oakland County Executive Brooks Patterson disgustedly on the Frank Beckmann Show this morning. Patterson thinks the ballot SNAFU must have been sabotage.

He is not alone. Many political pros can think of no other explanation. It is that inexplicable. One pro even suggested to me that McCotter sabotaged the ballot himself in order to get out of running for Congress (is that any stranger an explanation than running for president to get out of Congress?).

But sabotage would suggest a mole. Unlikely. More likely, say most, is that McCotter’s staff simply forgot the ballot deadline and rushed to meet it with a cut and paste mess. That’s not only dumb – it’s fraud. And heads are likely to roll before this is over.

Meanwhile. . . who will be the GOP nominee for the 11th district?

Stu Sandler, an experienced Michigan political pro, says McCotter is McToast. “A write-in campaign is an overly complicated task,” he says. A task too large for a candidate who has struggled to raise money in the past. Rusty Hills, a Michigan Republican vet, points to Alaska Senator Lisa Murkowski’s write-in win in 2010 as evidence it can be done.

But the consensus is McCotter won’t be the man. Which means Kerry Bentivolio – a candidate most Republicans agree is a Ron Paul wing nut yet is the only name on the ballot – will be the GOP candidate Which Democrats are salivating over.

Thanks a lot, Thad, sigh Mackinac Republicans.

Payne: McCotter McToast?

Posted by hpayne on May 29, 2012

Thad McCotter is toast.

That’s the word from one longtime Republican Party insider who says on condition of anonymity that McCotter’s “bizarre” inability to do his most basic electoral duty – get his name on the GOP primary ballot – calls into question whether he should be in charge of anything, much less a Congressional district. Combined with McCotter’s loose-cannon style (the notoriously aloof Livonia native has never been considered a team player by his party brothers) and the very real possibility that his campaign may be charged with fraud, Republicans are unlikely to return the five-term congressman to office this fall.

Michigan pundits are also ripping McCotter’s McFumble.

“It’s hard to imagine blundering on this cosmic a scale,” says Michigan political watcher Bill Ballenger who says the wheels have been coming off McCotter ever since he took up his guitar and thought he could outplay Mitt Romney for the GOP nomination last year. “Something’s wrong.”

“After all if you can’t count to 1,000, why in the heck should anybody send you back to Congress where they count higher than that everyday,” writes Tim Skubick at MLive.com. “Just what is the number of the national debt?”

McCotter may yet pull out a write-in win, but party insiders aren’t counting on it. They say the party is pursuing two other options: Get behind the only GOPer on the ballot, the relatively unknown Kerry Bentivolio – or get behind a better known candidate of the party’s choosing who would run as a write-in or as an Independent. Michigan law allows an Independent candidate with 3,000 signatures to file by July 19 – and names are already making the rounds, from Rocky Raszkowski to Mike Kowall.

Bentivolio is obviously in the catbird’s seat as the only GOPer on the ballot. The tea party favorite deserves the party’s consideration – especially as a four-time McCotter voter who had the foresight that something wasn’t right with his rep – and is not untested given his second place finish to Kowall for state Senate in 2010. He isalso running against two Democratic unknowns (one a LaRouchie) in a 55 percent-Republican district.

But nervous GOP big wigs will be weighing their options this weekend on Mackinac Island. Having failed Politics 101, McCotter is not popular in the party. “The real issue,” says Ballenger, “is whether the party drops everything to get him elected a write-in. I’m not hearing any great urge to pull his fat out of the fire.”

On the Frank Beckmann Show Tuesday, McCotter said you have to be and “idiot” to think that his quixotic presidential run was a distraction. After his disastrous ballot failure, “he needs to be careful about who he’s calling an idiot,” says my GOP insider.

Payne: Truth stranger than satire

Posted by hpayne on May 23, 2012

In the satire game these days, it’s hard to stay one step ahead of reality.

As the Detroit News cartoonist, I’ve regularly lampooned Washington’s “greening” of the automobile with an eco-NASCAR send-up. This one is from 2011. This one from 2008. This one from 2004. And so on.

Now comes the real news headline, courtesy of the Washington Examiner, that NASCAR is partnering with the EPA to green the sport:

According to the Environmental Protection Agency, NASCAR will encourage fans to buy “sustainable concessions” at races, expand the use of “safer chemical products,” conserve water, reduce waste, promote recycling, push products approved by the EPA that have a small enviro footprint and encourage suppliers to get an “E3 tuneup” aimed at promoting sustainable manufacturing.

This after NASCAR had already buckled to the EPA (and Big Ethanol) on using E15 fuel (apparently, reducing world corn supplies to the needy by diverting corn to politically-connected Big Ethanol is what passes as good corporate citizenship these days). Once the rebel of sports — a distinction that attracted a Live Free or Die, anti-government demographic and the iconic NASCAR Dad — NASCAR’s heavy corporate sponsorship is turning it PC.

“This collaboration is a statement of NASCAR’s commitment to green innovation and our role as a leader in sustainability,” said Mike Lynch, NASCAR managing director of green innovation. NASCAR director of green innovation? We can’t make this stuff up.

Will the satirical poster that accompanies this post be reality come 2015?

Payne: Turning their backs on progress

Posted by hpayne on May 21, 2012

Henry Payne/ The Michigan View.com

St. Louis – Last week at Washington University’s (and my son’s) graduation ceremony, one of the Midwest’s most prestigious universities honored one of its city’s most prominent citizens – a man whose company has developed technologies that have transformed agriculture and fed millions while making cropland more environmentally sustainable.

But when Chancellor Mark Wrighton called the name of former Monsanto CEO Richard Mahoney to receive his honorary degree, some 100 green student activists and alumni stood up and turned their backs in protest.

That Mahoney, who spearheaded the development of game-changing, genetically-modified crops, is a controversial figure says a lot about the American Left today.

Our colleges school students about the importance of getting involved – of solving the problems of hunger and poverty in the world. That is what Mahoney and his fleet of engineers have dedicated their lives to. Since 1960, the St. Louis company has led a productivity revolution that has more than doubled crop yields without increasing the area of land used. This revolution defied the Apocalyptic claims of the Left (before global warming, greens were obsessed with famine) that the world would run out of food by the end of the 20th century.

” If farmers were still producing food at 1960 levels of productivity, agriculture would have had to expand from 38 percent of the earth’s land to 82 percent to feed the world’s current population,” reports Ronald Bailey of Reason magazine. “This enormous increase in yields is the result of applying more artificial fertilizers, breeding higher yielding crops, a wider use of pesticides and herbicides, and expanding irrigation. More recently, advances in modern biotechnology have also contributed to boosting yields.”

Mahoney is one of the giants of this technological feat. From corn to wheat, his company developed crops that proved resistant to disease and drought – increasing crop yields at the same time they needed fewer pesticides in order the thrive.

These advances steadily increased crop yields in the U.S. (even as production has leveled off in hysterically anti-biotech Europe) – but created a boon in developing countries where help was needed most. For example, “biotech insect resistant cotton varieties have boosted the yields for India’s cotton farmers by 45 to 63 percent,” reports Bailey. “Similarly, biotech insect resistant corn varieties increased yields (or prevented losses) by 24 percent in the Philippines.”

For this, Mahoney gets booed? His industry’s breakthroughs are as misreported as they are significant.

Type a Google search on “Monsanto genetically-modified foods” and you are met by a wall of hysteria and misinformation from mainstream media outlets to Greenpeace to academics. Gorged on this ignorance, Washington University students protested Mahoney’s honorary degree. “Wash. U. should not award such a prestigious honor to someone responsible for a company that seeks to profit off the destruction of our agricultural system,” wrote one protestor. Destruction?

In addition to feeding the world, Monsanto has made this student’s university a powerhouse in American education. Aided by tens of millions in Monsanto contributions, Wash. U. churns out engineers and biology majors who will continue Mahoney’s groundbreaking work. Now retired, Mahoney gives his time to mentor students in the Olin School of Business. My son and his business colleagues were upset that activists stole next-day news headlines for their graduation stunt.

These activists are the children of the anti-business, anti-science Obama administration that is poisoning today’s airwaves with messages of class warfare and green extremism. The Mahoneys of the world can only be successful as long as governments make sensible regulations.

In 2006, Michigan Governor Jennifer Granholm bravely signed into law a statute forbidding attempts by her Green allies to prevent Michigan farmers from using genetically-modified seeds – potentially devastating the state’s #2 industry where 32 percent of corn and 90 percent of soy are genetically engineered. Those activists no doubt cheered at the negative publicity from Washington University last week.

Fortunately, however, its newest degree recipient never turned his back on the world’s hungry.

Payne: Levin’s JP Morgan scapegoat

Posted by hpayne on May 13, 2012

“(This) is an exact description of the type of risk-taking that got us into this financial crisis and recession,” said Oregon Senator Jeff Merkley in a joint news conference with Michigan Senator Carl Levin this week jumping on a $2 billion loss by JP Morgan as evidence that banks caused the 2008 financial crisis and that they need even more federal regulation.

That’s rich.

Actually, Carl Levin and his fellow Washington meddlers caused the 2008 financial crisis with years of excessive intervention in the U.S. housing market. Their actions since then – echoed by a clueless mainstream media – have been to try and rewrite the history books even as their renewed attempts at regulation are only further deepening America’s economic crisis.

Yes, a ticking time bomb of recklessly-bundled, credit-challenged mortgage securities eventually went off, cratering the housing market and crippling the taxpayer-backed U.S. banking system. But those mortgages would not have been issued in the first place were it not for Levin’s relentless push to weaken mortgage lending standards by Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae.

The Community Reinvestment Act (CRA), a regulatory poison pill prescribed by Dr. Levin himself, is at the root of the 2008 financial collapse – and proof that less Washington, not more, is the key to a healthy American economy.

Using the CRA, say experts, Democrats and housing activists had long ago planted the seeds for the next decade’s housing debacle. “Both ACORN and the Clinton administration were working together to impose large numerical targets or ‘set asides’ (really a sort of poor and minority loan quota system) on Fannie and Freddie,”reported National Review’s Yuval Levin (no relation) in 2008. ” Eventually ACORN got what it wanted. In early 1994, the Clinton administration floated plans for committing $1 trillion in loans to low- and moderate-income home-buyers, which would amount to about half of Fannie Mae’s business by the end of the decade. Thissweeping debasement of credit standards was touted by Fannie Mae’s chairman, chief executive officer, and now prominent Obama adviser James A. Johnson. This is also the period when Fannie Mae ramped up its pilot programs and local partnerships with ACORN, all of which became precedents and models for the pattern of risky subprime mortgages at the root of today’s crisis.”

Republican critics of this reckless practice read the tea leaves of disaster and attempted to strengthen lending standards. Levin would have none of it.

“I rise to speak about the Community Reinvestment Act (that encourages) banks to serve the credit needs of the entire community including low and middle income areas.,” said Levin in 1999. “I oppose the provisions weakening the CRA.”

The rest is history as subprime lending institutions made bad loans under lax federal standards, pols like Levin basked in the warmth of increased American home ownership, the lenders quickly turned the bad loans over to Fannie and Freddie, who in turn handed them to the secondary mortgage market where they were bundled into financial instruments waiting to explode.

“ACORN used CRA and Democratic sympathizers (that’s Carl) to entangle Fannie and Freddie and the entire financial system in a disastrous disregard of the most basic financial standards,” concludes NR’s Levin.

And now Michigan’s senior senator has the gall to lecture JP Morgan on risky financial practices.

“The enormous loss J.P. Morgan announced today is just the latest evidence that what banks call ‘hedges’ are often risky bets that so-called ‘too big to fail’ banks have no business making,” asserted Levin on Thursday (“enormous” is an overstatement as $2 billion is a mere 0.1 percent of the bank’s assets). Levin is now pushing amendments to the Dodd-Frank financial regulation, regulation that Michigan businessmen tell me has dried up capital markets and is one of the key reasons the economic recovery has been so slow.

Wall Street Journal financial writer Holman Jenkins sneered at Levin’s presumption: “Uh huh. Banks that refrain from risk aren’t banks. And expecting regulators to distinguish good hedges from ‘risky bets,’ as (Levin’s new regulation) requires, is to expect regulators to be better bankers (for a lot less pay) than one of the best bankers, (JP Morgan’s) Dimon, has shown himself to be.”

Indeed, The Journal reported this weekend, the intention of JP Morgan’s (ultimately disastrous) hedging was aimed at making “bets aimed at shielding the bank from the market fallout of Europe’s deepening mess.”

And why is Europe in a mess? Because of massive debt created by excessive government spending and unsustainable public sector union pension liabilities. And who is planting the seeds for similar future debt implosion in the U.S.?

Yes, Senator Carl Levin and his fellow Democrats.

 

Payne: Obama echoes Cheney

Posted by hpayne on May 11, 2012

America may be startled at the intensity of coverage of President Obama’s gay marriage vows. It is an issue, after all, which has hardly been on the front burner of policy – and seems a diversion from the massive economic issues facing the nation. Indeed, the pressing family issue in this country is the lack of it in places like Detroit. The city’s 80 percent black illegitimacy rate drives every inner city pathology – from school dropouts to adult illiteracy to crime.

But the media ignores the black family crisis (a crisis of class that also wreaks havoc on my home state of West Virginia) – a crisis ignited by government welfare programs. To admit the crisis would be to admit the failure of liberal welfare. And so the MSM prefers to knock the conservative War on Gay Marriage. It is a perennial issue in America’s liberal newsrooms on par with racial preferences and abortion rights.

It is also an issue I happen to agree with. I’m not convinced government sanctioning only heterosexual marriage is important. I default to choice.

There was a collective cheer in American newsrooms Wednesday as the media ssees the president’s advocacy as the culmination of years of press advocacy. But that begs the question: Why didn’t the media cheer when former Veep Dick Cheney took the exact same position in 2009?

“People ought to be free to enter into any kind of union they wish, any kind of arrangement they wish,” said Cheney who has a lesbian daughter.

Part of the answer, obviously, is that Cheney was an ex-veep by then. And his boss, President Bush, had never touched the issue while in office (though Cheney was also outspoken while in office against the federal Defense of Marriage Act).

But the bigger reason is simple partisanship. Party always trumps principle. Just as “liberal” newsies have thrown the Catholic Church under the bus on Obama’s contraception mandate – a clear violation of the First Amendment – they hated Darth Vader too much to acknowledge his progressive views.

Better to trumpet the words of their man Barack Obama – even if it took him three years to finally catch up with Dick Cheney.

 

Payne: Mourdock, scourge of Lugar. . . and Obama’s Auto Task Force

Posted by hpayne on May 9, 2012

Who is Richard Mourdock?

He is the bold Indiana state treasurer who brought suit against Chrysler in 2009 to try and protect state teacher and firefighter pensioners from the Obama Auto Task Force’s illegal grab of their investments to benefit the UAW. Mourdock’s ultimately futile suit was the last line of defense against a thuggish White House that had threatened New York bondholders into taking the White House’s ruthless, 29-cents-on-the-dollar deal to benefit its labor cronies.

But you wouldn’t know that from Wednesday’s MSM coverage of tea party favorite Mourdock’s upset win over Senate fixture Richard Lugar. The New York Times, for example, only mentions Mourdock’s Chrysler fight in the 16th graph of a sidebar story – headline “Many Pursuits, but Bipartisanship Isn’t One of Them.” As that loaded headline suggests, the Times’ coverage is decidedly anti-Mourdock (the story doesn’t even mention Mourdock’s flesh-and-blood plaintiffs ” dismissing them as “state funds”).

If the establishment press lived its credo of watching out for the little guy, then Mourdock’s David-like defense of pensioners in the face of the Goliath-like armies of Big Labor, Big Auto, and Big Government should have made him a national hero. Instead, his is but a footnote in Washington’s troubling Chapter 363 bankruptcies that stripped first-in-line secured credit holders of their rights to favor politically-favored Big Labor. An accurate portrait of Mourdock would clash with the MSM’s caricature of conservative upstarts as tea party extremists.

“As fiduciaries, we can’t allow our retired police officers and teachers to be ripped off by the federal government,” said Mourdock in U.S. district court on May 26, 2009. “The Indiana state funds suffered losses when the Obama administration overturned more than 100 years of established law by redefining ‘secured creditors’ to mean something less.”

“It’s improper, because creditors are not getting the legal procedure allowed to them by Congress,” UCLA Law Professor Lynn LoPucki told CFO magazine in June, 2009.

But Mourdock’s fight was a footnote in the MSM in 2009. Its coverage of White House kneecapping of New York investors? Non-existent. They were inconvenient speed bump in Obama Washington’s rush to save the UAW.

In his campaign against Lugar, Mourdock once again played David against a six-term incumbent Goliath. But The Times sniffs at the underdog for dislodging “a collegial moderate who personified a gentler political era.” Presumably a pre-tea party era when pols collegially ignored sky-rocketing debt and the trampling of the rule of law.

Now the electoral beast has been awakened. By the UAW bailouts. By trillion-dollar deficits. By Obamacare and the fear that America is following Europe over a debt cliff.

Does he regret sanding up for Indiana pensioners in 2009, the Times demands at the end of its article? “Absolutely not, replies Mourdock. “The law matters. And the fact was out retirees and teachers had their property stolen.”

Those crazy conservatives. They care about such things.

Payne: Twins

Posted by hpayne on May 8, 2012

America, meet Michigan.

Mitt Romney paid a visit to Governor Rick Snyder’s state Tuesday to — as local CBS Radio put it — defy the “popular wisdom” that Michigan is lost. In fact, Romney would do well to visit Michigan more often. Michigan is America. Failed governor Jennifer Granholm was Barack Obama. New governor Snyder is Mitt Romney. And Michigan’s resurgence under former Gateway Computer Corporation CEO Snyder and his Republican legislature is dramatic evidence of how a businessman can return fiscal sanity to a government run off the rails.

“I believe we are a role model,” said Snyder as he introduced Romney in the state capital of Lansing. “It wasn’t four or five years for us — we had a decade of tough times. It’s about ‘Relentless Positive Action.’ We are the comeback state in the U.S.A. Do what we have done — fix your tax system, fix your regulatory system.”

Indeed, a simple change in leadership has brought dramatic change to Michigan. Granholm’s assive tax breaks for politically connected corporations from Big Green to Big Hollywood have given way to a broad-based, simplified, flat tax system. Businessman Snyder often rankles movement conservatives by shying from partisan battles and adopting corporate language instead of Smithian principles to justify his fiscal policies. But in a state wrecked by eight years of Obama-esque mismanagement, his focus on the fundamentals has been refreshing.

He has brought balance to a once-chaotic budget process and has tackled the state’s long-term liabilities head on after years of neglect from Granholm — an attractive, Harvard-trained, Democratic ideologue with no management experience.

Sound familiar? Obama meet Granholm. America meet Michigan.

Romney echoed Snyder’s themes in his speech. “I am increasingly optimistic about our future,” said Romney, doing his own version of Snyder’s signature ‘Relentless Positive Action,’ miles from the divisive rhetoric that has become Obama’s trademark. “Businesses will spring up across the country by instituting pro-growth regulations, pro-growth taxes, pro-growth intellectual property protections, and pro-growth labor policies.”

From Obama to Romney. From Granholm to Snyder. It’s working in Michigan.

 

Payne: Please, Mr. Holder, stop helping

Posted by hpayne on May 7, 2012

“This is unacceptable,” Attorney General Eric Holder said of the bloodbath that is killing two black men a week in Detroit. Obama’s top cop told the NAACP’s annual dinner in Detroit Sunday night that the statistics were “shocking” and his administration is directing “unprecedented” resources to reducing young people’s exposure to violence.

Please, Mr. Holder, stop helping us.

Federal policies from public housing projects to welfare payments paying for children out of wedlock have set the table for today’s urban violence – violence bred by 80 percent birth illegitimacy rates that leave young males growing up fatherless, uneducated, and poor.

Indeed, as Holder spoke, The Detroit News told the tale of The Martin Luther King Apartments near downtown Detroit – a sprawling, federally-subsidized, 481-unit, low-income housing compound that’s been taken over by drug dealers and other criminals.

“We’re the forgotten people of Detroit,” MLK resident Sharonda Hawkins – a gun strapped to her belt – told The News. Her husband was gunned down there last year – a nameless statistic among in the hundreds of Detroiters murdered every year even as the city’s establishment trumpets each downtown restaurant opening as evidence the city is “coming back.”

While not as violent as infamous public projects like now-defunct Cabrini Green in Chicago, MLK-like apartments have also become federally-funded breeding grounds for violence, says Bill Johnson, a Michigan View columnist and veteran Detroit writer. Such complexes, explain Johnson, house concentrations of welfare moms and their children who are preyed on by drug dealers as both clients and drug couriers. Like the giant Cabrinis of old, such compounds are easily controlled by territorial gangs.

Such single families are the result of decades of federal welfare programs – expanded under President Obama – that have displaced the father in the home. Single parenthood, the Heritage Foundation’s Robert Rector writes, is a leading cause of poverty – and fuels every young male dysfunction, from school dropouts, to adult illiteracy, to criminal behavior.

Yet, incredibly, the Obama administration has just produced an ad celebrating single parenthood in the form of Julia – a mother who is dependent on cradle-to-grave government handouts. In this Obama campaign vision of the American family, a male never enters Julia’s – or her son Zachary’s – life. In this fairy tale, Julia starts a government-funded “web business.”

In urban reality, the odds are the Julia and Zach wind up in MLK apartments, terrorized by drug lords, her son a potential victim (over 100 Detroiters have been killed this year already) or recruit (60 percent of inner city black high school dropouts will spend time in prison).

Faced with these truths, Holder seemed to be speaking from another planet Sunday. “Across the administration, we’re working in a range of other innovative ways to achieve fairness and expand opportunity ” from successfully advocating for the reduction of the unfair and unjust 100-to-1 sentencing disparity between crack and powder cocaine offenses – to launching a new, Department-wide Diversity Management Initiative,” Holder said. And this will stem the violence how?

Maybe next time AG Holder comes to Detroit, he’ll get out more.

 

Payne: Anti-Voter ID Democrats require Voter ID for Michigan Caucus

Posted by hpayne on May 5, 2012

Detroit – Attorney General Eric Holder says that voter ID laws – requiring a government-issued form of identification to guard against vote fraud – are discriminatory. He has accused Republicans of trying to “suppress certain votes in the hope of attaining electoral success” and has called for an aggressive federal review of Republican-sponsored state laws – including South Carolina and Texas, whose statutes have not yet been approved by Holder’s department.

Does he plan to investigate his president’s party?

This weekend, the Michigan Democratic Party will be holding its caucuses to formally nominate Barack Obama as president. What do Democratic caucus voters need to vote? A photo ID.

“Even though we already know that President Obama will be our nominee, it’s important that we let him know we’re standing with him, now and this November. Commit to caucus now, and look up the caucus location in your neighborhood,” reads an email from Democratic Michigan Field Director Erin McCann (the email was sent to The Frank Beckmann radio show in Detroit from a listener. See nearby).

“Here’s everything you need to know,” continues the email with voting requirements:

– Who can caucus: You must be 18 or older and registered to vote (or, if you’ll be eligible to vote by November, you must pledge that you’ll register by then).

– What to expect: Bring proof that you live in the area served by the caucus location — photo ID is required.

– When and where to caucus: Registration starts at 9:00 a.m. — and you must be in line by 11:00 a.m. to participate in the caucus. You can look up your local caucus location here.

A link then takes caucus-goers to a webpage (pictured nearby) on BarackObama.com which reads: “Thanks for pledging to caucus for President Obama in Michigan. Don’t forget to bring a photo ID that shows you are a resident of the caucus district.”

By Mr. Holder’s standards then, President Obama’s party is engaged in voter suppression, targeting heavily black voting precincts like Detroit and Pontiac. Will Holder allies like the NAACP and the George Soros-funded Brennan Center, who claim without evidence that voter ID laws hurt minorities, protest the Democratic caucuses? Will the NAACP petition the United Nations as it did in December for a human-rights ruling on what its President Benjamin Jealous called a “tidal wave of assaults on the right to vote”? Will the American Civil Liberties Union sue the Democratic Party as it has Wisconsin to protests its voter ID law?

“Speak out. Raise awareness about what’s at stake,” Holder said last December in a speech decrying voter ID laws. “Call on our political parties to resist the temptation to suppress certain votes in the hope of attaining electoral success and, instead, encourage and work with the parties to achieve this success by appealing to more voters. We must be honest about this.”

Yes, we must. Or at least must be consistent. We look forward to Mr. Holder’s Detroit appearance this weekend.

 

Payne: Veep Nerd?

Posted by hpayne on May 3, 2012

Governor Snyder for veep? Now you know the presidential silly season is in full swing.

With the Republican race over and the Final Two set, journalists have to cool their heels until the political conventions in (gasp!) late August. With Obama’s veep set (though, you watch, the rumors of ditching Biden will soon start flying), that leaves only the suspense of Romney’s pick for #2.

There’s nothing more comical than political pros/jos with too much time on their hands. “My bet is (Snyder’s) Romney’s man for vice president,” wrote Chris Ingram, a Tampa Republican political consultant, in a Tampa Bay Online op-ed.

Huh? Spend any time with Snyder and you know he is allergic to politics. At the GOP’s political conference in Mackinac last year, he could barely muster the enthusiasm to tell the faithful to vote Republican for Senate in 2012. His endorsement of Romney for the Michigan primary came with just days to spare – not because he was on the fence (everyone knew one biz nerd would endorse the other biz nerd) – but because he wasn’t interested.

“Pure fantasy,” says one Michigan GOP insider when asked about Veep Nerd. “The numbers crunchers know that Snyder is no conservative, which is the one constituency Romney cannot afford to burn right now. If he’s making a geographic pitch, then Michigan Rep. Mike Rogers would be a much better choice (a Midwest conservative with foreign policy/intel cred out the wazoo).”

And one more thing: Snyder is a CEO. CEOs don’t do deputy. So how did Mr. Ingram put Snyder on the veep short list?

“Access to the convention site, proximity to the best restaurants and bars, being inside the security zone, and not having to ride a bus (a really big deal if you’re a Republican) are almost as important as fighting over abortion and gays in the party’s meaningless platform,” Ingram writes. And, he has found, Michigan’s convention delegation won the next best hotel spot to Massachusetts.

Because Snyder is from Michigan? A more logical conclusion: Because Romney is from Michigan and Massachusetts.

 

Payne: Chen and Elian

Posted by hpayne on May 2, 2012

Forget Monica Lewinsky. The biggest scandal of the Clinton presidency was its throwing young Elian Gonzalez back into Castro’s shark tank after his mother had sacrificed her life to get him to freedom. Now another Democratic president, President Obama, seems determined to betray a Communist dissident to realpolitik.

What is it with Democrats sacrificing civil liberties to communist thugs?

“The blind Chinese dissident who boldly fled house arrest and placed himself under the wing of U.S. diplomats balked Wednesday at a deal delicately worked out between the two countries to let him live freely in China, saying he now fears for his family’s safety unless they are all spirited abroad,” reports AP.

How is this possible? Did the Obama administration really take the word of one of the world’s most notoriously brutal regimes and turn over a dissident hero – a BLIND dissident hero – who had taken refuge in a U.S. Embassy because he actually believed America stands for the principle of freedom?

Barack Obama’s troubling silence when asked about Chen’s situation Tuesday now speaks volumes. “America’s first black president” is apparently unaware of the symbolic power that moniker carries. Why didn’t he demand that Chen’s family be reunited with him? Why didn’t he hold a news conference highlighting Chen and his cause – the forced sterilizations of women as a result of China’s one-child policy? Now THAT is a War on Women.

Like Clinton before him, hoever, Obama appears naïve about dictatorships – and more than willing to sacrifice civil liberties for diplomatic face.

After six days holed up in the U.S. Embassy, the U.S. released Chen today – spinning hard that a deal guaranteed his safety and a new academic life. We’re not making this up. The Obama Administration actually believed them – the same fascist government that has beaten Chen for years under house arrest and even followed a CNN cameraman and tried to wrestle his camera away when he visited Chen’s town. Hillary Clinton’s State Department spun reporters that she spoke with an enthusiastic Chen after his release back into Chinese hell.

“After saying in Chinese how grateful he was that she had mentioned him in the past and supported his case, he said in broken English, ‘I want to kiss you,'” a senior U.S. official said.

The story started to fall apart within hours as a shaken Chen told AP from his hospital room (yes, to treat injuries received escaping from the very thugs Clinton had just handed Chen back to) that Chinese authorities threatened to beat his wife to death if he did not leave the U.S. embassy.

“I think we’d like to rest in a place outside of China,” Chen told the AP, appealing for his freedom. “Help my family and me leave safely.”

Clearly, the U.S. had mishandled – or worse betrayed – Chen, concocting a cover story to get him out of the embassy. Why? Because – strategic and economic meetings (were to) start Thursday between Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton, Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner and their Chinese counterparts,” says AP. “I’m guessing US officials were eager to get rid of him,” one Chinese expert told The Washington Post’s Jennifer Rubin.

Don’t want to let human rights get in the way of government relations. Human rights groups (don’t “liberal” Democrats talk to these people?) are enraged. “I’m somewhat surprised by the U.S. government’s willingness to accept the Chinese government’s assurances or even to get Hillary Clinton to work for Chen’s safety in the long term,” said Nicholas Bequelin, senior Asia researcher for Human Rights Watch. Then again, should Mr. Bequelin be surprised after the Elian debacle?

I recently had the privilege of meeting Dayanna Delgado, a young Cuban doctor who had bravely escaped Castro’s tentacles for American freedom. I asked her about Elian Gonzalez – who the Clinton Administration had ripped from American relatives in a 2000 nighttime raid to send back to Castro (despite reports that Elian’s father, like Chen’s family, had been threatened unless he asked for his son’s return).

Delgado told me Elian lived life in a public cage in Cuba. His family had been given a nice house. The government knew his every move. He was both Castro’s prisoner and propaganda prize for Castro. Which is why his mother took him to the U.S. Democrats haven’t learned a thing.

 

Payne: Dr. Lutz’s Gas Tax Snake Oil

Posted by hpayne on April 30, 2012

Like President Barack Obama, Chevy Volt designer “Maximum Bob” Lutz yearns for Euro-style high gas prices. “People say politically it can’t be done. . . in the United States,” said Lutz on the Frank Beckmann Show Monday, holding up high-gas tax European nations as leaders in the fight for oil independence from OPEC.

But despite $8 a gallon gas prices, Europe today is more dependent on foreign oil than ever.

Since 2001, gas prices in Germany, for example, have more than doubled, from $3.60 a gallon to over $8 a gallon. Yet European dependence on oil imports has grown from 74 percent of consumption to 84 percent of consumption according to Eurostat (Germany is 97 percent dependent on foreign oil).

Lutz’s campaign is no doubt a self-serving ploy to increase demand for his pet Volt — but he also wraps himself in the moral imperative of, not global warming, but national security. He claims high gas taxes will wean America from oil. True? Again, Europe is instructive.

The doubling of gas prices should, by Lutz’s logic, have dried up European demand for oil — but it has not. Gas and diesel-powered cars remain the dominant form of transportation despite more than a decade of hybrid vehicle availability. Why? Because internal combustion engines remain the most cost-effective technology for consumers even in congested European nations.

Meanwhile, all that taxation — and its twin brother, regulation — have strangled European productivity with per capita income now just 70 percent of the U.S. as less-efficient government takes 45 percent of gross domestic product (compared to the 25 percent (and rising) in the U.S.).

No wonder raising the gas tax is, as Lutz puts it, “the third rail of politics.” Even President Obama and his Europhile sidekick, EnergySec Steven Chu, have backed off on their previous calls for higher gas taxes this year, saying: “Do you think the president of the United States going into re-election wants gas prices to go up higher?”

Trumped by facts and political reality, Lutz then got REALLY Obama-like. “When (gas) gets to $4 a gallon for market reasons, when it starts creeping down again, you don’t let it go down” he told Beckmann in describing how a gas tax might work. “You make up the difference in taxation. That would be one way to sneak it in where the public wouldn’t be aware of the fact that you’ve added taxes.”

Kinda like the EPA killing coal via sneaky carbon regs, get it?

At this point, the WJR phone lines exploded with fury against Lutz, whose reputation as Detroit’s car guy won’t survive many more of these interviews. A better solution? Let the market work. If there’s a better alternative to gasoline, the engineers will figure it out. And those evil OPEC countries? Boycott them. Just like we’ve done with an embargo on Iran the last 30 years.

 

Payne: General before King

Posted by hpayne on April 26, 2012

Wednesday morning, Democratic Party bigwigs called off UAW President Bob King and his union pit-bulls from protesting Obama corporate ally Jeffrey Immelt and his General Electric shareholders meeting held in Detroit’s Renaissance Center, the headquarters of Obama-bailed out General Motors.

Powerful Detroit Democratic leaders from Senator Debbie Stabenow to Rep. John Dingell reportedly pressured King to stand down for fear of besmirching Detroit’s already tarnished image. Recruited to Detroit by Democratic Governor Jennifer Granholm before she left office in 2010, the GE shareholder’s meeting is part of a broad campaign to sell Detroit’s struggling business district to trade conventions, tech companies, and other business interests.

But a UAW president leading a 99 Percent protest against an Obama-approved green corporation inside Government Motors’ headquarters also promised an image disaster for Democrats.

GE and GM, after all, are glaring examples of the “One Percenters” that has benefited from Obama’s largesse, and the sight of King – also an Obama BFF ” tearing down these corporations in the name of the “working man” would have made for delicious Republican campaign commercials.

King had been planning the “99 Percent Spring” protest ” a merging of the Big Labor and Occupy movements – since February to dovetail with Obama’s 2012 reelection campaign, and his decision to pull out looks very last minute. The UAW website still carries the banner headline: “Just taxes for all: Tell GE to pay their fair share.”

The article that follows is full of red meat.

“As the poster child for corporate tax-dodging, GE has made billions off the 99 percent while cutting jobs, stashing money in offshore tax haven accounts, and employing an army of lobbyists to buy political influence and stay ahead of its tax bill,” reads King’s screed.

In fact, GE is a poster child for Obama’s polices. Those “lobbyists” brought home billions in Obama stimulus money and green tax breaks. For example, GE’s $2 billion Shepherd Flats, Oregon wind turbine boondoggle is largely financed by taxpayers loans. And that tax bill? GE pays a 35 percent tax rate like every other American company ” a rate so much higher than other industrialized nations that it has driven earnings offshore to avoid U.S taxes. And Obama wants to punish corporate America with even higher taxes?

“While American families struggle to pay a higher tax rate than General Electric, the corporation lavishes millions on its top executives. In 2010 alone, the top five GE executives raked in $75.9 million. Over the last three years, GE executives collected $234 million,” continues King.

Remember, one of the executives King is attacking here is the chairman of the president’s own Council on Jobs and Competitiveness!

King himself is a walking son of government privilege as a key player in Obama’s $60 billion bailout of UAW-staffed GM. The so-called “UAW Bailout” has hardly endeared King to the 88 percent of Americans who are not in a union ” but the UAW’s money is key to underwriting Obama’s class war campaign this fall.

But some Obama toadies are more important than others. On this day, it was Mr. Immelt. He is a key Obama intermediary to a business community that has soured on the president. A UAW protest against GE would have been a black eye to Immelt. It would also be a “black-eye” to Detroit business, said Deputy Mayor Kirk Lewis, a Democrat. Without King, the protest largely fizzled, with SEIU employees bused in from Wisconsin making up the majority of the 300-odd protestors. They briefly disrupted the GE meeting before being chased away from GM HQ to a nearby park. By noon, they were gone.

Obama One Percenters 1, Obama 99 Percenters, 0. Bob King’s 99 Percent Spring will live to fight another day.

Payne: What the font?

Posted by hpayne on April 26, 2012

The Michigan Board of State Canvassers deadlocked 2-2 on party lines this morning, killing a Big Labor-backed ballot initiative to end the emergency manager law because Republican canvassers said petitions carried the wrong font size.

Stand Up For Democracy, the group representing EM law opponents, immediately jumped in the GOPer’s faces shouting “shame” and “fascists” (ah, that Democratic civility) and vowed to appeal the decision.

But, says Leon Drolet, this is how the canvassing system is supposed to work.

Drolet should know. He headed perhaps the most controversial ballot proposal of the last decade – the 2006 Michigan Civil Rights Initiative banning racial discrimination in government hiring and admissions. MCRI was defeated by canvassers but ultimately won on appeal – and on election day.

Ballot initiatives, says Drolet, are supposed to be hard. After all, they change the state constitution.

“Either enforce the rules, or no one complies,” says Drolet about the font details which are one of many that canvassers are asked to enforce. In the case of MCRI, says Drolet, the canvassers threw out the initiative on purely political pique – 3 of 4 petitioners wanted to continue racial discrimination in university admissions, claiming “diversity” trumped color-blindness.

But MCRI ultimately won, says Drolet, because the Appeals court not only approved their petition’s language – but because they were careful to abide by the rules. For example, MCRI threw out thousands of ballots because they either contained too many signatures per page or because they were photo-copied – both potential red flags to Democratic canvassers itching to defeat the proposal.

By contrast, anti-EM law petitioners refused to submit their ballots to canvassers beforehand in order to ensure that their font sizes, etc. were up to code. Big mistake, says Drolet. Rules is rules. Welcome to the ballot wars.

 

Payne: The Obama Coalition train wreck

Posted by hpayne on April 24, 2012

It began Monday, with protestors chanting “We are the 99 Percent” in front of WDIV-TV, the Detroit affiliate of NBC which is owned by General Electric. By Wednesday, Obama Big Labor ally and UAW President Bob King hopes his organization of the Obama-supported Occupy Wall Street movement, the “99 Percent Spring,” will reach its crescendo against Obama Big Business ally Jeffrey Immelt and his GE shareholders meeting at the Obama-bailed out General Motors headquarters in downtown Detroit.

Call it the Obama Coalition train wreck.

While President Obama has fashioned his 2012 reelection campaign as a fight for the middle class against the wealthy elite, this weeks intersection of Obama toadies illustrates that his presidency has been all about favoring a politically-connected, privileged few: Big Labor, their unionized industries, and Big Green corporations like GE.

“It is morally wrong – it is absolutely wrong – that (GE makes) billions and billions and billions of dollars and pay not a single penny in taxes. Enough is enough. We’re the 99 percent who want 100 percent fairness for everyone,” King raged in February against a company that has aggressively reduced its tax bill by pursuing tax shelters abroad to avoid the onerous 35 percent U.S. corporate tax rate as well as domestic tax breaks for its green energy projects.

King’s anti-GE campaign is thick with irony. GE will hold its shareholder’s meeting in the Renaissance Center on Detroit’s waterfront, the headquarters of General Motors – better known as Government Motors for its $60 billion federal rescue in 2009 that unfairly whacked GM investors in order to favor President Obama’s UAW friends, who were given 18 percent ownership of the company. The White House’s managed bankruptcy allowed the UAW-owned corporation to write off up to $45 billion of old losses going forward – good for a $15 billion tax break.

Moreover, GE Chairman Immelt is, like King, a close ally of the president having been appointed head of Obama’s Council on Jobs and Competitiveness. Like King’s UAW, GE has benefited from its privileged political status. If the UAW is the White House’ model of labor, then GE is the Democrat’s idea of a good green corporate citizen.

GE received 88 stimulus grants and contracts worth $123 million, including millions to develop off-shore wind energy. Immelt himself was invited by the Obama’s as a guest at the 2011 State of the Union address. King, who hosted Obama at the UAW annual conference in DC this February, has himself has been an outspoken supporter of federal green handouts to unionized- automakers like Ford.

Meanwhile, King’s UAW has also underwritten the Occupy movement against Big Business, in particular Occupy Detroit which paraded through downtown Detroit last October 14 in opposition to federal bailouts. Conspicuously missing from Occupy Detroit’s list of corporate evildoers was GM , which was playing host that same day to President Obama and King at its federally-bailed out Lake Orion plant north of Detroit.

Now , however, this Coalition of the Privileged is about to blow up as King seeks a high-profile target for the launch of Occupy 2.0, the “99 Percent Spring” movement coordinated with the Obama 2012 campaign to mobilize the union grassroots.

The rally has horrified a Detroit Democratic establishment which fears a black eye to a near-bankrupt city already struggling to attract business. Though King’s antics have been telegraphed for weeks , a top Democratic source says that the party is frantically trying to discourage King’s 99 Percent Spring troops (which last week occupied Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker’s speech in Troy). Funny, though – the party raised nary a peep last fall when the Occupiers marched on Comerica Bank and DTE Energy, Detroit’s largest utility. The image of the UAW rampaging in front of Democrat-friendly corporations like GE and GM, apparently, hits too close to the bone.

OWS and UAW vs. GE at GM HQ. OMG. What has POTUS wrought?

Payne: Granholm was for stand-your-ground before she was against it

Posted by hpayne on April 20, 2012

From under a hoodie, ex-Governor Jennifer Granholm has been outspoken on the need for “justice” in the Trayvon Martin killing, including attacking the NRA for pushing Florida’s so-called “stand-your-ground” law that allegedly encourages folks like George Zimmerman to wield a gun when threatened.

Left unmentioned in Granholm’s attack, however, is that she herself was an NRA-supported advocate for passing Michigan’s own stand-your-ground law in 2006.

“Tonight on ‘The War Room’ we’ll examine . . . the National Rifle Association’s push for self-defense laws that have allowed Trayvon Martin’s killer to go unpunished,” previewed the March 29 website of her Current TV program, “The War Room.”

In one of two segments on the stand-your-ground issue and gun rights run amok, Granholm guest, Joseph Marshall, an activist and radio host, exclaimed “that’s a bad law.”

“Of course,” replied Granholm.

But in 2006, the NRA applauded Granholm for passing a stand-your-ground law (also known as a “castle doctrine”) as governor of Michigan.

“Today Governor Jennifer Granholm signed into law a package of six self-defense bills backed by the National Rifle Association, bringing ‘Castle Doctrine’ protections to law-abiding Michigan citizens,” read the NRA press release.

“I want to thank the Michigan Legislature and Governor Jennifer Granholm for working together in making this victims’ rights bill into law,” said Chris W. Cox, the NRA’s chief lobbyist. “When you’re confronted by a criminal, you don’t have the luxury of time. This Castle Doctrine package states that if victims choose to stand their ground and fight, their decision will not be second-guessed by the State of Michigan.”

Granholm’s Michigan joined Florida, Texas, Arizona, Indiana, Kentucky, and others states, reports Awr Hawkins at Big Government.com, “where governors and state legislators have tried to restore the people’s right to use a gun to defend their own lives and the lives of their families. . . . It is the height of hypocrisy for her to talk and act otherwise now.”

We look forward to the next edition of “The War Room” in which talk show host Jennifer Granholm and her guest, Michigan Governor Jennifer Granholm, debate the issue.

 

Payne: Obama schmoozes Oakland One Percent, ignores Detroit 99 Percent

Posted by hpayne on April 19, 2012

Bingham Farms – “Mr. President, please drive through Detroit,” beseeched The Detroit News editorial headline Wednesday before Barack Obama’s visit to Michigan.

He didn’t.

Obama ignored Detroit, skirting its border to raise money in the tony suburb of Bingham Farms where Democratic One Percenters live safely in Republican Brooks Patterson’s Oakland County far from Detroit’s crime and dysfunction. Indeed, Oakland is the very antithesis of Barack Obama. Its chief executive loathes Obama. Patterson’s conservative government eschews Obama’s seat-of-pants budgeting. Its low tax, low regulatory environment sucks business from Detroit – the high-tax, Big Labor model of Democratic politics.

Detroit is a model of 40 years of Democratic malpractice. Of billions wasted on fanciful liberal programs that have failed to stem record murder rates. Of welfare programs that destroyed the nuclear family, dooming generations of kids to fatherless homes- the #1 driver of poverty in America. Of unions that have brought the city to the brink of insolvency.

Improbably, Obama took his anti-entrepreneur message – he is regarded by America’s top businessmen as anti-business – to the home of Denise Ilitch, the daughter of one of Metro Detroit’s most successful entrepreneurs, Mike Ilitch, presumably one of the reviled One Percenters whose greed the president says has exacerbated America’s wealth gap. The irony was rich as Obama lounged in Ilitch opulence.

“The room the guests were in included a grand piano, a sweeping staircase leading to an overlook and tables filled with gold-rimmed dishes, Waterford crystal and centerpieces of purple hydrangeas and peonies,” reported The Detroit News.

Earlier, Obama spoke at the Henry Ford Museum in Dearborn (made possible by another loathsome, wealthy industrialist), basking in the glow of his Detroit bailouts (more irony since Ford was not bailed out). With the Other Two’s resurgence, however, Obama deserves the accolades. But as usual he overplayed his hand. He continued the fiction that Republicans would have “let Detroit go bankrupt.” In fact, Obama himself took GM and Chrysler into bankruptcy. Mitt Romney too advocated bankruptcy for the automakers, but objected to Obama’s illegal stripping of bondholders’ rights in tilting the field to his UAW political allies.

Ultimately, however, it is Obama’s avoidance of Detroit that bruises his legacy.

His failed national policies – more spending, more welfare – echo Detroit’s failed solutions. Even more importantly, Obama has wasted a historic opportunity to do profound good. Even in recession, no corner of America has suffered more than urban areas like Detroit because of the implosion of the black family. Bill Cosby laments it. So does Mayor Dave Bing. Major academic studies rue its effects.

As a black male role model and father to two children, Obama could have preached the fundamental importance of family to a culture’s success. He could have changed the game. He didn’t.