Articles Blog

Payne: Four more years for President Granholm

Posted by hpayne on November 7, 2012

Welcome to Jennifer Granholm’s second term. Only this time, it’s President Granholm.

In 2006, Michigan rewarded Granholm’s vicious, anti-businessman, xenophobic campaign against Dick DeVos with a second term for their incumbent governor. She was Michigan’s attractive, I’ll-fight-for-you, first female governor. America’s attractive, I’ll-fight-for-you, first African-American president has followed the Granholm example to the tee against Mitt Romney, mimicking the Granholm campaign in its class warfare strategy. Granholm’s win brought one of the most dysfunctional, divisive, and disastrous second terms in Michigan history as the governor – inexperienced and incapable of compromise – fought a divided legislature over the huge structural challenges Michigan faced.

Expect the same in Washington for the next four years.

Only in Washington, the consequences will be much more dire. While Granholm’s fiscal incompetence and tooth fairy fantasies of transforming America into a Green economy mimic Obama’s agenda, she had not enacted historic entitlement legislation in her first term. Thus, her many mistakes were reversible once a competent executive like Governor Rick Snyder eventually took over.

A second term for Barack Obama means cementing in place Obamacare, a government takeover of health care that will fundamentally change America – not only eroding care and plunging the nation into deeper debt, but transforming it into a middle-class entitlement state like Europe.

The irony is that Michigan knows better. Two years ago, it elected Mitt Romney twin Snyder who has reversed Granholm’s second-term train wreck. Remarkably, however, even Snyder was unwilling to press Romney’s case this campaign.

On the morning of Romney’s first presidential debate against Barack Obama, Snyder took over three hours of highly-rated, drive-time talk radio – as Paul W. Smith’s guest host on Detroit’s WJR – and never mentioned his fellow Republican (nor did he mention his party’s candidate for Senate, Pete Hoekstra, much less invite him on the air).

One Tough Nerd has always made known his discomfort with partisan politics. But in a year in which the national election loomed as the most important in memory, Snyder’s reticence to sing Romney’s praises was curious because businessman-turned-governor Snyder was the best model for what a businessman-turned-president Romney presidency would look like.

A data-driven business geek, Snyder’s governorship has been a welcome, bipartisan respite from the chaotic, incompetent management style of his predecessor. So too would data-driven Romney have been a desperately needed antidote to Divider-in-Chief Barack Obama’s management-challenged style.

Yet, while Snyder is markedly non-partisan in his rhetoric (Romney too made the only bipartisan noises this presidential campaign), his tenure has been marked by bitter partisanship from Democrats with no desire for compromise. Snyder’s first two years have been remarkably productive – despite Democratic brickbats – because he has had the Republican votes in the legislature to get things done. Even if Romney had won, we now know he would still have faced a Senate roadblock.

America has voted for more of the same for the next four years. If Granholm’s Michigan is any indication, it will not end well.

Payne: Obamacare Mega-hospital

Posted by hpayne on November 5, 2012

For all its attacks on wealth and Big Business, the reality of the Obama Administrations is it has been a boon to the politically-connected rich. Big Government loves Big Business. Thus millions have gone to Big Green firms like LG Chem and A123 Systems, millions to GE to build alternative energy, millions to millionaires like Leo DiCaprio and Sen. Carl Levin to buy luxury electric cars.

The latest beneficiary of Obama’s Big Government is Big Hospital, one of the most powerful lobbies (along with Big Pharma and Big Insurance) behind Obamacare.

Big Hospital lobbied hard for Obamacare’s insurance mandate and for steering more business to big institutions. That’s the reality behind the megamerger of Detroit Beaumont and Henry Ford hospital systems, a marriage that will mean less competition and less innovation in Detroit’s health care sector.

“You’ve got to get bigger to manage” coming changes to health care under Obamacare, CEO of Henry Ford Health Systems Nancy Schlichting told The Detroit News’ Dan Howes “We’ve got to get bigger through scale to make the equation work.” Added Howes: “The nation’s shifting health care landscape is forcing hospital companies and their leadership to conduct strategic reappraisals of their business models.”

This is by design.

For years, health care innovation had been occurring away from hospitals in more nimble, less bureaucratic outpatient clinics. “Today, most patients needing long-term dialysis no longer get it in hospitals but go to less costly, more convenient outpatient clinics,” reports Scott Gottlieb, a physician and scholar at the American Enterprise Institute. “Complex issues like cancer are handled in specialized centers with expertise to better manage these problems, at lower cost.”

But thanks to Obamacare’s paperwork nightmare – and Big Hospital lobbying dollars – the playing field has been tilted towards Big Business. “ObamaCare actively promotes medical corporatism,” writes The Wall Street Journal editorial page. “The reason isn’t to encourage business efficiency but for political control. Liberals believe in health-care consolidation because fewer giant corporations are easier for (Obamacare’s Independent Payment Advisory Board) to control, and more amenable to its orders.”

“Instead of betting on entrepreneurs, Obamacare assumes that improvements in the delivery of medical care will arise as a result of shifts in market power. This turns on a shortsighted view that once providers are grouped into larger networks, they’ll make wider use of things like information technology to better coordinate the care of patients, in turn lowering costs. The legislation bets heavily on hospitals, envisioning them as the hub around which providers will be consolidated,” writes Dr. Gottlieb.

Sound familiar? This is exactly the logic of the Beaumont-Henry Ford megamerger. And already, smaller practices in Metro Detroit area are feeling the pinch. Physical therapy clinics, for example, are losing business as Obamacare’s central planners reward in-house hospital referrals over out-patient referrals.

According to a Accenture Health survey, by 2013, less than a third of physicians will still be in private practice. Most will be salaried employees of Big Hospital.

“The best way to drive innovation and productivity is to have entrepreneurial providers who actually understand what things cost,” writes Gottlieb. “Once they become salaried employees, their incentive to find new efficiencies floats off into the ether.”

Obamacare’s increased price controls will incentivize more hospital mergers – but as that consolidation in turn de-incentivizes more doctors from entering practice, doctor shortages will increase (as they have under Romneycare in Massachusetts) leading to longer wait times and less care. America leads the world in cancer survival, for example, thanks to its world-leading access to care. Obamacare’s centralization is a formula for Canadian-style wait lines and higher cancer mortality rates.

Big Government + Big Hospital = Smaller Patient Choice. The case for repealing Obamacare gets more urgent every day.

Payne: President Mitt Snyder

Posted by hpayne on November 4, 2012

n the morning of Mitt Romney’s first presidential debate against Barack Obama, Michigan Governor Rick Snyder took over three hours of highly-rated, drive-time talk radio- as Paul W. Smith’s guest host on Detroit’s WJR – and never mentioned his fellow Republican (nor did he mention his party’s candidate for Senate, Pete Hoekstra, much less invite him on the air).

One Tough Nerd has always made known his discomfort with partisan politics. But in a year in which the national election looms as the most important in memory, Snyder’s reticence to sing Romney’s praises from the rooftops is particularly curious because businessman-turned-governor Snyder is probably the best model for what a businessman-turned-resident Romney presidency would look like.

From his investment banker roots to beating a crowded primary field of more conservative GOP candidates to the bitter, Democratic class warfare campaign waged against him, Snyder’s road to CEO of Michigan is a mirror-image of Romney’s 2012 road to the White House.

What would Romney do in office? Again, look to Michigan under Snyder.

A data-driven business geek, Snyder’s governorship has been a welcome, bipartisan respite from the chaotic, incompetent management style of his predecessor, Jennifer Granholm. So too would data-driven Romney be a desperately needed antidote to Divider-in-Chief Barack Obama’s management-challenged style.

With metronomic efficiency, Snyder has analyzed and addressed Lansing’s long-term liabilities. Romney would likely do the same with Washington’s out-of-control entitlement programs. Snyder is not a professional pol, meaning he can afford to be bolder in his structural changes. Ditto Romney.

Yet, while Snyder is markedly non-partisan in his rhetoric (Romney too has made the only bipartisan noises this presidential campaign), his tenure has been marked by bitter partisanship from Democrats with no desire for compromise. Expect the same in Washington, which is why a Romney victory without significant GOP gains in the Senate could lead to a gridlocked presidency. Snyder’s first two years have been remarkably productive – despite Democratic brickbats – because he has had the Republican votes in the legislature to get things done.

An Obama victory, by contrast, will look like Granholm’s historically dysfunctional second term from 2007-2010: rudderless, picking partisan fights, ignoring the state’s long-term structural problems, and believing in the tooth fairy fantasy that green technology will transform the economy.

Governor Snyder is Mitt Romney’s best argument for electing a businessman. A pity Snyder has been shy to make the point.

 

Payne: Obamacare-Threat-To-Breast-Cancer-Treatment Awareness Month

Posted by hpayne on October 30, 2012

Thanks in part to NFL jocks wearing pink to commemorate National Breast Cancer Awareness Month, the issue of breast cancer receives enormous publicity every October. Less well publicized is that the United States has the world’s highest breast cancer survival rate.

And that success story may be threatened due to Obamacare.

The real War on Women this political season has been ignored. The government-run health systems abroad that Obamacare mimics have significantly higher cancer mortality rates – including breast cancer – than the U.S. Take Michigan’s neighbor to the north.

According to the U.S. Center for Disease Control, Americans have a nine percent lower breast cancer mortality rate than Canadians. From prostate cancer (184 percent higher) to colon cancer mortality among men (10 percent higher) Canadians suffer worse cancer survival rates than the U.S. Go across the pond and the pattern holds: The U.S. has 9 percent higher breast cancer survival rates than Germany and shopping 15 percent higher than in England.

Why? Because universal care does not mean universal access to treatment. In nationally-regulated systems from Canada to Europe, burdensome regulations and government-controlled health reimbursement create doctor shortages and reduced treatment. A hospital survey of five countries (U.S., Canada, New Zealand, U.K., and Australia), conducted by Prof. Robert Blendon of the Harvard School of Public Health found that “waits of six months or more for elective surgeries were reported to occur ‘very often’ or ‘often’ by 26″57 percent of executives in the four non-U.S. countries; only 1 percent of U.S. hospitals reported this.”

“It’s one of the most oft-repeated justifications for socialized medicine,” writes Forbes health expert Avril Roy in pointing out that the U.S. has the world’s highest mortality rates once you strip out our taste for murder. “If we would just hop on the European health-care bandwagon, we’d live longer and healthier lives. The only problem is it’s not true.”

The Fraser Institute reports “universally-covered” Canadians pouring into the US to find treatment: “46,159 Canadians sought medical treatment outside of Canada in 2011, as wait times increased 104 percent – more than double – compared with statistics from 1993.”

This is Obamacare’s model?

Indeed, in Massachusetts – home of Romneycare, the state model for Obamacare – patient wait times are increasing as are premiums. Alas, Romneycare’s troubles have been ignored by Obamedia – in part because the Romney campaign has shied from attacking Obamacare for fear of calling attention to its own candidate’s failings.

Barack Obama wants a second term in order to consolidate his biggest legislative achievement: Obamacare. Yet the act’s unpopularity – primarily due to its mandate that Americans buy insurance – has compelled the campaign to fight the campaign on straw women like the “Republican War on Women.” The irony is that women stand to lose the most from the president’s federal takeover of the world’s best health care system.

Anyone for wearing pink for Obamacare Awareness Month?

 

Payne: The bridge monopoly misnomer

Posted by hpayne on October 29, 2012

In its decidedly one-sided coverage of the Detroit bridge battle, Michigan’s MSM has demonized a Michigan businessman in favor of a foreign government, Canada. This weekend, The Lansing State Journal, for example, scolded Ambassador Bridge owner Matty Moroun for spending a ballot record ($31 million) on his Prop 6 designed to force a public vote on Canada’s new bridge.

But wouldn’t a newspaper do the same if government threatened its business?

Take the Journal. It’s the only daily newspaper in the state’s capital. What if the governments of Canada, Michigan, and the US ganged up on the LSJ’s “monopoly,” and decided to publish a government-run newspaper to put the Journal out of business?

You don’t have to endorse Moroun’s over-the-top, misleading ads – or his ballot proposal – to know that is exactly what the Canadian government is doing to the Ambassador Bridge Company.

In a decades-long war with Moroun, the Canadian government has tried repeatedly to put the Michigan mogul out of business, jealous that a private company is making money on “their” international border crossing. What is dumb-founding is that it has found a Michigan governor and American government to ally with them to destroy a profitable, American business.

The American pols have a bad case of “edifice complex” – the urge to build a monument creating short-term jobs. But in pursuing their goal, they have lighted on an absurd argument to make their case: They claim Moroun’s bridge is a “monopoly” and that his opposition to the New International Trade Crossing is anti-competitive.

The charge is absurd on its face.

Begin with the fact that governments are themselves monopolies – with limitless resources and no profit motive. Which is why Canada is intent on building a bridge that has no business case. With commercial border traffic flat, and predicted to be flat for the foreseeable future, no private entity will fund a new Detroit bridge.

Then consider that the Ambassador is no more a monopoly than most newspaper towns. The Ambassador competes in a US-Canada border crossing market. Its competitors are other crossings – the Port Huron bridge, the Buffalo bridge and so on. It would be as absurd to call The Lansing State Journal – competing in a market of broadcast TV, Internet, talk radio, and nearby Metro Detroit papers – a monopoly.

Finally, consider that Moroun’s bridge is a rare private exception to transportation infrastructure monopolized by governments. Canada, Michigan, and the US control almost all infrastructure with no competition. Only when Moroun – operating an efficient and highly-regarded bridge – threatens their supremacy do they have the audacity to call his competition a “monopoly.”

You bet Matty Moroun is spending millions. He is up against powerful, government-run monopolists intent on running him outta town.

 

Payne: Mitt Obama’s auto demagoguery

Posted by hpayne on October 28, 2012

Both the Obama and Romney campaigns are playing fast and loose with auto industry facts as they play hardball for votes in Ohio and Michigan before the Nov. 6 election.

But Michigan’s partisan MSM is only reporting Romney’s distortions.

In a heated exchange in the final presidential debate, President Obama falsely accused Romney of wanting GM and Chrysler to go out of business. When Romney protested, Obama shot back “People will look it up.” People did and Obama was wrong – as the record plainly records (in interviews with this reporter, The Detroit News, a New York Times op-ed, etc.) that Romney favored government support to help the Detroit companies through bankruptcy . And just to poison the waters with a little xenophobia, Obama also smeared: “If we had taken your advice Gov. Romney about our auto industry, we’d be buying cars from China instead of selling cars to China.”

Michigan’s major media was virtually silent.

For example, The Detroit Free Press – which has routinely policed Romney on its front page for opposing the UAW bailout – ignored Obama’s distortions, Sam Donaldson repeated Obama’s lie on WJR-Radio, and a MLIve.com endorsement of Obama also falsely accused Romney of wanting the industry to disappear.

What a difference a candidate makes. This weekend, after the Romney campaign hit Obama hard with similarly misleading claims that Chrysler’s “Italian” owners would ship all Jeep production to China, The Freep & Co. exploded in outrage.

“One of the great manufacturers of this state, Jeep, now owned by the Italians, is thinking of moving all production to China,” slimed Romney. Not true, barked the Freep watchdog: “Not only was the story wrong, Romney took criticism for not knowing better and repeating it without questioning it.” True enough – but then the Freep went on to repeat Obama’s lie that Romney’s 2008 NYTimes edit advocated that Detroit automakers should go out of business

Michigan’s partisan MSM watchdog is barking – and biting on behalf of the Obama campaign.

 

Payne: Debbie DebateItNever

Posted by hpayne on October 23, 2012

“Senator Stabenow, doesn’t the LG Chem boondoggle contradict your claim that green subsidies bring jobs to America? And wouldn’t voting for the Keystone pipeline have brought many more jobs?”

As the Obama-Stabenow stimulus implodes, that might make for an interesting debate question. If there were a debate.

But Michigan’s junior senator – and avowed defender of the planet – has refused any debates with her challenger, former Michigan Rep. Pete Hoekstra. From Massachusetts to West Virginia to Florida, Senate, House, and gubernatorial candidates are embracing debates this fall. But Stabenow is running from them. Instead, she has used her war chest of Big Labor-fed campaign dollars to launch a massive ad assault attacking her opponent as granny’s worst enemy.

Like President Obama, the Democrat’s air war has built for the incumbent a solid lead. Now imagine if you were Mitt Romney and were denied debates. Game. Set. Match.

After Romney’s debate-fed insurgence, Stabenow suddenly closed down debate negotiations.

Her campaign defends its strategy, claiming it had accepted two public debates – at the Detroit Economic Club and at Grand Valley State. But she refused to televise the DAC debate – and only allowed in public broadcasting for the college venue.

Again, imagine Mitt Romney agreeing to those conditions.

In a press conference October 11, Hoekstra said “it doesn’t do a whole lot of good (to debate) if no one can see it.” Fair enough. “It’s clear she doesn’t want to debate,” he added at a town hall this weekend. “She doesn’t want to defend her record. Anybody can call me up today and say, ‘Will you go here, will you debate her at the Detroit Econ Club or Grand Valley?’ The answer is yes. Her answer is, ‘I’m sorry. I’m busy.'”

Michigan deserves answers for the waste of green stimulus dollars, the gutting of Delphi pensions in the auto bailout and why Stabenow did not intervene – as well as questions about Hoekstra’s long career in public service. By ignoring the debate, Stabenow is ignoring Michigan.

Payne: Obama’s auto bailout whopper

Posted by hpayne on October 22, 2012

The Boca Bout was about foreign policy, but a subplot was of particular interest to Michigan’s economy: President Obama’s whopper on the auto bailout. For the first time, the two candidates went head-to-head on the Government Motors details – and Obama got it wrong. Badly wrong. Damn-the-facts-I’m-clinging-to-my-talking-points wrong.

For the record, Mitt Romney has always suggested that he favored a managed bankruptcy with government support if needed – despite Obama & Associated Press attempts to twist the facts.

“The federal government should provide guarantees for post-bankruptcy financing and assure car buyers that their warranties are not at risk,” wrote Romney in a 2008 New York Times op-ed. He has expanded on this view in numerous interviews with this writer and others – perhaps most explicitly in an interview with The Detroit News editorial board in February:

“I would never have allowed the auto industry to disappear,” he said then, adding that – at a time when capital markets were frozen – “if government financing was needed, fine. In a managed bankruptcy process, government could have provided guarantees, financing, and DIP financing.”

Yet, Obama insisted in the debate on his “Let Detroit to go bankrupt” caricature. The exchange is devastating to Obama’s veracity:

ROMNEY: The president mentioned the auto industry and that somehow I would be in favor of jobs being elsewhere. Nothing could be further from the truth. . . . I said they need – these companies need to go through a managed bankruptcy, and in that process they can get government help and government guarantees, but they need to go through bankruptcy to get rid of excess cost and the debt burden that they’d – they’d built up.

OBAMA: Governor Romney, that’s not what you said.

MR. ROMNEY: Fortunately, the president – you can take – you can take a look at the op-ed.

PRESIDENT OBAMA: Governor, you did not –

MR. ROMNEY: You can take a look at the op-ed.

PRESIDENT OBAMA: You did not say that you would provide, Governor, help.

MR. ROMNEY: I said that we would provide guarantees and – and that was what was able to allow these companies to go through bankruptcy, to come out of bankruptcy. Under no circumstances would I do anything other than to help this industry get on its feet. And the idea that has been suggested that I would liquidate the industry – of course not. Of course not.

PRESIDENT OBAMA: Let’s check the record.

But this time, Candy Crowley didn’t come to Obama’s rescue by butchering the record. The record clearly shows Romney is right. And Obama is fibbing.

Payne: Ground Zero, Ohio

Posted by hpayne on October 21, 2012

Columbus, Ohio – A drive across the battleground state of Ohio this weekend revealed a fall political landscape in full bloom – from colorful local races to dark scars of a divisive presidency.

“Lawless for Sheriff” read lawn signs across Pickaway County, Ohio, just south of the Ohio beltway. Of all public offices, Independent Jason Lawless chose sheriff as his goal. He will face a formidable foe in Democrat Robert Radcliffe, the third Radcliffe in line for the sheriff’s occupied by his father and grandfather before him.

Should Jason win his long-shot campaign, Pickaway will be Lawless for the first time.

North and south of Columbus reveal two different Ohios. To the southeast lies coal country where Obama’s anti-global warming fanaticism is decimating mining communities, leaving thousands of unemployed workers across the Ohio Valley from Kentucky and Ohio through West Virginia and south Pennsylvania.

“Obama’s No Jobs Zone” read billboards in this part of the state.

“This has not been Mr. Oil, or Mr. Gas, or Mr. Coal. Talk to the people that are working in those industries,” said an impassioned Romney in the second debate of his visit to an Ohio mine in August. ” I was in coal country. People grabbed my arms and said, ‘Please save my job.’ When the president ran for office, he said if you build a coal plant, you can go ahead, but you’ll go bankrupt.”

This callous disregard for America’s coal workers has played out despite this country’s desperate need for jobs in a slow recovery. Yet a partisan Democratic media largely ignored Romney’s debate comments. Just as it has ignored the tragedy in eastern Ohio.

The Obamadiaa has not ignored Northern Ohio, where Obama’s auto bailout brought a sigh of relief to communities around Chrysler’s massive, sprawling, cornfield-eating Jeep assembly plant outside Toledo (did I say Obama was anti-global warming?). Obama-Biden have basked as saviors here – towing a cheerleading reporters notably silent after Romney’s coal fields visit.

“Romney will raise taxes on the middle class” fibs a giant billboard northeast of Columbus paid for by Obama for America. The sign is fiction – Romney’s plan cuts tax rates by 20 percent on middle class earners and the sign apparently takes its cues from a fringe study that only predicts that Romney will have to raise taxes some day, sometime.

This weekend, the Columbus-Dispatch newspaper endorsed the GOP candidate for president, citing the need for a new sheriff after four years of “economic stagnation” and “record-setting debt.”

Four years ago, the same editorial page eerily predicted the Obama years:

” Illinois Sen. Barack Obama, is a rousing motivational speaker, but his experience and achievements — eight years in the Illinois Legislature and less than four in the U.S. Senate — do not stand comparison with McCain’s,” wrote the Dispatch in 2008. “A resume containing so little evidence of leadership and accomplishment leaves in question Obama’s ability to handle the most responsible and difficult job in the world, especially at a time when the nation faces a combination of problems so large and complex that they would challenge even the most seasoned leader. Nor does it seem likely that a man who has traveled in the left lane of American politics for his entire adult life really is the bipartisan centrist that he claims to be.”

Prescient words indeed. The Buckeye State reflects Obama in full. A master politician with both eyes on the next election, he strategically bailed out Big Auto in order to secure the Big Labor strongholds of southern Michigan and northern Ohio. But this inexperienced and deeply ideological manager has ruined working-class lives in eastern Ohio and beyond, leaving Americans unemployed and deeply divided.

America isn’t lawless, it’s leaderless.

 

Payne: Iacocca for Mitt (and Barack)

Posted by hpayne on October 18, 2012

“America needs a turnaround,” announced former Chrysler turnaround artist and celebrity executive Lee Iacocca Thursday. ” Our people are hurting. . . and we just aren’t doing the things that would get our country back on the right track.” In short, Obama’s policies have failed and the country needs competent management, says Romney’s fellow businessman.

But in fairness to Obama, it should be noted that Iacocca himself once endorsed two cornerstones of the Obama formula: auto bailouts and creating a new green economy.

Though critical of its details, Iacocca has praised the White House’s political, Chapter 363 restructuring of the automakers. More significantly, Iacocca has long been an advocate of government-subsidized efforts to electrify America’s vehicle fleet – an effort that has proved a spectacular boondoggle as government -backed battery-makers like A123 Systems have gone bankrupt.

The founder of Lido Motors ten years ago, Iacocca was an early advocate of so-called NEVs, neighborhood electric vehicles, that in 2009 won a $2500 federal tax credit for buyers via Obama’s stimulus blowout. NEVs are one of the clever loopholes that automakers have carved out to help them meet Democrats’ onerous MPG standards.

What’s more, Iacocca has been a strong advocate for pure electric cars like Nissan’s electric Leaf – which receive a $7500 federal tax credit – saying “there’s going to be a scramble for the pure electric car.” Struggling A123, however, is a poster child for an electric market that has failed to materialize as the Leaf and other electrics have seen sales sour.

Auto icon Iacocca’s endorsement gives a powerful jolt to a Romney campaign that Obama has tried to caricature as anti-auto for opposing the UAW bailout. But Iacocca is also a reminder that plenty of CEOs swallowed Obama’s fairy tale vision of a new Green economy.

 

Payne: Obama’s ‘doubled fuel efficiency’ con

Posted by hpayne on October 17, 2012

In the second presidential debate, President Obama & Media touted his MPG mandates as evidence of his commitment to energy independence. “That’s why we doubled fuel efficiency standards on cars,” said Obama at the Hofstra town hall. “That means that in the middle of the next decade, any car you buy, you’re going to end up going twice as far on a gallon of gas.”

“This is true,” cheered The Washington Post. No, it’s not.

It is, in fact, evidence of the false promise of government regulation. Never mind the “doubling” of fuel economy to 54.5 mpg by 2025, cars won’t come close to increasing fuel economy by 30 percent to 35.5 mpg (from the current, random, 27.5 mpg federal standard ) that Obama has mandated just three years from now.

That’s because, in Obama World (coming soon to a health care system near you) standards are meant to gamed by lobbyists with deep pockets.

35.5-by-2016? Ha. The average MPG of vehicles sold this September is a mere 23.2 MPG according to industry analyst TrueCar. That’s because, even with gas approaching $4 a gallon, fuel efficiency isn’t the only reason buyers purchase cars. So, to square market realities with Obama World, the president hands out expensive loopholes to corporate lobbyists.

Take the ethanol loophole.

Few fuel their cars with ethanol because it has never made economic sense. At $3.45 a gallon today, for example, ethanol – which goes 30 percent fewer miles than does a gallon of gas – can’t compete when $3.82 gas is just 11 percent more expensive (do the math).

And yet automakers in the U.S. market continue to make – and publicize – “flex-fuel vehicles” that can run on both gas and ethanol. Why?

Because “in calculating mileage numbers to meet the federal government’s fuel economy standards, automakers are allowed to use the average of the gasoline mileage and the (ethanol) mileage for flex fuel vehicles. But the E85 number is multiplied by seven to reward them for producing vehicles capable of using the alternative fuel,” explains The Detroit News.

Multiplied by seven.

That random number, bought by auto lobbyists, helps automakers (along with more credits gained from electric cars, and natural gas cars, and different air conditioning fluids, and “placing louvers on car grilles to improve aerodynamics,” and we’re not making any of this up) meet President Obama’s equally random 30 percent fuel economy increase by 2016. Or the “doubling” of fuel economy by 2025.

These are fictional numbers set by bureaucrats and manipulated by lobbyist dollars. They are a con. They exist only in Obama World. And in presidential debates where a president and his media willfully mislead the American people into voting for more and more expensive regulations that drive up the price of their cars even as they don’t deliver the benefits claimed.

Payne: It’s the economy, Mr. President

Posted by hpayne on October 16, 2012

When the first two questions of a town hall debate come from a young voter worried he won’t have a job when he graduates and a gentleman who worries why gas prices have more than doubled in four years, it’s going to be a tough night for the incumbent. And these were New York voters.

President Barack Obama was back to his old feisty self Tuesday night – but the dynamics of this race fundamentally changed waaaay back with the first debate. As valiantly as Obama fought to bring the debate back to his themes of class warfare and Romney’s wealth, the voters aren’t interested. Those voters were the questioners in the Hofstra University town hall and none of them asked about Romney’s tax returns.

They had one collective concern: It’s the economy, stupid.

As long as the media controlled the airwaves, Obama’s themes dominated the discussion. Now that Romney had direct access to voters via TV debates, Obama’s envy issues seem small compared o the big themes of unemployment, economic growth, and energy prices that Romney is about.

Just when you could hear the Democratic base cheering Obama’s haymakers, the Michigan native would stand up the incumbent with one his own.

The toe-to-toe confrontation on drilling was great theater – and devastating to President Glib. “How much did you cut licenses and permits on federal land and federal waters?” demanded Romney, wheeling on a suddenly stammering Obama who looked stunned that someone would challenge his audacious fib that he is a champion of carbon fuels.

“The proof of whether a strategy is working or not is what the price is that you’re paying at the pump,” Romney continued to push. “When the president took office, the price of gasoline here in Nassau County was about a buck eighty-six a gallon. Now it’s four bucks a gallon.”

Ouch.

Romney even sounded more empathetic as he talked of visiting coal miners under siege from Obama’s War on Coal. “I was just at a coal facility where some 1,200 people lost their jobs,” said Romney, airing the pain of Eastern Ohio and West Virginia that the MSM has been covering up. ” I don’t think anyone really believes that you’re a person who’s going to be pushing for oil and gas and coal.”

Time and again, Romney met more Obama promises for the next four years by bringing the discussion back to the last four years.

“I think you know better,” said Romney. ” I think you know that these last four years haven’t been so good as the president just described and that you don’t feel like you’re confident that the next four years are going to be much better either. He said that by now we’d have unemployment at 5.4 percent. He said that by now middle-income families would have a reduction in their health insurance premiums by $2,500 a year. It’s gone up by 2,500 (dollars) a year. There are. . . one out of six people in poverty. When he took office, 32 million people were on food stamps; today 47 million people are on food stamps. How about the growth of the economy? It’s growing more slowly this year than last year and more slowly last year than the year before.”

After the debate, I was on a TV panel with two Democrats who wanted to talk about how stiff Romney looked. About how uncomfortable he looked. But what’s uncomfortable is the numbers Romney cited.

 

Payne: Media’s fact-free auto fact check

Posted by hpayne on October 16, 2012

AP’s Debate Fact Checker gets its facts wrong Tuesday night on the auto bailout.

ROMNEY: “I know he keeps saying, ‘You want to take Detroit bankrupt.’ Well, the president took Detroit bankrupt. You took General Motors bankrupt. You took Chrysler bankrupt. So when you say that I wanted to take the auto industry bankrupt, you actually did. And I think it’s important to know that that was a process that was necessary to get those companies back on their feet, so they could start hiring more people. That was precisely what I recommended and ultimately what happened.”

THE FACTS: What Romney recommended did not happen, and his proposed path probably would have forced General Motors and Chrysler out of business. He opposed using government money to bail out the automakers, instead favoring privately financed bankruptcy restructuring. But the automakers were bleeding cash and were poor credit risks. The banking system was in crisis. So private loans weren’t available. Without government aid, both companies probably would have gone under and their assets sold in pieces.

AP is editorializing. Its facts are in error.

Romney is correct that “the president took Detroit bankrupt.” The administration took both GM and Chrysler into Chapter 363 bankruptcy, a politicized bankruptcy criticized as “end-running the legal process” by at least one prominent legal expert – in order to benefit Big Labor special interests at the expense of bondholders, teacher and firefighter pensions, Delphi salaried employees, and so on. Under Romney’s proposed Chapter 11, the companies and creditors would have gone into Chapter 11 bankruptcy court – but, in a crucial point ignored by AP, with federal financial help in order to secure supply chains and jobs.

AP’s claim that Romney’s “proposed path probably would have forced General Motors and Chrysler out of business” is not only contradicted by repeated statements by the candidate – but also by many industry experts.

“Without government aid, both companies probably would have gone under and their assets sold in pieces,” writes AP, getting its facts wrong about what Romney proposed.

“The federal government should provide guarantees for post-bankruptcy financing and assure car buyers that their warranties are not at risk,” wrote Romney in the 2008 New York Times op-ed that Obama & AP caricature as a call for Detroit to die. Furthermore, in numerous queries by this reporter, Romney has consistently hewed to a flexible line, saying that the federal government would have done what was necessary to keep GM and Chrysler – and its suppliers – alive while they worked through bankruptcy.

“I would never have allowed the auto industry to disappear,” the GOP candidate said in an interview with The Detroit News editorial board in February. He added that – at a time when capital markets were frozen – “if government financing was needed, fine. In a managed bankruptcy process, government could have provided guarantees, financing, and DIP financing.”

So much for AP’s fact checkers. Romney’s nuanced position has made him no friends on the libertarian Right. Fair enough. But AP’s caricature of Romney as a Darwinian advocate of bankruptcy is bad journalism.

 

Payne: Romney’s Snyder tax reform model

Posted by hpayne on October 15, 2012

With the presidential debates forcing the Democratic Chorus off its Obama-led character assassination-of-Romney theme and into actual public policy issues, the tune has changed. From Obama spokesmen to Detroit Free Press writers to ABC’s Martha Raddatz to Saturday Night Live, the new Democratic line is: Which loopholes would the Romney-Ryan tax plan close?

The question is a strategy meant to detour the GOP campaign from broad economic themes into the special interest weeds (like the Big Bird flap on the “what programs would you cut?” question). In truth, the tax code is a Swiss cheese of loopholes for powerful lobbies – which is precisely why the code needs to be streamlined and why any credible candidate – Republican of Democrat – leaves the details for the bargaining table.

Take Romney’s tax-reforming political twin, Michigan Governor Rick Snyder.

Like Romney, Snyder is a private equity, business turnaround specialist who made tax and spending reform his primary goals as a candidate in 2010. But in his “10-point plan to reinvent Michigan,” the tax reform details were limited to this:

“Point #2 Reform Michigan’s Tax System. Rick believes that we need to reduce the tax burden on families and businesses in Michigan. Rather than advocate for short-term solutions ” Rick wants to reform Michigan’s tax system so that it is competitive, simple, fair, transparent, efficient and facilitates economic growth.”

That’s all, folks.

On the campaign trail, he stuck to the broad outline, eschewing specifics save that he wanted to eliminate the Michigan Business Tax and replace it with a flat corporate income tax (Romney has also specified that he would like to eliminate the dividend tax and cut income rates by 20 percent) while closing tax loopholes (a mirror of Romney).

Upon entering office, One Tough Nerd followed through on his tax reform promise – and also brought specifics to the Legislature. It’s easy to see why he didn’t provide those details in the campaign. Tax loopholes, after all, come with very large special interest constituencies.

As governor, Snyder proposed a simplified tax structure of a 6 percent corporate tax and a reduction to 4.25 individual income tax. To maintain revenue neutrality, he eliminated tax credits like Big Hollywood’s 42 percent film subsidy and introduced a new tax on pensions (Michigan being one of the few states that had exempted pensions from taxation).

The elimination of tax goodies caused a storm of protest from the lobbies that had protected them: seniors, the film industry, and so on. Snyder fought each battle and eventually won most of what he wanted from the Legislature. But had Snyder proposed these details during the campaign, his candidacy would have been derailed into putting out special interest brush fires. It’s the same reason that Romney won’t let Obama & Media distract his tax proposal.

Campaigns are for broad themes. Governing is for the details.

Payne: Uplander, Michigan Power Couple

Posted by hpayne on October 14, 2012

The big story out of Tigertown this weekend is that the Orange & Black have a 2-0 game lead over the Yankee Evil Empire.

The second biggest story is that Tigers’ Ace Justin Verlander and St. Joseph-born super model Kate Upton are officially Michigan’s First Celebrity Power Couple.

The long-rumored pair are an item, their proud grandparents confirmed over the weekend. “[Kate] was at his first game in Detroit against Oakland,” Curvy Kate’s grandfather, Stephen, told Celebuzz, an Internet gossip website. “She has all of our support.”

“I heard he has been on dates with a Sports Illustrated girl. I saw a photo – she’s beautiful,” added Richard Verlander, Sr. “They make a good-looking pair because he’s a good-looking man, too. Justin is a fine boy, and whoever he ends up with is lucky. He’s not only a great baseball player – he’s a great guy.”

Seems the Yanks are not only coming in second to the Tigers on the playing field – but also when playing the female field. Once celebrity dating partner for the likes of Kate Hudson, Madonna, and Cameron Diaz, Alex Rodriguez is now dating ex- wrestling diva, Torrie Wilson. Torrie who?

And perpetual playboy Derek Jeter? He was last seen with a Ralph Lauren model named Hannah Davis – after being dumped by actress Minka Kelly.

Uncle Fred Upton has the powerful House Energy and Commerce Committee in DC. And now his niece, Kate, is on the powerful right arm of the Great Verlander. Move over Brangelina. . .

Hello Uplander.

Payne: Joe Jerk

Posted by hpayne on October 11, 2012

If the vice presidential debate had been a prize fight it would have been called after two rounds.

In opening the debate on Libya, moderator Martha Raddatz of ABC put front and center the explosive, unfolding, misleading administration response to the 9-11 terrorist attack on our Libyan embassy. That failure not only plays to a Republican strength, defense, but also forced Pinocchio Biden into fibbing about the Libyan ambassador’s rejected call for security – and the White House’s false claim that the attack was the result of a YouTube video. Ryan only had to note the obvious: “This was the anniversary of 9-11 and they did not give our ambassador a Marine attachment?”

That foreign policy incompetence was then bookended by Question #2: Why isn’t unemployment under 6 percent as the president had promised?

Game. Set. Match. And we were just 32 minutes in. But this being television, it’s in demeanor where Joe Blow really blew it.

The rest of the debate was a Biden clinic on how to be a jerk. Sneering, laughing, smirking, and interrupting, interrupting, interrupting – 82 times by one count – Biden lived up to the caricature of the unlikeable uncle at the Thanksgiving dinner table annoyed by his young, successful nephew.

“That’s a bunch of malarkey,” snarled Uncle Joe. “This is a bunch of stuff,” he huffed. “These guys bet against America all the time,” he demagogued. These dismissive huffs interspersed with rote references to “the wealthy” and “the super wealthy.”

Through this blather, Ryan remained composed, witty, bipartisan – and loaded with facts.

“Sometimes the words just don’t come out of your mouth the right way,” he said as Biden walked right into the trap of mentioning Romney’s admitted 47 percent gaffe. It was a Lloyd Benson “I knew Jack Kennedy” moment and it both disarmed Obama’s #2 and also humanized the smiling Ryan.

All this just 40 minutes into the debate. The rest was gravy with Ryan pressing on Obama’s $90 billion in “green pork,” violations of the Catholic Church’s First Amendment rights, and even a touching moment about naming his son “Bean” on a Raddatz question about abortion. All delivered with a confident smile and respect for his opponent.

Biden was the Grinch to the end – a fitting partner to a president whose disrespect for bipartisanship and divisive, thuggish campaign tactics have grown tiresome. The Ryan performance built on the first debate of a Romney-Ryan team – the CEO and the COO – that is serious about this country’s problems. Obama-Biden are just pols.

Payne: Debbie Debateitnot

Posted by hpayne on October 11, 2012

Think of how Romney-Obama presidential race turned around with one debate and now imagine that the Hoekstra-Stabenow race will have no debates at all. The stunning development today is a devastating blow to the Hoekstra campaign in what may have been his last chance to turn around a flagging campaign.

The Hoekstra camp is understandably frustrated that Stabenow stubbornly refused more debates ” or even to give network coverage to the two debates they could agree on. Meanwhile, other Senate races in Massachusetts, Ohio, and Florida are all engaged in vigorous TV debates.

But in the end, Hoekstra is the challenger that needs debate oxygen – not Stabenow.

The debate debacle is the latest setback in a bumbling Senate campaign that began with PeteSpendItNot tripping out of the blocks with a bomb of a Super Bowl ad. Since then he has failed to gain the traction or the money that he expected when he was reluctantly drafted into a key Senate race if Republicans have any hope of retaking the Senate (and exorcising Obamacare). He has also received little support from Romney who has concentrated on Ohio at Michigan’s expense.

Like Romney, Hoekstra has had to fight both an incumbent and a partisan press in Michigan that has given him little airtime – except to hammer him for his China ad gaffe. Thus the imperative of a debate – Hoekstra’s lone chance to talk directly to Michigan voters.

In a phone press conference Thursday after Stabenow pulled out of debate negotiations, Hoekstra lamented Senator Debbie’s refusal to agree to primetime, network TV. Instead, Stabenow insisted that a Detroit Athletic Club debate not get any coverage – and that a Grand Rapids rumble be relegated to public television.

“It doesn’t do a whole lot of good (to debate) if no one can see it,” lamented Hoekstra when asked if it is worth doing debates with little TV exposure.

He has a point, of course. Imagine if Romney and Obama had debated in Denver. . .with no TV.

It is hard to defeat a Democratic incumbent & Media without the boob tube (as painful as that is to admit as a newspaper guy). Print coverage won’t cut it. And ultimately, the fact that Michigan isn’t having the same TV debates as other states is an embarrassment.

“Michigan needs an independent debate entity,” says GOP consultant Paul Welday. Just like Massachusetts. Just like the presidential race.

Shame on Debbie Stabenow for refusing Michigan voters the chance to compare her and her challenger. And shame on Michigan’s MSM for not calling her on it. But in the end, this is Hoekstra’s problem. He needs debates to get into this race. He isn’t in a position to negotiate. Even if she proposes a debate in a closet, he’s gotta go.

Payne: Leno jokes, Detroit whines

Posted by hpayne on October 10, 2012

They say Detroit’s a tough town. So why is its skin so thin?

Jay Leno cracked a Detroit funny in his Monday monologue and Detroit leaders predictably became unhinged. “Well the police chief of Detroit was suspended after a female police officer said she had sex with him in exchange for a promotion,” Leno said. “And of course people are stunned: Detroit has a police department?”

Good, satirical stuff about America’s most dysfunctional city. But not to Thin-Skin-in-Chief Dan Gilbert who erupted at a public event Tuesday. “What can we do about people destroying the reputation of our city, locally and nationally?” said Quicken CEO Gilbert.

Memo to Gilbert: Detroit destroyed its own reputation with sky high crime, looming bankruptcy, and City Council clowns.

Leno is no LeBron James. He’s not a Gilbert employee and he certainly reflects the prevailing national view of the city. As Gilbert knows, Detroit has an image problem which is precisely why he is boldly spearheading downtown efforts to make Detroit a welcoming place again.

“We need to get Jay Leno here,” Gilbert continued. “I guess it’s a good thing that his ratings suck.”

Actually, they don’t. Leno is THE top-rated late night talk show. And when Detroit moves up in the ratings among America’s cites, it will stop being the butt of Leno jokes. Just like the improving Detroit Lions. When’s the last time you heard Leno joke about them? Exactly.

 

Payne: Kid Ryan, Union Joe

Posted by hpayne on October 9, 2012

Joe Biden has come to Detroit twice this campaign – both times to pay homage to the public school establishment. By contrast, when Paul Ryan came to town Monday night, he swing by the private, non-union Cornerstone Schools – an innovator in school choice for inner city Detroit children.

The Mainstream Media likes to paint the Romney-Ryan ticket as out-of-touch with regular folks – but the evidence on the ground contradicts the narrative.

When it comes to advancing Detroit’s schoolchildren, Ryan embraces innovation and reform – while Biden walks right by it to embrace party special interests.

Never mind that Cornerstone graduates 95 percent of its kids, while Detroit public schools squeeze out just 62 percent. Never mind that innovative charter and private schools give inner city, often minority, parents the same school choice that wealthier suburbanites enjoy. Never mind that a high school diploma and college placement is a gateway out of poverty.

Kid Rock introduced Ryan at an Oakland County campaign rally hours after Ryan’s Cornerstone visit. “Born Free” is Kid Rock’s anthem – and “Free to Choose” is Kid Ryan’s education theme. Democrats? They march to the union drummer.

Payne: Godbee, Clinton, and The War on Women

Posted by hpayne on October 8, 2012

This week Democratic Mayor Dave Bing pressured Detroit Police Chief Ralph Godbee to step down after the police chief was discoed to be in an unethical affair with a subordinate. This, just one month after Bing’s Democratic Party celebrated its commitment to women by inviting ex-President Bill Clinton – who famously had sexual relations with White House intern Monica Lewinsky – as its Charlotte convention keynote speaker.

How to resolve the glaring hypocrisy of these two affairs?

Politics. SImply put, Godbeee (and Bing) are not in jeopardy of losing their jobs to Republicans. But Bill Clinton was – and thus the entire Democratic Party abandoned principle in order to engage in an extraordinary War on Women in order to preserve a man as president.

Lewinsky was belittled as psychologically unbalanced. As a liar. A groupie. Only when she revealed that she had kept a semen-stained dress did the president of the United States admit he had lies about their affair. Then, the story changed. Then the MSM allowed that his unethical sex with a subordinate was “his private life.” Feminist icon Gloria Steinem famously wrote that Clinton deserved “one free grope” in a New York Times op-ed. Other victims – Paul Jones, Kathleen Willey – claimed sexual harassment. One Juanita Broaddrick claimed rape. The press ignored Broaddrick. Jones’ suit was settled for $850,000.

And Democrats have the nerve to declare themselves the Party of Women.

Godbee joins dozens of other executives – including Detroit Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick and two newspapermen that I knew of during the Clinton scandal – who have been dismissed for improper executive conduct with subordinates because its is not their private life. It is Management 101.